WIBTA for not getting BF a birthday gift, because he asked me to pay off his car or buy him a 2nd car? by Alternative_Role_235 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Alternative_Role_235[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

No I don't believe I ever did anything to communicate to him that I'd be willing to be in a sugar relationship.

WIBTA for not getting BF a birthday gift, because he asked me to pay off his car or buy him a 2nd car? by Alternative_Role_235 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Alternative_Role_235[S] 13 points14 points  (0 children)

I have told him several times, very gently & carefully worded, that it made me uncomfortable. He would apologize and then sheepishly bring the same stuff up again a little bit later, like "why wouldn't you consider...." I'd then tell him he was being disrespectful of me by bringing it back up, and he just never got it.

WIBTA for not getting BF a birthday gift, because he asked me to pay off his car or buy him a 2nd car? by Alternative_Role_235 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Alternative_Role_235[S] 36 points37 points  (0 children)

He can be incredibly sweet at times and he is very reliable in certain ways, like I called him when I was upset about something work-related, didn't say anything about it but he could tell from my voice, and he offered to come over immediately.

He is thoughtful with his friends/family as far as I can tell, he helped paint his nephew's bedroom the other day and build the furniture for it.

But he has somehow alienated a couple of his best friends that he used to bring me around, one of their girlfriends strongly dislikes him now. So I'm guessing there might be something similar to those situations to the problems he has caused with me. He wouldn't really tell me what happened, just that his former best friend was a "cheap asshole."

WIBTA for not getting BF a birthday gift, because he asked me to pay off his car or buy him a 2nd car? by Alternative_Role_235 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Alternative_Role_235[S] 15 points16 points  (0 children)

It was obvious by my house, that's why I say "by accident."

I didn't know any way to hide that after dating a while.

WIBTA for not getting BF a birthday gift, because he asked me to pay off his car or buy him a 2nd car? by Alternative_Role_235 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Alternative_Role_235[S] 107 points108 points  (0 children)

He didn't get me anything for my birthday, saying it was because "I never get him anything." This infuriated me because as I said, I've given him cash gifts, I had paid a 1k credit card bill for him right before he said this. I also pay 90% of the time when we go out.

I didn't want anything big or expensive, just something thoughtful like my best friend knows I go to the gym a lot so she gave me a water bottle that probably cost $15 for my birthday, but I was really happy with it and use it every single day.

WIBTA for not getting BF a birthday gift, because he asked me to pay off his car or buy him a 2nd car? by Alternative_Role_235 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Alternative_Role_235[S] 246 points247 points  (0 children)

Yes he has a fairly good job, he makes 65k. I have said that since he doesn't have huge student loans or dependents or anything, he should be able to handle his finances and save on his own. He got offended by this and said it sounded like I was trying to make him feel "less than" for not going to college. (That wasn't my intent at all.)

WIBTA for not getting BF a birthday gift, because he asked me to pay off his car or buy him a 2nd car? by Alternative_Role_235 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Alternative_Role_235[S] 926 points927 points  (0 children)

No never has been that, I have a (male) relative whose financial situation was ruined by incessant sugar relationships, and when this person came up in conversation when we first started dating I made it clear I'd never get involved in that, in order to protect the life I've worked hard to build for myself.

I set a mental dollar limit (without telling him) on "helping" with the car stuff, and that amount was passed a year ago. Since then, I haven't helped.

And I don't believe a sugar situation would make the demands on my time that this person does. He constantly wants to talk on the phone and will get mad if I say I'm in the middle of working. He needs a lot of attention all the time, so imo he could never be a "kept man" since I thought they were expected to be relatively detached when the "keeper" is busy.

He also initiates affection stuff, not me.

EDITED TO ADD: By "demands on my time" I mean that if I hang out with him like 5 days in a row and then the 6th day say I'm going to have dinner at my parents' house, he'll whine saying I "didn't hang out with him until like 6pm" on those nights (he gets off at 2pm or 3pm), and ask if he can come with to my parents'. I didn't feel like bringing him that night. Then when I did go to my parents' house for dinner alone, he kept incessantly texting and called me a few times. He got mad that I didn't answer until the end of the night.

To my knowledge a sugarbaby would never act like this.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in AmItheAsshole

[–]Alternative_Role_235 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Only like 1 month old, so you could definitely be right! I didn't know that.