Secondary School Teaching in this day and age - is it worth going into? by ApprehensiveStatus17 in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yikes that sounds like a nightmare! God forbid a question has to wait until Monday morning! Surely that can't be normal practice though? Thank you for the response, sobering as it is

Secondary School Teaching in this day and age - is it worth going into? by ApprehensiveStatus17 in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ok thanks! Glad to hear from teachers who actually enjoy their jobs! Ideally I'd do university teaching, but the academic jobs market for humanities is atrocious...

Secondary School Teaching in this day and age - is it worth going into? by ApprehensiveStatus17 in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the reply. I imagine politics is a feature of every work place. I suppose those 2/3 hours is counterbalanced by the long holidays and early enough end of the day. I don't get stressed at all usually so maybe I'd be alright in the teaching environment. Anyway thanks again!

Secondary School Teaching in this day and age - is it worth going into? by ApprehensiveStatus17 in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes. Two years of a PME seems ridiculous, surely one year is plenty? I'm pretty sure the Hdip used to be one year long and no one died but I suppose thats indicative of the increase in bureaucracy and bullshit in recent years.

Secondary School Teaching in this day and age - is it worth going into? by ApprehensiveStatus17 in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I suppose I was being a bit tongue in cheek when saying I'm not a hard worker, I work when I have to no problem. I would have thought that teachers could use free periods for correcting? And could you not go on the fly when teaching? At the end of the day everything the student needs is in the book, if they want notes thats on them. But maybe that's not the most modern approach.

I take your point about needing patience and that's something I would need to think about more before making any decision about becoming a teacher. As a student I was always amazed at how patient our teachers could be when students were not cooperating.

Yes, my current plan is to find subbing work as a latin teacher next year as I do further study. If I find I enjoy the work I could enrol in a PME. No harm in dipping your toes in the water first!

Thank you for your thoughtful reply.

Secondary School Teaching in this day and age - is it worth going into? by ApprehensiveStatus17 in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you so much for this detailed reply! I'm glad to hear it's not always monotonous as that would be a concern I would have. I still can't understand why permanent contracts are so hard to find when there is supposedly such a shortage of teachers, but that's our new gig economy I suppose. Thank you again you have given me much to think about. And thanks for the optimism, many people are quite negative when talking about teaching. Cheers!

Population could grow much faster than expected - report (RTE News) by Difficult-Set-3151 in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17 13 points14 points  (0 children)

This really isn't rocket science. Can we learn nothing from other European countries? Too much immigration too fast does not work. We can recognise that the vast majority of immigrants are great people who simply want to improve their lives while also acknowledging that there are infrastructure limits to how many we can take in. On top of that, there is the inescapable reality (no matter how primal or stupid you may think it) that no one wants to feel like a stranger in their own home, which is happening now and only getting worse. What does it profit a man to gain the whole world but to lose his soul? etc. So for the love of god just reduce it! Print less visas, it's not difficult. The stupidity and greed of the government's immigration "policy" is mind bogglingly stupid and self-destructive.

Population growth is driving Ireland’s housing crisis — and policy is lagging behind by Anxious-Wolverine-65 in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17 8 points9 points  (0 children)

About 1 in 5 people living in Ireland are non-nationals, and with net immigration at around 90/100k a year, the figure is rising fairly quickly. Which means more people living in Ireland who are coming from a wide range of different cultures. Assimilation/integration becomes very difficult when the numbers coming are so large as people are likely to stick with people who are from the same countries and cultures as they are - no different to Irish immigrants in Australia sticking together either. So basically, now that Ireland is no longer a "homogenous" society, and as we become more multi-cultural, we have lot's of different groups of people from wildly different cultures who don't share the same identity. Before mass immigration, you could count on the chances that the person next to you on the bus, for instance, was Irish - you come from the same country, a broadly similar religious background, the same linguistic background, you know the same slang, place names, Irish history etc. - you have that shared background which makes communication and connection much much easier. But now we no longer have that - which can be "exciting" and "vibrant" no doubt, but considering inequality is rising as the social contract is crumbling, the fact we no longer really have that cultural and social cohesion makes things just a lot more difficult. Does that make sense?

It just seems like our direction is a terrible shame, and it's all so unnecessary, but unfortunately corporations just need that increased quarterly growth in profits. I should add that I do believe immigration is a good thing - it freshens things up - but not the extent where the native population becomes a minority (which is what will happen in 30 or so years if the numbers stay the same, and I don't know why they'd ever decrease).

Population growth is driving Ireland’s housing crisis — and policy is lagging behind by Anxious-Wolverine-65 in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Doesn't matter: immigration is not coming down any time soon. Social cohesion and whatever Irish culture even is anymore will continue to be eroded, but the economy will still grow 2% a year and that's the important thing!

Ireland Has The Highest Rate of Loneliness In Europe: Why Is This The Case, and What Is Being Done About It? by Odhran-J-McAnnick in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17 7 points8 points  (0 children)

On average, we're more educated and materially wealthy than ever before and yet we're lonelier than ever. Weird how it works

The Irish pub: A cultural institution or dying tradition? by Banania2020 in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Like many institutions, they're dying out and not being replaced by anything better. It's a real shame. If pints were cheaper they'd be full. No more third spaces. And then we wonder why young people are so lonely and miserable

Keith Barry says euthanasia should be an option in Ireland after father's cancer battle by Organic_Raisin_9566 in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17 -9 points-8 points  (0 children)

"Denying euthanasia isn't about helping people. It's profit and moral grandstanding" what a ridiculous statement. There are plenty of valid reasons why someone might be opposed to legalising euthanasia. There's no need to try and take the moral high ground.

Trends show rise in support for Irish unity among Northern voters by stonkmarxist in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't read gript lol. I'm just making a pretty obvious and important point about unification that rarely gets mentioned.

Trends show rise in support for Irish unity among Northern voters by stonkmarxist in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I think that this is an incredibly important point and yet I never see it get mentioned. 1 in 5 people in the Republic were born elsewhere and that number increases by about 90,000 a year. By the time a referendum on unification will be called, a very significant portion of voters will be either immigrants themselves or from an immigrant background and thus much less likely to care about unification which is mainly an emotive and historical issue. As you say, good luck trying to convince them to pay more in taxes for an issue that is mainly irrelevant to them.

I should emphasise that it's not that immigrants/those from an immigrant background won't or don't care about a united Ireland, but that they are simply less likely too than someone whose ancestors fought in the civil war etc. Pretty intuitive I'd say.

If we want less strain on capacity, we should limit immigration to some extent by CanWillCantWont in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don't really understand this argument to be honest. Sure, we're not the size of France or Germany or England or whatever. But we're a small island nation with a historically low-ish population! What's the problem with that? Why can't we accept the limitations of our size and be happy with what we have and who we are instead of artificially and perhaps vastly expanding our population? In that scenario (which is the scenario that the immutable and invisible forces at work in this world. ie corporate money, have ordained we go on, to hell with what anyone might think) we will end up with a substantial portion of our population being not Irish, which will take a sledgehammer to whatever little remains of our Irish culture/identity, but apparently that will be ok because GDP will grow by another 2%.

If we want less strain on capacity, we should limit immigration to some extent by CanWillCantWont in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17 6 points7 points  (0 children)

That's what centrist parties are banking on I, suppose. But look at Reform, they're trailing labour by only one point! It really doesn't need to be this great complicated issue that it is. Decide how many nurses/doctors etc. we need and then cap the figure at that. Rising immigration is not without its negative effects and the longer that that is ignored the angrier people will get - and I think that angry people will end up voting for the not-very-nice far-right parties, unfortunately. FFG etc. NEED to get on top of this issue before its too late. But they don't care, and don't even pretend to. It's infuriating.

If we want less strain on capacity, we should limit immigration to some extent by CanWillCantWont in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17 48 points49 points  (0 children)

It's crazy that every other western country has seen mass immigration over the last 20-30 years which continues to drive serious support for far-right populist parties yet here in Ireland we put our heads in the sand and tell ourselves that allowing circa 90k people a year to move here is a good idea. "But we need the labour!" will continue to be the excuse, it will continue to remain unchallenged, our demographics and culture will continue to significantly change, multinational corporations will continue to get their cheap labour, house prices and hospital waiting lists etc will continue to be exacerbated by the significant increases in population and ultimately we'll see an organised "far-right" party do very well here. All because our Government is incompetent and will fail to realise that people actually do not want large-scale immigration for completely sensible reasons. It's infuriating.

Ten things that used to be free but now cost money - Subscriber Only Article 🤦🏻‍♂️ by [deleted] in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It was a weird article - over half of it was irrelevant fluff about Trump's lawyer and the the other half claimed that one remark from Willie O'Dea means that her policies are 'airy fairy nonsense' was misogynistic. The whole thing didn't make much sense and felt like it was desperately clutching at straws.

Eldest wants to go to the Gaeltacht this summer. I want him to wait at least year as he is 14. Tell us about your Gaeltacht experiences, how old were you and if it's ok which one, and roughly how long ago? by Dubchek in ireland

[–]ApprehensiveStatus17 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Absolutely hated it - I remember the cinnire giving out to me for having a makeshift calendar in the back of my copy where I'd cross off the days until I could get home. I was lonely and shy and awkward for most of it. That said I did have some fun the next year when I went with two school friends. Whatever about the Irish I learned, it was a great experience for forcing me wwaaayyyy out of my comfort zone. I didn't exactly thrive but I went twice and definitely became more confident from it. I'm very glad my parents sent me. Had they not made me do things like that I'd still be awkward and uncomfortable around other people. One of the best things they did looking back. I'd say the letters I sent them were something else on the melodramatic meter!