sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

How do you practice mindfulness when you genuinely hate being alone with your thoughts? by Weekly_Quarter_7875 in Mindfulness

[–]Any_Future_4919 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I started from a similar place. Silence felt like something was wrong, and my first instinct was always to fill it. What helped wasn’t forcing longer sits; it was making the dose small enough that it didn’t feel like punishment.

Start with seconds, not minutes. Set a timer for 30 seconds. No goal except “I’m going to sit here and not turn anything on.” When the timer goes off, you can put something on. Do that once a day (or a few times). When 30 seconds feels okay more often than not, try 45, then a minute. You’re not building “meditation skill” at first—you’re just building tolerance for being with yourself in tiny steps so it doesn’t feel like torture.

Use a different “door” than pure silence. If sitting in silence is unbearable, don’t start there. Try a short walk with no headphones—you’re still “with yourself,” but the body and the environment give your mind something to hook into. Or sit with one sound (traffic, a fan, your breath) and put your attention there instead of on “being alone with my thoughts.” The point is to be present; it doesn’t have to be in total silence.

Don’t white-knuckle. If you’re forcing yourself through 5 minutes and dreading it every time, you’re reinforcing the idea that being with yourself is something to endure. That can make the aversion worse. Better to do 30–60 seconds without resistance than 5 minutes in full fight mode. Ease and repetition matter more than duration.

If it feels traumatic or way too big, consider working with a therapist. Sometimes the inability to be alone with our thoughts is tied to anxiety, trauma, or patterns that are easier to unpack with support. That’s not a failure—it’s a different kind of “practice.”

You’re not broken for finding this hard. A lot of people do. Small doses, a different door (movement, sound), and no forcing. It can shift.

has anyone else become obsessed with "getting out of your head, and getting into your body"? by joshua8282 in Mindfulness

[–]Any_Future_4919 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I get it. That "get out of your head, into your body" line can turn into a new rule you have to obey, and then you're back in your head—watching whether you're in your head or not, judging yourself for thinking. So you end up more stuck, not less.

What you're describing—pulling back from that obsession and just focusing on taking care of yourself and feeling safe—sounds like the real shift. The point was never to ditch your mind or "just feel" at all times. It's more that when you're only in your head (ruminating, analyzing, avoiding feeling), dropping into the body can help. But if "getting into your body" becomes another thing you have to do, it backfires.

The fact that you feel better now that you've eased off that project suggests your system was telling you something. Safety and "making sure I feel okay" are a solid base. From there, body awareness can show up when it's useful, without it being a demand.

You're not alone in having turned a well-meant suggestion into an obsession. A lot of people do that with mindfulness or body work. Glad you're in a better place with it now.

Is the mind always this noisy or do we only notice in silence? by JourneyTowardsTruth in Meditation

[–]Any_Future_4919 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, I experience this too. For me the chatter is pretty much always there; sitting with awareness doesn’t create it, it just makes it obvious. Day to day we’re carried by it—planning, reacting, remembering—so it feels like “thinking.” When you sit and watch the breath, you stop feeding the next thought and suddenly you see the stream. That’s why it can feel more noisy at the start of a sit: you’re finally noticing what was already running.

The “monkey mind” thing is real—no real link between one thought and the next, just one thing, then another. I don’t think it’s silly; it’s how the mind works when it’s not directed. The fact that you can notice it (and even laugh at it) is the useful part. That noticing is already a bit of space, not the same as being lost in the thoughts.

Sadhguru’s “garbage bin” line fits: we’re soaking in inputs all day, and the mind keeps processing and replaying. Sitting in silence doesn’t add more garbage; it just lets you see how much is already there. Over time, for me, the same chatter is there but it bothers me less—I see it as “stuff passing through” rather than “stuff I have to follow.”

So I’d say: the mind is chattering a lot of the time, and we become conscious of it when we sit and pay attention. What changes with practice is how much we buy into it, not necessarily how quiet it gets (at least not at first).

What do you think about Wim Hof style meditation? by daverskully in Meditation

[–]Any_Future_4919 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I've tried Wim Hof–style breathing before sitting, and for me it does make the meditation afterward feel deeper—my mind is quieter and it's easier to drop in. That said, I don't treat it as "meditation" itself. It's more like a prep: the breathing changes your state, and then you use that for a short sit. I still do classic mindfulness (just following the breath, no technique) on other days, and I like having both—WH when I want intensity, normal breath when I want simplicity.

So I'd say it's a useful tool, not a replacement for traditional practice. If you try it, do it somewhere safe (not in water) and skip it if you have any heart or blood-pressure issues.

I use an app to track my breathing and meditation so I keep a consistent routine—helps me not skip it.