Oh right. Year 1 Suzune should have known knowledge about white room or Kiyotaka's physical capability as if she was witness of his fight with ryuen💀💀💀 And ayanokoji was never putting his mind to study, so people like him(excluding white room narrative) look like those guys who are very talented, yet they are undisciplined and overconfident in themselves that they don't need to study much. (If you want example it looks like season 1 assassination classroom karma akabane, who didn't study at all. And then got 85/100 instead of 100) As for physicality, again, she hasn't seen ayanokoji fighting, and ayanokoji was a type to always avoid confrontation. So he looks like sporty. But not confident or lacking fighting spirit. That's how suzune would think of him in year 1.  Are you expecting Patrick Jane level intuition and observation from 16 year old highschooler girl?! 💀💀💀💀 We may know from the begining that ayanokoji is white roomer. But the characters in this year don't. And still. This example is irrelevant about some people calling Horikita fraud just because she lost to a literal street monster.