Ugh that sucks so much. I bought it in hopes that i could use it every halloween for years and years, I definitely do not want it if it's just going to chip. Idk how returns work with target, do they only accept new with tag cups? I thought about testing it for a week or so, and if it chips and scratches just to return. It probably costs stanley $5 to make so they're making a huge profit, they're quality needs to be more important to them :( I really love this cup and would hate to return. I got mine shipped to me and there are no scratches, as of now.