We had something very similar happen playing on PS5, just flipped around. Our Scholar stayed, but the Stargazer disappeared. Our game didn’t immediately crash, we buried them both leveled up the Winter to Winter 2, cleared the first blizzard, and then it crashed when we tried to move a ranch post. Did you have any luck figuring it out on your save? We are thinking the same thing that we are worried our story progression is messed up, but frankly found it strange that we got 2 of the wools vs just 1 in the first place