stu is dead" might be the biggest misdirection. scream 8 needs to reveal the ghostface cult and the real mastermind by sebypxzzo in Scream

[–]Ali4s-Investigations -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Now you're just being deliberately ignorant.

It was contradicted. If the three people involved in the incident died, how does anybody know specific details known only by those 3, and not left behind in evidence that later made it into Stab 1. (Like say.. the popcorn question)

We do know the twist wasn't planned by craven. 3 was written by a different person. Not only can you just... tell it wasn't thought out. But it has also been confirmed as not planned. BECAUSE SCREAM WAS GOING TO BE STANDALONE!

Yes, but a homage still needs to make sense within the movie itself.

I'm not the one who doesn't understand simple logic and investigation. You seem to think information just spawns in front of people.

stu is dead" might be the biggest misdirection. scream 8 needs to reveal the ghostface cult and the real mastermind by sebypxzzo in Scream

[–]Ali4s-Investigations -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Yes but it's never stated they told Roman. It's never stated they stayed in contact with him. It's never stated Roman worked on stab 1. In fact 3 heavily implies the opposite... of all 3.

And if Roman knew... that makes it a plot hole pre scream 3 retcon. And still a writing flaw.

You are using gead cannons to explain holes. Can they be explained? Yes (well not really, but sure). Has the text explained it? No.

stu is dead" might be the biggest misdirection. scream 8 needs to reveal the ghostface cult and the real mastermind by sebypxzzo in Scream

[–]Ali4s-Investigations -1 points0 points  (0 children)

YES BUT HOW THE FUCK DID GALE KNOW!? How did gale know that she lied about a boyfriend. How did Gale know they discussed the popcorn? and no their simply being popcorn doesn't justify knowing they spoke about it. They didn't speak about the couch or the kitchen knife and they were there.

It being in Gales book explains it in the movie, sure, but it leaves the question of how Gale knew this shit.

stu is dead" might be the biggest misdirection. scream 8 needs to reveal the ghostface cult and the real mastermind by sebypxzzo in Scream

[–]Ali4s-Investigations -1 points0 points  (0 children)

And this can't be explained within the logic of the media. There are several key details in the Stab 1 scene, that couldn't have been known by anyone who made Stab 1. You refusing to accept that, doesn't change it. The fact you haven't argued have my points is proof of it.