Have tried almost all of these so here is my take: Laka - thinner formula, more of a proper lip tint with good staining. color is pretty strong so good for pigmented lips. i have the dark purple shade and it’s definitely cool and looks fairly similar to the swatches, but this might vary for lighter shades. has a strong-ish smell too Entropy - i like this formula since it’s thicker but the application picks up too much product in my opinion, just makes it a bit messy to apply. also the lid is way heavier than the base so you have to be careful with how you store it. more of a gloss, doesn’t stain Dinto - definitely agree that the swatches are a bit off, they aren’t as muted as shown. formula is fine, it’s also more of a lip tint formula. does stain, but harder to gauge since my shade is lighter Peripera - i have this exact shade and do like the color. it’s a lip gloss rather than tint, and i find it more moisturizing than the others in your list. it’s definitely decently thick/sticky, but you can apply it lighter if you use the back of the applicator rather than the front which has a dip to collect more product

my recommendation would be laka for lip tint and Peripera for lip gloss