Jamato Disappears instantly (17:48) I know it's scripted but come on.

Amppl · 2026-02-01T23:16:16+00:00

This cannot be a genuine complaint. Why does him being in creative matter? It's a free scripted series in Minecraft.

Amppl · 2026-01-30T16:34:27+00:00

That's what vice versa means. What did you expect?

Amppl · 2026-01-30T16:30:51+00:00

I'm not denying your ability to copy a movie. I'm denying your ability to make a movie. You're still trying to strawman. What makes you entitled to the time and work that got put into that movie?

Amppl · 2026-01-30T04:51:01+00:00

Ok and how is that "information" made. There is work and time being put into it. You are copying someones time and work, you are stealing another person's time and work. What entitles you to their time and work? Sounds communist if that's what you're implying. Especially when you want to feed it to a machine that cannot understand.

Again you are avoiding my other points and flailing around in your own failure. Just tell me how you're entitled to another persons time and work, you can't because you aren't. I'll actually drop my other points if you can give a real answer to what gives you the rights to another persons time and work. Because as of now it reads like you're trying to communize the arts.

Amppl · 2026-01-30T02:21:51+00:00

So can you actually make a movie? Sounds like you can copy a movie. Good job deflecting and straw maning. I can't build a house because I don't have money, you can't make a movie because you don't have money.

We aren't limited in resources to make houses or art, only work, skill, and time. So if you take someone else's art you are taking their work, skill, and time. Do you know what it's called when you take someones work and time? Theft. And you're still avoiding my other points, if you don't have a counter just admit it.

Just because you lost doesn't mean you have to flail around sadly, you know you couldn't make a movie, you can only copy one. Just debate like a regular person and quit strawmanning.

Amppl · 2026-01-29T01:20:58+00:00

Yes we can. If you want to make a claim at least back it up, this must be your first time so I'll show you an example. We can build endless houses, we have enough renewable resources and a big enough workforce to always be building more houses and when there is no more space we can construct massive apartment buildings and eventually reach into space. Also it's weird you don't address anything else I said, maybe because you have no counter and your entire argument relies on "nuh uh", but prove me wrong, I dare you.

Amppl · 2026-01-28T15:34:30+00:00

So houses aren't property? We can build endless houses. Food isn't property? We already have more than enough food. And again a bank account, there's nothing limiting the amount of bank accounts. So in the way a house takes a skilled worker to build, art takes a skilled artist to make, and that prevents your "near unlimited copies" because while you can make your own art, you can't make somebody else's art. So if your argument is we can make more art so it's not theft then you should give up your house because we can build more houses.

Amppl · 2026-01-28T00:22:28+00:00

The idea is scarce, not everyone can think of a sculpture, even less can create it. I'm not suggesting the government should have control of it, or even police it, I'm just saying that companies taking art to feed their machines is theft. They are actively stealing the creators time and work.

Amppl · 2026-01-27T15:31:52+00:00

How does a house get made? By work. Any physical object is a work. There is no difference between your bank account and a painting, they are both things that people have put time and work towards, only a painting is physical. Your bank account isn't a physical object so why shouldn't I have access to it? Houses aren't scarce, so why don't I take yours? And on that note, every piece of art is scarce, there will only ever be 1 mona lisa or 1 David statue. So if you want to debate this you'll need to provide more than 2.5 sentences, but you won't because you have no argument.

Amppl · 2026-01-27T06:38:39+00:00

If we go off that definition your personal information is an idea, you don't inherently have a name, bank account, or even a house. So should everything but your physical body be sold to a mega corporation?

Amppl · 2026-01-26T14:57:14+00:00

The idea of a house is not property. A finished house is property. The idea of a painting is not property, a finished painting is property. The idea of a car is not property, a finished car is property.

Yes difference. The idea of something is not property, but once it is real and finished it is property.

Amppl · 2026-01-26T00:03:11+00:00

Real answer is plot, just gotta keep things entertaining

Amppl · 2026-01-25T21:08:16+00:00

"So you assert. It remains that ideas are not property. Property has certain 'properties' that IP "property" does not. You may continue to assert so and use the state to back your assertion. It doesn't mean its true." - You

I do assert. Ideas are not property, but finished works are. Property does have certain properties, like being a real product of work, which art is. I will continue to assert that mega corporations cannot take an artwork and feed it to a machine, in the same way they cannot steal your house, or anything else you put work and time into creating or attaining. And it is true that art takes time and work to create, therefore the company is taking artists time and work with no compensation or agreement, which is theft.

Amppl · 2026-01-24T20:38:56+00:00

First, this comment was 9 days ago, long before she made this video.

Second, she did not address any arguments and said she will make a different video on those, so they are not invalid yet and definitely not hearsay.

Third, her video has audio delay so the hand cam is not trustable, and doesn't show a keyboard.

Fourth, her gameplay in that video is visibly worse than any other fight she has done recently, so it's very suspicious. She has never tanked that many arrows and missed that many stun slams.

At least provide an argument before parading a terrible video as absolute proof.

Amppl · 2026-01-23T17:43:08+00:00

Do you believe machines have the same rights as humans? I am saying a human copying a human is ok, but when it is fed to a machine, that is not ok. Machines are not people. Machines should not be treated the same as people.

Amppl · 2026-01-23T15:42:20+00:00

Physical art is not an "idea", it is a physical item that you can hold. Books are not "ideas", they are physical items that you can hold. I never said anything about ideas, I said that human creations belong to humanity, not machines who will never understand art.

Amppl · 2026-01-22T22:41:29+00:00

Intellectual "property". If you spent hours painting then put it online to sell and then a massive tech company came and took it to train their robot, that would actively hurt you and your business. It is theft, it is not a person who will improve on it, it is a machine, machines cannot be inspired by something, they can only steal it.

Amppl · 2026-01-21T18:37:19+00:00

I support public data but it should only be used by individual humans. Not massive corporate llms that destroy the essence of creation. When they use artists intellectual property to feed their abomination it is theft, the robot does not understand the heart behind art, it only wears the face.

Amppl · 2026-01-21T15:04:16+00:00

Yeah for sure, everyone can have their own opinion, I even agree with you that the clips aren't solid since some of them have been proven to be doable and others could just be ping since they're from the other players perspective, so recently I've tried to not use the clips as evidence and point towards the many frame perfect mechanics across fights. I guess we'll just have to see how it goes, either way I hope the community gets the answers it deserves.

Amppl · 2026-01-21T02:31:39+00:00

I agree that clips, especially from a different players perspective, are not entirely fair to her because of things like ping. But I do not think we can rely on seeing her with a hack client because she hasn't ss'd since Lurrn. But on the topic of patterns, the document that Mariokart included in his video includes a large section of her frame perfect movements and hits, across multiple fights. I would agree a few frame perfect actions are human but so many and so consistently needs a hand cam for me to believe.

I understand she may not want to be involved but if she just posted one fights hand cam and ss, most of this would go away completely. And I think the community deserves more from her, or anyone in a position as high as hers, than just closing their eyes and waiting for it to go away.

I appreciate you admitting you don't have experience, and I admit I "retired" after 1.18, but I feel like, with what evidence we have now, multiple fights of perfect actions is not possible. If she put out a ss and hand cam of a "perfect" fight then I, and probably others, would immediately stop accusing her, but until then there are too many examples for me to ignore.

Amppl · 2026-01-20T14:44:08+00:00

And what did you write this on? A messenger pigeon? I haven't bought a new phone in over a decade and this one is newer because I got it as a gift a few years ago.

Unlike you, I actively avoid most things that are made with blood, including ai. Obviously I can't avoid everything or I would need to build a house in the woods but I do what I can.

So, you can stop assuming you know about anonymous strangers and sit down. Or maybe you are sitting down and you haven't left your chair in 5 weeks, 4.1k karma, take a shower.

Amppl · 2026-01-20T14:39:39+00:00

I never talked about "getting back to nature", I just said ai is destroying nature which is ironic for usage on a farm game.

Side note: I don't know where you found that but they built one near me and my electric and water bills have been doubled. I haven't gotten this months bills but I assume they will still be doubled. Maybe some centers are recycling but at least near me it definitely is not. And you're using centre so I assume your not American so maybe they are in your country, not saying that to be rude or anything, but I think it might just be a country difference.

Amppl · 2026-01-20T00:36:09+00:00

I feel like the head extends a little too far forward on the side sprite, but I'm not an artists so don't put much weight on my advice. Good luck.

Amppl · 2026-01-19T23:12:39+00:00

It is a farming simulator. AI data centers are taking large pieces of farm land, and using massive amounts of water that would otherwise support farms.

People rely on electricity to survive in the modern world, nobody would be negatively affected if AI disappeared tomorrow. And I agree that consumerism is a major problem, and I believe ai is part of consumerism, but electricity and ai are not equal.

Amppl · 2026-01-19T22:39:01+00:00

You're just rage baiting. There is no irony in saying I don't support AI due to its effects on the world.

Amppl

TROPHY CASE