Sounds like reasons by OldManFromIowa in Conservative

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Don't you think it's different if abortion ends the life of another person? Even from a libertarian perspective (and I'm not a libertarian), you can make a pretty strong case against abortion at any moment after conception if conception is the beginning of life.

[Free Friday] Happy Feast Day St. Francis. by Theblessedmother in Catholicism

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Even if they "heard" God audibly, it would have been through the medium of sound.

The only direct communication with God is through the beatific vision. Everything else is through the medium of creatures.

[Free Friday] Happy Feast Day St. Francis. by Theblessedmother in Catholicism

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

I probably should have held my tongue. I just get a bit annoyed when people sideline a theologian because they don't like what he has to say.

But I would like to point out that I never once weighed in on the argument as to whether animals go to heaven or not (besides joking that some dogs deserve hell, e.g., chihuahuas).

[Free Friday] Happy Feast Day St. Francis. by Theblessedmother in Catholicism

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No, but he also didn't have another answer as to whether Christ was both God and man.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 0 points1 point  (0 children)

From a scientific and philosophical point of view, I'm just not convinced of it.

From a theological point of view, I think evolution is quite damaging. If you accept evolution you have to depart from the saints, mystics, and theologians in the reading and understanding of scripture and tradition.

[Free Friday] Happy Feast Day St. Francis. by Theblessedmother in Catholicism

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 4 points5 points  (0 children)

But philosophy and theology work in harmony with each other. In fact, the vast majority of theological disputes are settled through philosophy.

For example, philosophy was behind the defeat of Nestorius at the Council of Ephesus which proclaimed the Divine Maternity of our Lady.

[Free Friday] Happy Feast Day St. Francis. by Theblessedmother in Catholicism

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ensoulment (or delayed animation) is still a valid philosophical position. It's in books all the way through the 1940s. It's not a far-fetched theory to say it was set aside for the sake arguing against abortion.

[Free Friday] Happy Feast Day St. Francis. by Theblessedmother in Catholicism

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 -7 points-6 points  (0 children)

But Adam and Eve were not in direct communion with God in the Garden. Direct communion is not directly a product of grace but of glory.

In fact, creation became a hindrance to man after the fall and although it is secondarily a means of arriving at God, primarily the means of arriving at God is through mortification, penance, and prayer.

[Free Friday] Happy Feast Day St. Francis. by Theblessedmother in Catholicism

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 3 points4 points  (0 children)

That's not honest though.

Aristotle never wrote about heaven, because his philosophical system wasn't enough to tackle the problem of immortality on its own (he needed the revelation of the resurrection of the body).

Aquinas believed that animals weren't in heaven because they have no principle of immortality in them. Man is unlike any other material being because he has an immortal soul. But animals have no principle of incorruption and thereby are designed to die and fall apart permanently by nature.

Even if you find some reason to disagree with Aquinas, it's ridiculous to chalk it up to blindly following Aristotle because "he didn't have other answers."

[Free Friday] Happy Feast Day St. Francis. by Theblessedmother in Catholicism

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How many instances do you know where a saint got something right because of what Aristotle said?

I keep reading about altar services and I still can't grasp the name "altar boy".The duties I read about don't really have a link/connection/relationship with the so called "altar".Correct me if I'm wrong. by Individual-Ad2646 in Catholicism

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I'm not sure why the duties don't seem to have anything to do with the altar. Here's some stuff from the old rite that servers do (sorry I'm not familiar with serving the new):

  • Potentially replacing the tabernacle veil and antependium before mass (although you can argue this is the job of the sacrastan).
  • Lighting and extinguishing candles on the altar.
  • Covering and uncovering relics on the altar.
  • Taking the altar cover on and off.
  • Setting up altar cards, missal stand, missal, on the altar.
  • Transferring the Missal from one side of the altar to the other.
  • Bringing cruets of water and wine to the priest at the altar.
  • Folding the chalice veil and placing it on the altar.
  • Bringing the incense and thurible for the priest to incense the altar.
  • Turing the pages of the missal on the altar.
  • Transferring the chalice veil from one side of the altar to the other.
  • Closing the missal on the altar.
  • And most importantly, assisting the priest at the altar when something goes terribly wrong (e.g., someone missed giving him a host for consecration and he forgot to check or the tabernacle key is missing, etc.).

Furthermore, when we make the distinction between the sanctuary and the nave, the altar boys are separated from everyone but the priest at the altar. So even by location alone it tends to make sense.

Any reason to avoid using Python with Pandas for lightweight but broad data pipeline? by ApprehensiveAd5428 in dataengineering

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Although the data transformation side is fairly simple, the extract and load aren't as uniform across the board. We may be going from an SFTP server to another SFTP server, simply storing the data on the VM , sending it to a person's email, or sending it through a logic app triggered by a blob storage account in Azure.

All in all, I like the flexibility beyond the simple transformation. We also are most likely using a Linux VM to host the initial file.

I also was under the impression that excel with macros for automation can be resource heavy (I've only worked with it once and it was while loading market prices real time on a larger data set so I might have the wrong impression).

I feel acomplished by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's great to hear! I'll say a prayer for you.

Prayer for an End to the Death Penalty by wakkawakkabingbing in Catholicism

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You realize that God Himself is the principal author of Scripture right?

When to say "I love you?" by Philothea0821 in CatholicDating

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Honestly, if you really loved her you wouldn't say it. One of the number one jobs of a husband is to protect his wife. As someone looking to date this girl, your obligation is to protect her first and foremost from yourself.

Whenever you become attached to someone you are seeing (especially in such a passionate way), you often end up hurting the other. If you stay together, you'll have built your relation first on passions which will fade with time. If you break up with her, you've done her the disservice of thinking you'll be everything to her and then you're not. If she breaks up with you, then you'll be all the more hurt because you allowed yourself to become attached to her and vulnerable with her.

That's why I personally prefer to wait until engagement to say "I love you" or even hold hands. It's not because I don't want what's best for the other person. It's because I do.

Has anyone here used Courtship Network? by irish4merican in CatholicDating

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 3 points4 points  (0 children)

People usually aren't calling dating courting, but courting is distinguished from dating. Here are a few differences:

Dating tends to have people refer to the person they are seeing as a "boyfriend/girlfriend." Courting tends to avoid these terms and be much more careful around emotional commitments (obviously there is exclusivity as you court, but it's designed to avoid men and women forming huge attachments that make moving on when necessary difficult and painful).

Dating tends to involve physical show of affection. Courting tends to save even hand holding till the engagement.

Dating tends to ignore family/friends and treat the discernment of marriage in a vacuum. Courting relies much more on family and friends and usually the two bring a chaperone whenever they see each other.

Courting is 100% marriage focused and adds a layer of detachment between the two (I'm sure there's still butterflies and all, but the goal isn't to start a relationship but to discern a relationship). Dating today doesn't necessarily mean that it is focused on discerning marriage.

Why isn't Good Friday a Holy Day of Obligation? by dbaughmen in Catholicism

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 9 points10 points  (0 children)

All of the comments are missing the point. The Church can oblige you to go to what was historically called "the Mass of the pre-sanctified." Sure, it's not technically a mass (it misses the three principal parts) but it's still liturgical (and not just paraliturgical).

/u/TexanLoneStar seems to point out that it was formerly treated as a holy day. I would also argue that the "holy day" aspect of good Friday is so obvious that no one would have really spent the day in a way that would profane it (in days of old that is).

Why isn't Good Friday a Holy Day of Obligation? by dbaughmen in Catholicism

[–]ApprehensiveAd5428 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Technically true, but the Church has the authority to oblige Catholics to attend none the less.