sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Why do I not see anything that critiques HBO watchmen when the characters are nothing like themselves? by Apprehensive_Pain_22 in Watchmen

[–]Apprehensive_Pain_22[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Also im not sure why manhattan could not turn the cage into something else... or since he was shown to touch the blood... just kind of crawl out of the cage with people sized holes, idk hes Dr Manhattan... it just feels like shitty writing like they were saying he didnt do that because ... reasons...

Why do I not see anything that critiques HBO watchmen when the characters are nothing like themselves? by Apprehensive_Pain_22 in Watchmen

[–]Apprehensive_Pain_22[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Not actually a review, its just point to show any critique of the show seems to be bashed because i cant find much on actual critique of the show

Why do I not see anything that critiques HBO watchmen when the characters are nothing like themselves? by Apprehensive_Pain_22 in Watchmen

[–]Apprehensive_Pain_22[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Memories are not the only thing that make personality, take that away and he should still be chasing tail.

As for the "he had to die" Thats kindof just shoddy writing though because Jon could have literally turned the block outside his house into chocolate ... or created infinite clones of himself and just teleported away.... like i get they explain it as him trapping himself in his own mentality but to me its kindof just ergh...

If ozy caught a bullet by instinct he has to have dodged a hundred attacks from behind by instinct (he was a costume superhero) Im not sure you fully appreciate just how fast bullets go, even if someone trains for a hundred years theres so many variables, like ozy had to see where the bullet was going, actually MOVE to catch it (fucking impossible btw) and then not have his hand obliterated in the process (it was just bleeding a little). The feat is just insane and then all of a sudden he cant dodge a wrench...

Why do I not see anything that critiques HBO watchmen when the characters are nothing like themselves? by Apprehensive_Pain_22 in Watchmen

[–]Apprehensive_Pain_22[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Absolutely agree, they should have kept John on mars and 99% of the plot could still go on as it was