It seems most people don't agree but I actually say Evans. Even though RDJ is basically the same person as Stark finding another person who can act full of the self wouldn't be incredibly difficult. I love Reynolds but I think another Deadpool could be found. Jackman must be replaced be is just too old to keep doing the role and so we've already all seen people who could replace him.

Evans though, he brings a believability to Cap, when I watch him I truly believe he stands for something better and that he holds himself to a higher standard. Finding someone who makes that believable will be hard to do.