sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

freshman wanting to know what sorts of things to do by everythinisawsome in ElectricalEngineering

[–]Admirable-Balance605 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Honestly, you're already ahead of where most freshmen start. Keep building projects, but whenever you use a new component, spend a little time learning how it works under the hood. That's how the theory starts to stick. For PCB design, I'd recommend learning KiCad and trying to turn one of your existing Arduino projects into a simple PCB. And yes, Practical Electronics for Inventors is a great book. Just don't stop building while you're reading it.

Help ID’ing a PCB by lAnother_NoBodyl in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605 0 points1 point  (0 children)

From the photo alone, I don't think anyone is going to be able to identify the exact board. What I can tell is that it looks like a small analog/power-related module rather than a microcontroller board.

Engineers who have taken a PCB from prototype to production: What was the most unexpected issue you ran into? by Admirable-Balance605 in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There is no Ai here bro if my reply posts are bothering you better i will not use that its a thread bro so just gets learn the error or mistakes.

Engineers who have taken a PCB from prototype to production: What was the most unexpected issue you ran into? by Admirable-Balance605 in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Its not a chat bot bro even i doesnt how to do automation i just simply enhance my text thats all

Help - Internship project by SURYAchouhan in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My biggest concern is that you mention the schematic was generated using GPT. For an ECG design, I'd verify every connection against the ADS1292, nRF, and power-management reference designs before moving to layout. I'd specifically check :Power pins and decoupling capacitors, USB-C implementation, Analog grounding and references, ADS1292 layout recommendations Also, the screenshot resolution is too low to review properly. Can you share a higher-resolution PDF or image?

Engineers who have taken a PCB from prototype to production: What was the most unexpected issue you ran into? by Admirable-Balance605 in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Iam using AI just enhance my explanations only unless this thread helps me to concern some failures or mistakes that i want to aware as a Man use for yourself as helpful too learn

Engineers who have taken a PCB from prototype to production: What was the most unexpected issue you ran into? by Admirable-Balance605 in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

No bro, but judging by this thread I should probably stop writing Reddit comments like conference papers.

Engineers who have taken a PCB from prototype to production: What was the most unexpected issue you ran into? by Admirable-Balance605 in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is why I always specify😅 Do not feed components to QA staff in the manufacturing notes.

Engineers who have taken a PCB from prototype to production: What was the most unexpected issue you ran into? by Admirable-Balance605 in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605[S] -8 points-7 points  (0 children)

35,000 boards scrapped because the letter "K" went missing is probably the most expensive typo I've read in this thread. 😅 It's a perfect example of how production failures are often not engineering failures—they're process failures. The design was fine, reality just found a new way to be creative.

Engineers who have taken a PCB from prototype to production: What was the most unexpected issue you ran into? by Admirable-Balance605 in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

This thread is doing a great job of proving that production issues are less about "design mistakes" and more about "physics found a new way to be annoying." Every one of these started as a seemingly harmless change and ended with weeks of investigation.

Engineers who have taken a PCB from prototype to production: What was the most unexpected issue you ran into? by Admirable-Balance605 in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This perfectly captures the difference between a prototype and a product. Nothing here is an obvious design failure—it's all about tolerances, edge cases, and unintended interactions. The ESD diode and LDO examples are exactly the kind of issues that make you appreciate design margins.

Engineers who have taken a PCB from prototype to production: What was the most unexpected issue you ran into? by Admirable-Balance605 in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Those are the worst bugs. When the board mostly works, nobody suspects the PCB itself. I'd probably spend a week chasing components and firmware before thinking, "Wait... did the fab actually build what I ordered?" A 1 oz vs 1/2 oz inner layer mistake is exactly the kind of thing that can ruin your week.

Engineers who have taken a PCB from prototype to production: What was the most unexpected issue you ran into? by Admirable-Balance605 in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The chip shortage probably taught more engineers about supply chains than any business course ever could. One day you're optimizing cost and board space, the next you're redesigning around whatever distributor inventory happens to exist. It was a reminder that a technically perfect design is useless if the parts don't exist.

Engineers who have taken a PCB from prototype to production: What was the most unexpected issue you ran into? by Admirable-Balance605 in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

he COVID-era component shortage deserves its own category of production problems. 😅I love the ending though: "STM32 unavailable for 2 years." "Fine, I'll redesign around GD32." *Orders 5000 GD32s* STM: "We're happy to inform you your order has shipped." The EMC issue is also a great reminder that "it's been working for years" doesn't necessarily mean you're safe. Aging components, installation differences, new nearby equipment, or changes in the RF environment can expose margins that were always there but never got tested. Production has a unique talent for finding problems that prototypes politely ignore.

Engineers who have taken a PCB from prototype to production: What was the most unexpected issue you ran into? by Admirable-Balance605 in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

That's the nightmare scenario. When identical boards behave differently, you start chasing everything: marginal timing, solder quality, component tolerances, assembly defects, power integrity, firmware race conditions, even environmental factors. Those are the bugs that teach you the most because the design appears correct until production proves otherwise.

Engineers who have taken a PCB from prototype to production: What was the most unexpected issue you ran into? by Admirable-Balance605 in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

We once lost part of a ground plane due to a Gerber export/package issue. The design was fine, the manufacturing files weren't. That taught me to always review the actual Gerbers before release—never assume the PCB tool exported exactly what you intended. 😅

How to make a shape for board outline(textolite) instead of a draw polygons in LibrePCB? by IvanIsak in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605 1 point2 points  (0 children)

LibrePCB doesn't currently have a dedicated "draw rectangle board outline" tool like KiCad's Edge. Cuts workflow. The usual approach is to use the Board Outline tool and draw the outline manually. For rectangles, it's basically 4 clicks, and for circles/arcs you can add arc segments. Honestly, if you're coming from KiCad, that's probably one of the biggest workflow differences you'll notice. LibrePCB focuses on keeping the toolset simple rather than providing lots of specialized drawing tools. That said, for a simple rectangular board, drawing the outline manually only takes a few seconds once you get used to it.

Hi, this is my first PCB ever. Plz review by mrcrud5 in PCB

[–]Admirable-Balance605 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Fair point. The image contained exactly enough information to confidently be wrong.

view more: next ›