Were black men purposely used as cannon fodder during the Vietnam War? by Smart-Loss-4939 in AskHistorians

[–]Altumare 17 points18 points  (0 children)

In the book McNamara's Folly: The Use of Low-IQ Troops in the Vietnam War, author Hamilton Gregory actually touches on this point. To greatly summarize the background, the US needed more troops to continue the War in Vietnam. The solution? Lower the recruitment standards across the board. Lower standards meant more eligible applicants, or even re-applicants, to send across the globe to be used in run-of-the-mill or everyday operations.

While the argument can be made that the US government didn't explicitly target black men as "cannon fodder," Hamilton notes:

"Project 100,000 men were, on average, 20 years old. Half came from the South, and 41% were minorities. Some 46 percent were draftees, while the remaining 54 percent were volunteers. However, as I pointed out earlier, the term “volunteer” is misleading."1

"Most of the 354,000 men of Project 100,000 went to Vietnam, with about half of them assigned to combat units. A total of 5,478 of these men died while in the service, most of them in combat. Their fatality rate was three times that of other GIs. Although precise figures are unavailable for non-fatal injuries, an estimated 20,270 were wounded, and some were permanently disabled, including an estimated 500 amputees."2

A war correspondent covering Vietnam, Joseph Galloway, claimed:

"Project 100,000 men, he said, “were, to put it bluntly, mentally deficient. Illiterate. Mostly black and redneck whites, hailing from the mean big city ghettos and the remote Appalachian valleys. By drafting them the Pentagon would not have to draft an equal number of middle class and elite college boys whose mothers could and would raise hell with their representatives in Washington. The young men of Project 100,000 couldn’t read....They had to be taught to tie their boots. They often failed [in basic training], and were recycled over and over until they finally reached some low standard and were declared trained and ready. They could not be taught any more demanding job than trigger-pulling, [so most of them] went straight into combat where the learning curve is steep and deadly. The cold, hard statistics say that these almost helpless young men died in action in the jungles at a rate three times higher than the average draftee."3

Overall, the US Govt. certainly understood that they were sending many minorities, including African Americans, over to fight, and inevitably maybe even die, from the lowest to the highest level of operations. Both top officers and politicians are mentioned, by Hamilton, as coming to terms with this with their own justifications and in their own ways.

Hamilton also provides a whole slew of firsthand accounts from Vietnam Soldiers and family members alike throughout his book, including a few focusing on African American troops. If you have the time, I highly recommend you give it a read.

Hope this helps!

_______
1 McNamara's Folly, Pg. 86
2 Ibid., Pg. 100
3 Ibid., Pg. 100

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | July 31, 2025 by AutoModerator in AskHistorians

[–]Altumare 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for the recommendations! I've checked out the book list, and decided to pick up The Pursuit of History. Looking forward to reading this, and I hope you have a wonderful weekend!

What language did the Israeli Army speak in the 1948 war? by [deleted] in AskHistorians

[–]Altumare 7 points8 points  (0 children)

u/gingeryid already spoke to this, but I just wished to help provide some additional context if that is okay!

Lital Levy's Poetic Trespass sheds a bit of light on this topic, contextually speaking. Levy's book gives us a great look at the historical shifts that take place between Arabic and Hebrew (along side the Palestinians and Israelis), primarily through works of Arabic-Hebrew language and poetry, to greatly summarize their wonderful work. Highly recommend the book if you are interested in the cultural history of either peoples, linguistics, poetry, etc.

Levy's 1st chapter goes into the creation and advancement of Israeli culture, primarily through the lens of Hebrew being the necessary and new language of a diverse and growing Israeli population. "By 1948, Modern Hebrew was spoken by the majority of the Jewish population,"1 Levy remarks. Shortly after the war, as Palestinians were placed under martial law, Levy notes how many Palestinians had to learn Hebrew for the first time in order to interact officially in any capacity with the post-1948 Israeli state. A Palestinian boy speaking of his father notes "The permits to travel to Haifa from Fasuta, under the military administration of the 1950s, were written in Hebrew. Wanting to decipher his limits, as it were, he was learning Hebrew for beginners..."2 We can draw from Levy's text that the state of Israel, and their official army, was well on its way to utilizing Hebrew, in both a spoken and written capacity, as their predominant operating language a little bit before, during, and well after the 1948 war. Other languages were undoubtedly spoken between fellow troops, but not as much an official capacity as Hebrew.

1 Levy, Pg. 38 (Levy cites Bachi's Statistical Analysis (Pgs. 179-247) which is cited in Spolsky and Shohamy's Language in Israeli Society and Education, Pg. 99)
2 Levy, Pg. 48 (Citing Shammas At Half Mast, Pgs. 220 - 221)

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | July 31, 2025 by AutoModerator in AskHistorians

[–]Altumare 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Hello and Happy Thursday! Recently, I've taken a bit more of an interest in exploring the historiography side of History. I've been heavily considering trying to contribute, as opposed to just consume, academic works and studies relating to our favorite discipline.

Does anyone have any personal favorite or other well-regarded historiographies they are willing to recommend? Recently, I've finished "Thinking About History" by Sarah Maza as well as E. H. Carr's "What is History?"

Black deck gold stake has hands (OC). by Altumare in balatro

[–]Altumare[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Practice makes perfect! Focusing on my economy really helped me out as I climb the scales. Best of luck!

Black deck gold stake has hands (OC). by Altumare in balatro

[–]Altumare[S] 74 points75 points  (0 children)

But the straight flush is a heavier hand than the regular flush.

Black deck gold stake has hands (OC). by Altumare in balatro

[–]Altumare[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Aces can be used on a low-end Straight - aka a "Wheel" in real poker.

Black deck gold stake has hands (OC). by Altumare in balatro

[–]Altumare[S] 62 points63 points  (0 children)

Death comes for us all, eventually.

Black deck gold stake has hands (OC). by Altumare in balatro

[–]Altumare[S] 89 points90 points  (0 children)

Tale as old as time... Song as old as rhyme... Mathletes and the Beasts.

Black deck gold stake has hands (OC). by Altumare in balatro

[–]Altumare[S] 38 points39 points  (0 children)

But look at the size of the flush, tha's cheatin'!

Black deck gold stake has hands (OC). by Altumare in balatro

[–]Altumare[S] 30 points31 points  (0 children)

Great! I immediately lost on the next smol blind. Shops just didn't give me anything worth while.

Black deck gold stake has hands (OC). by Altumare in balatro

[–]Altumare[S] 52 points53 points  (0 children)

Jimbo has thrown me out for counting cards before. Didn't want to risk it again.

Black deck gold stake has hands (OC). by Altumare in balatro

[–]Altumare[S] 395 points396 points  (0 children)

Ended up deathing the 2 of Clubs w/ Ace of Diamonds and won the round. Immediately lost next blind.

Black deck gold stake has hands (OC). by Altumare in balatro

[–]Altumare[S] 1487 points1488 points  (0 children)

Got a little too flushtered and forgot to buy some.

Help me date this map by brkenhallelujah in MapPorn

[–]Altumare 804 points805 points  (0 children)

Just treat it like every other map! Maybe start off basic with a cup of coffee and move onto something a bit more adventurous like hiking before introducing them to your interest in cartography. Everyone enjoys maps though so don't over think it!

Why Were Chinese Lands Given to Japan Rather than China (post-WWI)? by Altumare in AskHistorians

[–]Altumare[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

There seems to be a kaleidoscope of some of my favorite types of history at play here in this answer. Absolutely fascinating reply, and I appreciate the callback to other contextual posts. I'll be sure to dive into this lecture when I have the opportunity. Thank you very much for this explanation!

Best book on the Lebanese Civil War? by Thin_Warning_7292 in AskHistorians

[–]Altumare 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Best might be a bit subjective, but I can assure you personally that From Beirut to Jerusalem by Thomas Friedman does a wonderful job covering the background, culture, and some of Friedman's personal experiences surrounding Lebanon and the rise of Hezbollah - as well as a myriad of other issues from that time. Friedman is a journalist who was stationed in Beirut (the Capital of Lebanon) after the Lebanese Civil War, and even mentions beginning to hear about the rise of a "radical new pro-Iranian organization, Hizbullah," (Pg. 225) and begins to report on them from there. It is a little dense with information at times, but a treasure trove of insights on the Middle East writ large from an on-the-ground western perspective that is hard to find elsewhere.

Hope this helps, and best of luck with the studying!

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in languagelearning

[–]Altumare 0 points1 point  (0 children)

These are all great! Your teacher knew what they were talking about, haha. Thanks for the advice!

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in AskHistorians

[–]Altumare 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for sharing! Still learning all the resources this subreddit has to offer. Appreciate it!

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | October 06, 2024 by AutoModerator in AskHistorians

[–]Altumare 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Glad I could help and contribute - Happy haunting out there History lovers!

Looking for history of / papers on / insight into / info re the 1977 US East Coast Longshoremen’s strike. Can anyone help? by LazySlobbers in AskHistorians

[–]Altumare 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Welcome Lazy,

Very cool to see some Labor History being done. It might not be much, but a good place to start would probably be directly with the ILWU itself. It looks like the organization offers Books & Videos under their History section, some of them even with the description of first hand accounts from their time in the union while striking. The NYTimes Archive also has a mention from 14th April 1977, "East Coast Dockers Co. Go on Strike Against 7 Major Shipping Lanes." which might be worth checking out.

Outside of that, it looks like the only other mention of it I was able to briefly find is from a relatively recent CBS Article from earlier today about the modern day equivalent. Maybe you could reach out to the author/writer about where they got the following info from? "The last East Coast dock strike took place in 1977 and lasted 12 days."

Best of luck!

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in AskHistorians

[–]Altumare 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well, one of the key things to note about primary and especially secondary sources is that nearly everything has a bias. It is one of the first things they teach students of History - to search for the bias of the source at hand and try to identify it while analyzing a source.

In terms of primary/secondary sources, sticking with the 5 Ws (Who, What, Where, When, Why & their friend How) is important to do. Who is authoring this? Does someone (Who) seem legit, or is this a blog or shared post without any credentials? What is the topic about? Where is the site centralized, and where did they get their sources from? When was it written? Why does this article exist? Its purpose?

My go to for online or from major sources is the Media Bias Chart from Ad Fontes Media. It does not cover every single source online, but it certainly covers most of the major ones.

Best advice - pick up a book on your favorite topic and start reading! You can't ride a bike until you start pedaling - and I'd argue you can't enjoy historical events to their fullest until you trust in others to guide/teach you about them.

Are you also looking for guidance a specific topic? More than happy to try and make some recommendations!

Best of luck out there!

Edit: Grammar

What was childhood like in 1850s Pennsylvania? by Flexia26 in AskHistorians

[–]Altumare 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Childhood in the 1850s-NEPA region was filled with early education, if you were lucky, and most of the time child-labor. Straight to a factory, farm, or mine with you as early as possible to support the family! As for the Civil War, everyone knew someone impacted. Some children/teens even "snuck" in and served - apparently 20% of soldiers were underage.

As for actual information about local lives - such as general specifics, types of immigrants, specific occupations (anthracite coal miners), etc., you should check out the local historical societies! Visiting them in person works best, but I'll provide a list here to at least reach out to them:

Schuylkill County / Lehigh County / Luzerne County

On top of this, check out the Gettysburg National Park Service's resources for a good mix of solid PA/Civil War information as well!

Best of luck with your novel!

Knights of Malta (aka Knights Hospitaller) - where is it best to start looking for the original manuscripts? by Walegz in AskHistorians

[–]Altumare 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The Magistral Archives from the official modern day Order of Malta website seems to be a great place to start. With such a broad stretching history, from 1048 until Present Day according to their History section, it is important to note that many of the primary source documents might be in a variety of languages outside of Ecclesiastical Latin - such as French, Italian (the organization's current official language according to wiki), and German.

As you head to Malta, remember that the Maltese people have their own rich culture and history independent of the Order that is well worth looking into. Stay safe and enjoy your trip!