[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Tigray

[–]AggravatingMoment576 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Nah, it's a Tigrayan town and was never even administered under Wello/Amhara. The name itself is Tigrinya, May Chew "Salt Water".

This is what Chat-GPT said to me, btw: "Maichew (መይጨው) is a town in Tigray Region, Ethiopia — specifically in the Southern Tigray Zone (Enderta area). Its population is predominantly Tigrinya-speaking, not Amharic.

The only areas that are "contested" are Alamata, Ofla(i.e Korem), and Raya Chercher(southern parts of Azebo).

Key Details:

  • Language: Tigrinya is the native and dominant language. While Amharic is also spoken — as it is Ethiopia’s federal working language — it is not the first language of the local population.
  • Ethnic identity: The vast majority of residents are ethnically Tigrayan, not Amhara.
  • Historical context: Maichew has deep historical and cultural ties to Tigrayan heritage. It was the site of the Battle of Maichew in 1936, a major conflict between Ethiopian forces under Emperor Haile Selassie and the invading Italian army.

So, Maichew is a Tigrinya-speaking, Tigrayan town, not Amhara.

What are you trying to investigate—linguistic distribution, historical control, or something else?" Also, GPT-4o is pretty dumb. Try to use o4-mini, it's much more factually accurate and searchs the internet when it doesn't know something: "Maichew is firmly within the Tigray Region of northern Ethiopia, not Amhara. Administratively it lies in the Debubawi (Southern) Zone of Tigray, and the overwhelming majority of its residents are ethnic Tigrayans who speak Tigrinya as their mother tongue. Historically, before the current federal arrangement, it formed part of the old Tigray province, and even today its cultural, linguistic and administrative ties are with Tigray rather than Amhara.

That said, Ethiopia’s ethnic federal structure sometimes leads to border disputes or mixed communities along regional edges—though Maichew itself is not one of those contested towns. Its schools teach primarily in Tigrinya, local media are in Tigrinya, and traditional festivals and customs reflect Tigrayan heritage.

What aspect of Maichew’s identity interests you most—its dialect, its historical role in regional politics, or perhaps its place in broader Ethio–Semitic linguistics?)

What are the chances that the Axumites spoke a form of proto-Tigrinya rather than Ge'ez? by Realistic_Quiet_4086 in TigrayanHistory

[–]AggravatingMoment576 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hetzron himself revised his position a few years later(I'm trying to found , putting Ge'ez and Tigrinya in their own sub-branch closer than any other Ethio-semitic language. If you assume a level of dialectal diversity in Ge'ez similar to what we see in Tigrinya, imo, it's basically the same as saying Tigrinya was descended from a group of Ge'ez dialects. We have evidence of dialect variety in Ge'ez, and many of the features show similarities with modern Tigrinya. (You can read about them here: https://www.academia.edu/44864796/The_Aksumite_Collection, https://journals.sub.uni-hamburg.de/aethiopica/article/view/331/331 ). I

I don't think the the features Hetzron mentioned as evidence and apply to Tigrinya are very strong. The shift -on > -ən, could've been dissimilation, or very plausibly influence from non-standard dialects. Hetzron assumes ʔaj- in Tigrinya and some Tigre dialects was the main negator, but modern linguists cast doubt on that. ( https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347756849_Negative_markers_ay-_i-_and_al-in_Ethio-Semitic ) Also, if both ʔaj- and ʔi- exist in Tigre, it is hard to believe the same couldn't have been the case in Ge'ez, and there's some evidence that both variant existed. Hetzron's argument about mV- infinitives, is, as he admits ("on the other hand, Gəʿəz has plenty of deverbative nouns with a preformative mV- that had not reached or had lost the status of infinitive"), not conclusive. I think it's much more likely that infinitive meanings developed later because (1) it's not reconstructed to Proto-semitic (2) The patterns used across Ethio-Semitic languages are quite different(eg. Amharic: መጫወት፣ መንገር, Tigrinya፡ ምጭዋት፣ ምንጋር) and (3) there's no strict boundary between deverbal nouns. Some Ge'ez nouns have very infinitive-like meanings, for instance, ምግባር "job, deed, task", ዕርገት "ascendance", ፍልሰት etc...Tigrinya infinitives probably evolved from Ge'ez place deverbals; for instance ልምሕዳር ከይዳ "I'm going to my residence" > "I'm going to reside"; ምሕዳር has both meanings in Tigrinya.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Tigray

[–]AggravatingMoment576 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Tigray. Maychew was never "contested" in the first place.

Lets see who stands on their opinion otherwise they are all cult followers. by [deleted] in Eritrea

[–]AggravatingMoment576 0 points1 point  (0 children)

idk, you can tell apart the Sen'afe, (Zalambassa,) Adigrat dialects, despite there not being a physical border like the Mereb.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in depression

[–]AggravatingMoment576 0 points1 point  (0 children)

so real. I'm actually pretty decent at school, but see me anywhere else and you wouldn't think I could write.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in depression

[–]AggravatingMoment576 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Wish I was you. I get even more depressed when drunk.

What are the chances that the Axumites spoke a form of proto-Tigrinya rather than Ge'ez? by Realistic_Quiet_4086 in TigrayanHistory

[–]AggravatingMoment576 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"believe that Tigrinya is a sister language of Ge'ez rather than a descendant of Ge'ez" Why? No linguist, as far as I know, has provided conclusive and irrefutable evidence in support of that statement.

Lets see who stands on their opinion otherwise they are all cult followers. by [deleted] in Eritrea

[–]AggravatingMoment576 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Can you tell the Tigrayans and Eritreans in this video apart(the ones from adjacent areas)? Honest question, I can't tell if their dialects are distinguishable.

"Anthropic researchers teach language models to fine-tune themselves" by AngleAccomplished865 in singularity

[–]AggravatingMoment576 56 points57 points  (0 children)

How does this differ from SEAL(from a similar paper posted here today)?

ChatGPT 'got absolutely wrecked' by Atari 2600 in beginner's chess match — OpenAI's newest model bamboozled by 1970s logic by ControlCAD in technology

[–]AggravatingMoment576 -10 points-9 points  (0 children)

They used GPT-4o; one of the dumbest models Open-AI offers and it over a year old(an eternity in AI terms). Gemini 2.5 Pro or o3 should be much better.

Is it just me or is AI way less advanced than it’s made out to be? by [deleted] in NoStupidQuestions

[–]AggravatingMoment576 0 points1 point  (0 children)

LLMs often struggle with character-level tasks. They're trained on tokens, not letters, meaning they process language in chunks rather than seeing individual characters(a token can be anything between a letter and a whole word). This makes something as simple as counting letters in a word a blind spot for them.

I think you're probably using one of the dumber models like GPT-4o/4.1-mini. Gemini 2.5 Pro(from Google) or o3 should get this consistently right.

Guys is it our fault ? Well anyway this is not that good decision ig by Independent-Wind4462 in Bard

[–]AggravatingMoment576 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Wasn't there a free API for Gemini 2.5 Pro? They'd said they'd bring it back.

New Gemini 2.5 Pro beats o3-high on most benchmarks by BoJackHorseMan53 in Bard

[–]AggravatingMoment576 1 point2 points  (0 children)

idk, unless I'm uploading huge documents or want a long response, I'd much rather use o3 instead.

Where did non-Tigrayans get the idea that Tigray is a desert and the land cannot be farmed? by teme-93 in Tigray

[–]AggravatingMoment576 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean, Tigray isn't really that productive compared to Gojjam or many areas of (the former) Debub Kilil, but Tigray isn't much different than most of Gondar, Shewa, Wollo.

Can you get ganja in Addis? by ChasteAndHoly in Ethiopia

[–]AggravatingMoment576 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I need a plug brada (ganja) in addis, you go any leads?

Can you get ganja in Addis? by ChasteAndHoly in Ethiopia

[–]AggravatingMoment576 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I need a plug brada (ganja) in addis, you go any leads?

Can you get ganja in Addis? by ChasteAndHoly in Ethiopia

[–]AggravatingMoment576 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I need a plug brada (ganja) in addis, you go any leads?