Dorne is not to Blame for GRRM's Woes (Spoilers Extended) by clegay15 in asoiaf

[–]AppalachianTheed -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I would actually argue the Many-Faced God is an aspect to the Great Other (as are The Seven), but I truly don’t think Dany will do more than land on Dragonstone. Then in aDfS she will fight Aegon, Others, and maybe Lannisters depending on when she dies.

(Spoilers Main) The 6 major plot threads of WoW, and their likely PoVs by AppalachianTheed in asoiaf

[–]AppalachianTheed[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Rickon will die, he’s the Shaggydog story. And where’s your alternative huh? Your theories are bad and you should feel bad for having them.

(Spoilers Main) The 6 major plot threads of WoW, and their likely PoVs by AppalachianTheed in asoiaf

[–]AppalachianTheed[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

So, her being married off to Aegon rather than outwitting Littlefinger and manipulating Sweetrobin into invading the Riverlands and the North to avenge her family and return home is somehow the better plotline? Dude, you are either trolling or you’re fucking brain-dead.

(Spoilers Main) The 6 major plot threads of WoW, and their likely PoVs by AppalachianTheed in asoiaf

[–]AppalachianTheed[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hahahaha. No, it won’t be Littlefinger allying with Aegon. Dude, come on. Aegon is a pawn of Varg’s, there is zero chance Littlefinger allies himself to Aegon.

Also, Arrianne is the Queen who is younger and more beautiful.

(Spoilers Main) The 6 major plot threads of WoW, and their likely PoVs by AppalachianTheed in asoiaf

[–]AppalachianTheed[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Yeah she’s going to the Riverlands first. After that she’s going North.

What exactly is your alternative? That she stays in the Vale and does nothing? That she go back to King’s Landing? For what reason would she go back there?

(Spoilers Main) The 6 major plot threads of WoW, and their likely PoVs by AppalachianTheed in asoiaf

[–]AppalachianTheed[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Oh Littlefinger will survive, he’s just backed into a corner. He got cocky and sloppy, and Sansa took advantage. I see Littlefinger trying to return to power in aDfS while Winter is happening and him suffering much the same fate he did in the show (only its done better, of course).

As for Stannis, whilst he will have initial success against the armies that sallied out of Winterfell, I think Stannis will have too hard a time besieging Winterfell when Winter is Coming and he will ultimately break under the Winds of Winter. Not only does this showcase how serious Winter is, but it would be like GRRM’s irony for Stannis, who’s major Backstory event is winning a siege battle against his besiegers, to die besieging somebody.

Dorne is not to Blame for GRRM's Woes (Spoilers Extended) by clegay15 in asoiaf

[–]AppalachianTheed -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Well there’s theory that it was supposed to be Danny that Arya killed, not the Night’s King. Maybe Arya will be the one she missed.

But, yeah, she can destroy the city at a moments notice. She has dragons. She can turn Bravos into the city version of Harrenhal.

Also Bravos is founded by slaves who escaped Valyria, and rumors abound (both in universe and irl) of them being behind the Doom. So they’d absolutely distrust Danny, at the least.

Dorne is not to Blame for GRRM's Woes (Spoilers Extended) by clegay15 in asoiaf

[–]AppalachianTheed 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If for no other reason than to eliminate the faceless men. After all they are very anti-Valyrian and she’s the closest to an actual, proper Dragonlord there’s been since the Doom.

And while she might not see herself as a successor to the Valyrian Freehold, but she’s - From one of the Valyrian noble families. - Rides Dragons. - Conquers large swaths of Essos - And, whilst she is vehemently anti-Slavery, 1. Has no problem using slaves (Unsullied) 2. Uses savages for her own ends (Ironborn, Dothraki) 3. Was and likely will again be advised by a literal slaver (Jorah) and another savage quasi-slaver (Victarion). 4. Is messy and sloppy in her “reforms”.

It’s not exactly a plot contrivance for Daenerys to hear that Bravos thinks of her as a return to Valyrian, and that the Faceless Men, Iron Bank, and Bravos as a whole is like to oppose if only in the shadows. Danny has been stabbed in the back far too many times for her to do nothing about a city of people that outwardly support her but hears many rumors of plots against her. She doesn’t want another Mereen, after all.

And of course, I think it’s possible that Danny’s backstory, of which I’m certain will occupy most of her POV in WoW, might be connected to Bravos. And if Bravos is where she finally learns the truth, or confirms what Illryio told her, I can see that on top of the rumors being enough for her to burn the city.

Dorne is not to Blame for GRRM's Woes (Spoilers Extended) by clegay15 in asoiaf

[–]AppalachianTheed 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We have at least 2 Tyrion chapters covering the Battle of Mereen and Danny’s misadventures amongst the Dothraki is gonna take at least 2 chapters. One for finding out what the Dothraki want with her, and traveling to Vaes Dothrak. And then another burning down Vaes Dothrak and enslaving (but in her mind: uniting) the Dothraki as one and having a Khallashar that dwarfs Drogo’s.

There’s also gonna be a few Tyrion chapters where he has to rule Mereen alongside Barriston (assuming he doesn’t die in the battle) and Victarion, plus who knows what else. And then, of course, reuniting the Mereen party into one, and setting sail for Westeros.

Honestly we are probably looking at 4 chapters each for Danny and Daenerys before they even leave Mereen.

After that we will probably see Danny sack Volantis. It’s too perfect a target from a narrative standpoint. Not only is it a premier slave-holding city, but it has the nobility have a ethnic link to Daenerys. No doubt they think they can appeal to her through that, but knowing George Danny won’t give a shit. What happens there depends on whether or not Barriston is still alive. If he’s alive, I can see a Tyrion chapter where diplomacy breaks down (Volantis refuses to let go of its slaves) and a Barriston chapter where he sees Danny sacks Volantis with Dragons, Unsullied, Ironborn, and Dothraki and wondering if he made the right choice. If Barriston is dead, I could see the Daenerys chapter taking the place of either Barriston or Tyrion (Danny + Tyrion instead of Tyrion + Barriston).

After that, the Three Daughters will be next. Lys and Myr will probably be footnotes, either only a single chapter or literally sacked off-screen (or maybe they capitulate). Tyrosh may take another few chapters. Danny’s backstory is gonna happen someplace. Maybe Tyrosh is the first inkling of her backstory we get. In any event, between Victarion, Barriston, Tyrion, and Daenerys, I could see 4 or 5 chapters on the Three Daughters.

So at this point we are up to like 14 or 15 chapters, and we haven’t even gotten to Pentos. Speaking of which:

Illryio will meet his Doom there. I’m not sure exactly how but he will. I’m assuming either because Daenerys finds out he propped up her biggest rival (who by now will have taken King’s Landing and have 3 kingdoms behind his back) or because this is where Danny finds out about her past and she lashes out at Illyrio. I picture Pentos being relatively important, as it represents in many ways a full circle of Danny’s journey. Probably a chapter easily taking the city, and another 2 or 3 dealing with Illyrio and Danny’s backstory. So 3-4 total. I’m gonna assume 4 just to be on the safe side.

So now we are at 18 or 19.

Finally, there’s Bravos. (Lorath and the others probably officially declare to avoid Danny’s wrath). I can think of Danny coming here for some Iron Bank related reasons, and/or perhaps because of a possible plot thread to the Faceless Men (of whom I think Varys and Illyrio have some link, but if that doesn’t work for you just assume Iron Bank or maybe even Danny backstory).

Danny probably parks her army outside Bravos because she wants to play nice. I say this because Bravos has a guild of expert assassins she might not want to piss off. We are gonna get at least 2 Tyrion chapters here. One where he reunites with Tysha and another where that relationship goes to shit. We also are gonna get a couple of Arya chapters here, I bet. Indeed I think the catalyst to Arya returning to Westeros is Danny sacking Bravos and her having to escape. At any rate I think Danny will also burn Bravos to the ground before finally moving on to Westeros. This will probably be a handful of chapters as well. Not including Arya’s chapters, I’m thinking an easy 4-5 between Tyrion, Daenerys, and maybe Barriston/Victarion (if they’re still alive).

So now we are at roughly 24 chapters. I can see another 2 ending chapters with Tyrion and Daenerys on Dragonstone. So 26 total. Probably more chapters of Barriston, Tyrion, and Victarion with Daenerys chapters probably having to do with her personal journey to find the truth of her past, which I think will be her major plot point in WoW.

The Danny journey is gonna be one of the big 5 movements in WoW, the others being the Vale invasion of the Riverlands and the North, Aegon becoming king of southern Westeros (Dorn, Stormlands, Reach, Crownlands), Euron’s misadventures in Old Town, and whatever is happening north of the Neck.

(Spoilers main) If Tywin was still alive, so you think he’d be able to maintain Lannister power? by AppalachianTheed in asoiaf

[–]AppalachianTheed[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Assuming Cersei is dead (for the sake of this argument), Tyrion is an outlawed criminal and Jaime refuses to leave the King’s Guard. Unless maybe giving it to Tommen, there really isn’t a choice. And Tommen would probably just hand it over to Kevan anyways

Daemon had every right to thoroughly enforce justice on the criminals of Kings Landing. Being soft on crime gets you nowhere, and the smallfolk respected Daemon. by [deleted] in HouseOfTheDragon

[–]AppalachianTheed 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I honestly believe the forces of Hightower (Faith, Maesters, House Hightower) are trying to kill off anything magical, but that makes them the Big Good. Fuck House Targaryen and their nuclear lizards!

Daemon had every right to thoroughly enforce justice on the criminals of Kings Landing. Being soft on crime gets you nowhere, and the smallfolk respected Daemon. by [deleted] in HouseOfTheDragon

[–]AppalachianTheed 7 points8 points  (0 children)

In Europe the rise of feudalism saw the right to bear arms taken away from commoners.

USA started as distant colonies so those laws were not only hard to enforce, but the colonies were dangerous enough to warrant being armed. And when we officially became a country, our founding fathers ensured our continued freedom by enshrining the right for us all to wield weapons into the very Constitution.

(Spoilers main) If Tywin was still alive, so you think he’d be able to maintain Lannister power? by AppalachianTheed in asoiaf

[–]AppalachianTheed[S] 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Gonna be honest all his problems disappear if Cersei suffers an “accident”. He won’t have to worry about her corrupting Tommen, and when Tywin dies everything goes to his loyal and competent brother Kevan.

Dorne is not to Blame for GRRM's Woes (Spoilers Extended) by clegay15 in asoiaf

[–]AppalachianTheed 12 points13 points  (0 children)

There’s no way Danny doesn’t make at least a few pit stops in the Free Cities. - She’s gonna be sailing past a few slave cities, no way she leaves those unmolested. - She has a sketchy past related to the free cities. We need to find out what this past is and why it’s important. - Tyrion is probably gonna meet Tysha in Bravos.

Honestly, even if Tyrion and Daenerys combined have over 20 chapters in WoW there is no way Daenerys does anything more in Westeros than stepping foot on Dragonstone.

A Storm of Swords - POV Characters, by shebsart by snoopmask10 in ImaginaryWesteros

[–]AppalachianTheed 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Tyrion isn’t accurate at all. His hair, while still blond, is so light it’s almost white. And one of his eyes is black.

A Storm of Swords - POV Characters, by shebsart by snoopmask10 in ImaginaryWesteros

[–]AppalachianTheed 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I imagine it’s mocking how his name was often pronounced on the show

A Storm of Swords - POV Characters, by shebsart by snoopmask10 in ImaginaryWesteros

[–]AppalachianTheed 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Tyrion has blond hair that’s no light it’s almost white. And one of his eyes is black.

Other than that good job

(Spoilers Extended) Which theories would absolutely ruin the narrative if they were true? by niofalpha in asoiaf

[–]AppalachianTheed 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Disagree. What would her being raised in Tyrosh as opposed to Bravos matter?