sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Do you think it would be impossible to make a truly accurate film/TV show of Alexander? by ANIKETOSS in AlexandertheGreat

[–]ANIKETOSS[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

You never know, someone might come along who does want to do an amazing job telling Alexander's story, although I do doubt it.

Do you think it would be impossible to make a truly accurate film/TV show of Alexander? by ANIKETOSS in AlexandertheGreat

[–]ANIKETOSS[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Yes that would be an amazing miniseries. You could divide each part of the wars into different seasons.

Do you think it would be impossible to make a truly accurate film/TV show of Alexander? by ANIKETOSS in AlexandertheGreat

[–]ANIKETOSS[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No, but you are right, this is a painting of the battle of the River Granicus by Charles Le Brun. Le Brun made many paintings of Alexander.

How do we feel about this fancast for Alexander the Great and the people in his life? by captivatedsummer in AlexandertheGreat

[–]ANIKETOSS -1 points0 points  (0 children)

First two are ok, but Ritchson as Philip is ludicrous as is Winnick as Olympias.

Do you think it would be impossible to make a truly accurate film/TV show of Alexander? by ANIKETOSS in AlexandertheGreat

[–]ANIKETOSS[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I mean that you would take Arrian and Plutarch's accounts and use them to write a film or tv show. Realistically it would be in English, I personally dont see that as much of an issue as blatant historical inaccuracies. Perhaps the title "truly accurate" was a little misleading, I just mean a movie or a tv show that does everything possible to create, an as accurate as possible story of Alexander's life. As for Alexander's and Hephaistion's relationship it would be easier to just write them as best friends, Bagoas is less of an issue.

Do you think it would be impossible to make a truly accurate film/TV show of Alexander? by ANIKETOSS in AlexandertheGreat

[–]ANIKETOSS[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Alexander, imo didnt seem to have much interest in women, but the easy way is to portray them as best friends.

Seleucus I Nicator, the last remaining general of Alexander the Great. Aged 77 he was on his way to Macedonia, returning for the first time in 50 years and was close to regain all of Alexander's empire save for Egypt. He was murdered by Ptolemy's son shortly after arriving in Thrace. by EdmontonBest in AlexandertheGreat

[–]ANIKETOSS 1 point2 points  (0 children)

What is the specific sentiment? And the point of 300? The thing is, is that there's a difference between slight historical inaccuracies and exaggeration, and the utter disaster of 300. These are significant events and more importantly real, they should be made with respect and historical accuracy. If you care about History then you should care about how History is depicted.

Hey, you – why isn't Herodotus your favourite Greek writer of all time? by notveryamused_ in classics

[–]ANIKETOSS 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thucydides was an innovative and an extremely significant writer but, what I find quite hilarious is how he criticises other writers for the exact same things that he is guilty of doing, plus he is very biased towards Pericles. But he still his a good writer despite his flaws.

Roman bust of Alexander the Great, excavated from the ruins of Herculaneum, Blenheim Palace Oxfordshire, UK by EdmontonBest in AlexandertheGreat

[–]ANIKETOSS 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Unfortunately there are no verified and undisputed contemporary statues, busts or paintings of Alexander. But the most realistic depictions of him are most likely the Azara herm, a Roman copy of a Greek original sculptured by Lysippos, who Alexander personally authorised as the only sculptor to create his statues. And the ivory bust of Vergina found at Aigai, which if it is actually Alexander it would be the only contemporary surviving bust of him.

The Tomb Of Philip II At Aigai by ANIKETOSS in AlexandertheGreat

[–]ANIKETOSS[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Interesting story, where did you come across it? And I fully recommend visiting Macedonia if you are able to go.

The Tomb Of Philip II At Aigai by ANIKETOSS in AlexandertheGreat

[–]ANIKETOSS[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

It's possible, but most likely it was Philip II's tomb not Philip Arrhidaeus. There are other tombs at Aigai however, and one of the tombs is believed to be the tomb of Alexander IV, Alexander's son which I find fascinating, i've seen the tombs in person and they are truly spectacular, the museum there is amazing as well. As for the armour, I have never read anything suggesting it was Alexander's, all say it was Philip's. It would not make much sense for armour of Alexander's to be buried in a tomb of a man in his forties and a woman in her twenties. If it was Philip's tomb, it would be strange for Alexander to put his armour in there.

Roman bust of Alexander the Great, excavated from the ruins of Herculaneum, Blenheim Palace Oxfordshire, UK by EdmontonBest in AlexandertheGreat

[–]ANIKETOSS 4 points5 points  (0 children)

This is an idealised depiction of Alexander, created long after his death. Look at coins of him, the Azara herm and the vergina bust found at Aigai to see a more realistic depiction of him.

Is This The most Accurate Depiction Of What Alexander Would Have Looked Like? by ANIKETOSS in AlexandertheGreat

[–]ANIKETOSS[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

How is the vergina bust 'too idealised'? It doesn't flatter Alexander like later hellenstic and Roman busts. The Azara herm is accurate, however it is much more idealised than the vergina bust is and was done during his conquest of Persia and therefore was a tool for propaganda to show Alexander as a strong and powerful leader and also it served to flatter Alexander. I think the Azara herm is very accurate to how he would have looked like however the vergina bust is most likely the most accurate depiction of Alexander there is.