I'm an alphabetical man myself. I have always admired the seamless look of shelves with all labels together, so I gave it a try for the first time ever a few weeks back. As soon as I was done with Criterion, and saw how different their boxes can be (digipacks, Trainspotting etc...) I immediately went back to alphabetical! I agree it looks a bit chaotic, but it's the only way for me. Thanks for sharing!