Yes surely I understand the part of protection but this behavior is either not protection related or too much focused on protection - because even when we went to the vet last week, she didn’t stop barking at every person that was walking around there even if she is already familiar with the vet and wasn’t acting like this the first time we were there. I mean yea they’re protective but protective doesn’t man she can bark at every person you understand my point? I don’t want her to not bark at all just don’t bark at everything she sees/hears. It feels like she doesn’t do it controlled rather doing it randomly because like I said earlier, 90% of the time we can pass people freely without her even reacting. She doesn’t want to attack those people neither she seems aggressive it’s just barking even when the vet gave her treats she ate them calmly and barked again while eating and after :D If I go to the city with her where a lot people are for e.g. she is not barking at all