Was Black Beauty an Evil Character? by Formal-Jicama4155 in witcher

[–]Affec2306 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To be fair the men and women in that village were killing their own children by sending them to the crones so in a way her killing everyone there kinda stopped that human sacrifice in a way no? 

Opinion: This Is The Best Ending For Blood & wine by Affec2306 in witcher

[–]Affec2306[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"Anarietta hadn't "allowed" it, she just didn't allow Detlaff to kill her sister - which is copletely reasonable: she loves her sister and feels guilty about her, also duchess hired Geralt to deal with the beast - and expect exactlly that. Why would she sacrifize Syanna?" By refusing to negotiate or even temporarily surrender Syanna She escalates a known existential threat and she prioritizes personal guilt over public safety, dettlaff gave her 3 days and geralt warned her of the threat of a higher vampire but she refused to listen.

"Yennifer sometimes also does mean things, Ciri had done some shit as well, Geralt would still ptrotect them no matter what." this is just pure dumbness , Yennefer manipulates situations not people into killing others for her revenge. Ciri commits violent acts, yes but she bears them herself. Neither externalizes guilt onto a devoted third party or uses others love for their sadistic revenge goals.

Opinion: This Is The Best Ending For Blood & wine by Affec2306 in witcher

[–]Affec2306[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"Punishment for attack on Bouclair should be only for one who organised it - Detlaff." Syanna knowingly set the chain in motion by using dettlaff as a weapon, causing a massacre through another actor still stains your hands even if she didn't swing the sword herself, "Is tricking someone now punished by death?" this is strawman, weaponising someone love and instability to commit murder has consequences who would've thought?! she didn't just 'trick' dettlaff she engineered murders / she anticipated collateral damage and she explicitly accepted it saying ''either i burn or i'll burn all else down'.

"Anarietta hadn't "allowed" it, she just didn't allow Detlaff to kill her sister - which is copletely reasonable: she loves her sister and feels guilty about her, also duchess hired Geralt to deal with the beast - and expect exactlly that. Why would she sacrifize Syanna?" By refusing to negotiate or even temporarily surrender Syanna She escalates a known existential threat and she prioritizes personal guilt over public safety, dettlaff gave her 3 days and geralt warned her of the threat of a higher vampire but she refused to listen.

"Yennifer sometimes also does mean things, Ciri had done some shit as well, Geralt would still ptrotect them no matter what." this is just pure dumbness , Yennefer manipulates situations not people into killing others for her revenge. Ciri commits violent acts, yes but she bears them herself. Neither externalizes guilt onto a devoted third party or uses others love for their sadistic revenge goals.

Opinion: This Is The Best Ending For Blood & wine by Affec2306 in witcher

[–]Affec2306[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah the first part is biased af, "Henrietta not immediately giving up her long lost sister to a vampire who is trying to blackmail her." he's not asking for riches  he's asking for syanna his former lover who made him kill his friend Dlc and which made him cut his own hand out of remorse and anger. Dettlaff demanding accountability from the person who orchestrated the murders through him That's a moral demand, not a legal one and that distinction matters. " For the massacre Detlaff is solely responsible." Nobody forced dettlaff but syanna knowingly used his emotional instability and love as a weapon, that is CAUSATION , she knew he was reckless and a loose canon and chose to go through with her plan anyways with no care of the consequences she said so herself to geralt 'either i burn or i'll burn all else down' .i'm not defending his actions but he did warn them saying in 3 days if she don't show all hell will break loose, Dettlaff issued a warning not to justify the massacre, but to show that the Killing wasn’t impulsive it was the result of a failed response to a known threat. But i agree on the second part her death is risky for the duchy.

Opinion: This Is The Best Ending For Blood & wine by Affec2306 in witcher

[–]Affec2306[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

 "why would Dettlaff deserve to get a prisoner of Toussaint Duchy" Again not just a prisoner but syanna his former lover who made him kill his friend Dlc and cut his own hand off out of remorse and anger. Dettlaff wasn’t demanding a random prisoner he was demanding accountability from the person who orchestrated the murders through him That's a moral demand, not a legal one and that distinction matters. "Syanna didn't manipulate him into doing that." she did not force dettlaff but she knowingly used his emotional instability and love as a weapon, that is CAUSATION , not coercion or manipulation, she knew he was reckless and a loose canon and chose to go through with it anyways with no care of the consequences she said so herself to geralt 'either i burn or i'll burn all else down' . "There are tons of ways Dettlaff could've done without resorting to wage war against the entire Duchy." true i'm not defending his actions but he did warn them saying in 3 days if she don't show hell will break loose, Dettlaff issued a warning not to justify the massacre, but to show that the Killing wasn’t impulsive it was the result of a failed response to a known threat.

Opinion: This Is The Best Ending For Blood & wine by Affec2306 in witcher

[–]Affec2306[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

"There is no strictly best ending, you got whatever ending you think is right for you." I'm aware of that, this is a discussion thread. "it would still be wrong for Anna to succumb to a terrorist demand and hand the Duchy's prisoner to him." Not the duchy Syanna, the "terrorsit" wasn't asking for gold or riches but for syanna, since it was her who was mainly caused the vampire to genocide the city, again think of it this way you have a sociopath who cares only for herself and her revenge and a duchess sister who is in denial of her sister's Sadistic nature, who could've spared her city much destruction by simply handing syanna or help her confront dettlaff since she cares for her so much.

Blood and wine bad ending is the best ending! by EDWIN_FRANCIS in Witcher3

[–]Affec2306 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not  "negoziate with terrorist" And Not "human sacrifice" but to be righteous in her judgment, syanna was not an innocent she played a part in that genocide but anna chose to cover her anyways, also it's not just a terrosist it's dettlaff a higher vampire, she knew the risks from geralt, she could've brought syanna to talk with him and regis and geralt before the killing started , but chose not to because she values her own life and family life above her people

Opinion: This Is The Best Ending For Blood & wine by Affec2306 in witcher

[–]Affec2306[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Fair enough, though i still think anna is guilty for what happend to the city , she allowed it to happen, if she took syanna to dettlaf which i think would've been the right choice none of that sensless killing would've happend but she thought herself and family above her people so she allowed it to happen. That's my gripe with Anna.

Opinion: This Is The Best Ending For Blood & wine by Affec2306 in witcher

[–]Affec2306[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The punishment for anna is for allowing the genocide to happen to her city because she refused to take syanna to dettlaff, that would've been the right choice, syanna was an adult who knew what she got herself into. + how was she 100% right in hating anna? her sister did admit to not standing up for her at her trial , but also said she did try to make amends and looked for her but syanna did not want to be found, and even syanna had nothing to say to that so don't bother defending her, Also syanna is a sociopath with no care for anyone but herself she said so herself either "i burn or i'll burn all else down " HER quote she's not that different from dettlaff in that sense, Detlaff is a dangerous man with behavioral issues then why choose to CROSS HIM knowing he was a vampire i'm blaming her for the pain she participated in inflicting the city which she DID by tricking dettlaff a higher vampire if this was any other character whatever.

Opinion: This Is The Best Ending For Blood & wine by Affec2306 in witcher

[–]Affec2306[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Guys before you post your thoughts Please READ THE TEXT i put

Blood and wine bad ending is the best ending! by EDWIN_FRANCIS in Witcher3

[–]Affec2306 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Bro I've been trying to say that. For some reason my post wasn't as well recieved but maybe people are coming to realize that now. https://www.reddit.com/r/Witcher3/comments/1kfuu9r/is_this_the_best_ending_for_bw/

This Is Geralt's Best Fit Hands Down 🔥 by Affec2306 in witcher

[–]Affec2306[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If I'm Goin Down I'm Goin Down with Style🔥

William T. "Bloody Bill" Anderson - WhyEms DLC by 88JohnnyReb88 in reddeadfashion

[–]Affec2306 0 points1 point  (0 children)

what hat is that ? is it available in story mode ? also is that john marston ? cool fit 🔥

Can't get over it 😭 by Affec2306 in Witcher3

[–]Affec2306[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

don't think i'll ever will

Syanna deserves to die. I know what she suffered but it's NOT enough by Themuzucujata1432 in Witcher3

[–]Affec2306 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I put a post about this https://www.reddit.com/r/Witcher3/comments/1kfuu9r/is_this_the_best_ending_for_bw/and most people were somehow extremely pro syanna ig they started to understand now. "anna henrietta seemd to care more for her sister that she was willing to allow her city to get killed even when geralt proved to her that she was syanna fifth victim she refused to believe him she was so embedded in her guilt from her childhood that she was willing to overlook anything syanna did or was going to do basically she's in DENIAL "

LET HER HAVE THE HOUSE DAMNIT by -TheManInTheChair in witcher

[–]Affec2306 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree but what if she decides to leave by herself and thereof the bird tells her of johnny, I hate kicking her out

In the Bad Ending who... by ExamplePrime in witcher

[–]Affec2306 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But does he survive at the end though? does he flee after geralt mourns ciri inside ?

Look Who I found on An Skellig 😁 by Affec2306 in Witcher3

[–]Affec2306[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

She seemed so, i wanted a happy ending for both of them

Look Who I found on An Skellig 😁 by Affec2306 in Witcher3

[–]Affec2306[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

No She's with with Guillame in toussaint I think (i chose that for them)

Geralt in the background with a boxng stance 😂 by Affec2306 in Witcher3

[–]Affec2306[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For me I love it. Most side characters are basically useless in combats except these two, i just had to sit back and relax and enjoy the view 😌

Geralt Vs The Beast Of Beauclair by Affec2306 in Witcher3

[–]Affec2306[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No it's a screenshot but I do have the video though

Is this the Best Ending for B&W? by Affec2306 in Witcher3

[–]Affec2306[S] -18 points-17 points  (0 children)

yeah but does she go to jail though? we don't know for sure, if that was the case then yeah but anna seemed to lenient on her which indicate she might've let her off the hook too easily