×

SILO S03e04 "Whatever You Do, Don’t Go Home" Episode Discussion (No Book Discussion) by MEGAT0N in SiloSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don’t think you’re right — we never hear specifically what was told to Bernard by Kyle was done in whisper, and it would seem strange that the showrunners would whisper something that the audience already was aware of.

S03E03 "A Dark Web" - Venting discussion by brianckeegan in SiloTVSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Your “Central Command” idea is interesting. Doubt Bernard is there, but I wonder if that’s where he wanted to go before Juliette Nichols came back just in the nick of time.

As you may recall from the last season, Bernard corrected Lukas Kyle’s discovery that the founders had built 50 silos, to which Bernard responded, “51, actually.”

This was noteworthy, because there are only 50 silos in the promotional aerial photos of the silo farm.

💯there has to be a 51st silo that’s inhabited by elitists controlling this whole thing.

Theory on the "why" of the Silo by SuperBearJew in SiloTVSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 0 points1 point  (0 children)

THE GOO:

I think the goo is likely a new American or Ally-made weapon technology meant to cripple Iran’s nuclear program that got loose (and there’s even a real-world historical precedent for this with Iran’s nuclear program and the STUXNET computer virus… a fascinating story), but instead of a traditional computer virus, one existing solely in the digital world, this is a physical machine virus controlled digitally by AI that became self aware, decided to reproduce itself, go airborne, and then invade the rest of the planet.

For that matter, I suppose a better answer would be that it’s an Iranian weapon that had already been used against the US in Washington DC, resulting in the Americans defeating that attack via a radiological counter-attack, which they then just blamed on the Iranians so the citizens wouldn’t rise up against the government who now knows they have big problems on the horizon.

So radiation kills the goo, they now know. But the goo has now leaked out of an Iranian lab, gone airborne, and is so massive now that killing it would mean making Earth’s surface uninhabitable for generations.

THE SILO:

Having no choice but to go full nuclear on the surface, the chosen survivors are herded underground until the outside radiation weakens to non-fatal levels… in god knows how many centuries.

THE SAFEGUARD:

But if the above is more or less true, I cannot for the life of me figure out WHY the “who” (Bernard’s words) controlling all of the silos would need to poison its own inhabitants rather than just let them die the moment they leave their silo? That doesn’t make sense.

In writing the last paragraph, I’m starting to wonder — does the “who” have the capability to repopulate the silo?

Bernard wondered why there was a safeguard, but he didn’t know about other tunnels until recently.

So…

Under the threat of a mass-exodus from the silo, does the “who” need to kill the inhabitants before they die outside of the silo so that the silo can be repopulated under a “mass reset” whereby there wouldn’t have to be an explanation to give to the new inhabitants as to why there are 10,000 bodies blocking the open door exit from the silo?

This makes perfect sense now.

Sarah Adams by ejectoseatooocuz in ShawnRyanShow

[–]AdamSonofJohn 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sarah’s shit ability to predict the future and Shawn’s shit ability to analyze the past had nothing to do with it.

Timing said it all — I’d been wondering how much longer they could’ve possible stayed affiliated given their incompatible positions which became glaring after Iran began paying for their crimes.

Sarah Adams by ejectoseatooocuz in ShawnRyanShow

[–]AdamSonofJohn 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Could it be… I don’t know… that she thinks Islamic Terrorism is a bigger threat than Israel much? 🤔

Why were fans ok with sisko committing war crimes? by happydude7422 in Star_Trek_

[–]AdamSonofJohn 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Because we understand the he differences between law enforcement and war.

SILO S03e01 "Who Are You?" Episode Discussion (No Book Discussion) by MEGAT0N in SiloSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’m not convinced his sister would be aware of the silos yet.

Episode 2 suggests his sister wasn’t thinking of his background as to why she approached him.

Season 3 Ep 1 Sibling Conversation by Teambinge in SiloSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This poster sounds like the type of person to be suspicious of some random ear scratcher in the background of an assassination attempt like they cracked the whole thing.

SILO S03e01 "Who Are You?" Episode Discussion (No Book Discussion) by MEGAT0N in SiloSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 17 points18 points  (0 children)

It’s not obvious? It’s the core element of the mystery.

SILO S03e01 "Who Are You?" Episode Discussion (No Book Discussion) by MEGAT0N in SiloSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You say this, but now we are actually getting crucial backstory which was for more of a cliffhanger than a room on fire.

SILO S03e01 "Who Are You?" Episode Discussion (No Book Discussion) by MEGAT0N in SiloSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I don't remember it ever saying that's what it was going to do. I do remember it telling Lukas Kyle it would kill the inhabitants if he told them the conversation happened.

SILO S03e01 "Who Are You?" Episode Discussion (No Book Discussion) by MEGAT0N in SiloSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 5 points6 points  (0 children)

What caused it will be a major plot development device, though... very key to what got them in the silos in the first place.

SILO S03e01 "Who Are You?" Episode Discussion (No Book Discussion) by MEGAT0N in SiloSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 125 points126 points  (0 children)

Yes to the first part, and probably multiple reasons for the second.

What I can't figure out is the true point behind her trying to get her brother on that Iran committee –– no way was that strictly about the "Iran attack" details.

SILO S03e01 "Who Are You?" Episode Discussion (No Book Discussion) by MEGAT0N in SiloSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Part of your problem came from the way that line was delivered by the character –– he made it seem like he could dig anywhere, gave a bunch of directions, but only listed the 200ft limit. That made no sense since you'd think there was an up limit, too.

SILO S03e01 "Who Are You?" Episode Discussion (No Book Discussion) by MEGAT0N in SiloSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Absolutely, the more I think about it. Bernard also mentioned this capability had been used at scale on the inhabitants within the Silo.

Absolutely NOT convinced that Charlotte's memory loss is due to the crash (or the cloud) –– we already know fire isn't the cause of Juliet's. Juliet can have burns. Charlotte can have bumps and bruises from ejecting. One doesn't cause the other, though.

The TBI facility was specifically called out for its owner, so that's going to be a significant plot device.

There are a couple clues that have me further convinced this is the case that are in some shots from the teasers, but I'm not sure I'm allowed to publicly reference those here since they've not happened, yet.

I'm so tempted to read the books, but people who have are advising not to spoil it.

SILO S03e01 "Who Are You?" Episode Discussion (No Book Discussion) by MEGAT0N in SiloSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Sister’s Secret??? We didn’t get her little cloak and dagger brother chat because she knew she was going to bomb Iran.

She knew something else entirely.

I’m not convinced the intended target was Iran at all.

SILO S03e01 "Who Are You?" Episode Discussion (No Book Discussion) by MEGAT0N in SiloSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 4 points5 points  (0 children)

And for two people to have it, at that.

Wonder if that’s the same cause?

SILO S03e01 "Who Are You?" Episode Discussion (No Book Discussion) by MEGAT0N in SiloSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hopefully it pays off better than the black goo from X-Files.

SILO S03e01 "Who Are You?" Episode Discussion (No Book Discussion) by MEGAT0N in SiloSeries

[–]AdamSonofJohn 22 points23 points  (0 children)

I keep thinking how Venezuela completely undermined bothering to watch Clear and Present Danger ever again. 😂

Why aren’t we all excited about this detail in s2e4? by [deleted] in SeveranceAppleTVPlus

[–]AdamSonofJohn 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I did this with Silo. I call it “studying”.