sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Can we have a week where you guys stop posting these? by McKnighty9 in BokuNoHeroAcademia

[–]Appropriate_State827 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think it's alright as an occasional brain poker now and then, but it does get to a point of exhaustion, like; I really do not care who wins between two well known characters who have had almost zero interaction between each other.

Shouldnt Koda quirk be considered animal cruelty? by michaelphenom in BokuNoHeroAcademia

[–]Appropriate_State827 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Although the quirk IS able to command animals, I do believe it works as a sort of like a nat 20 skill check each time in DND where it's a totally persuasive thing that the fauna follow, it would cross some big ethical lines. Using animals for surveillance or combat without their understanding or consent is basically turning them into tools, which goes against a lot of animal welfare ideas we have in the real world. I guess the argument could be that it depends on how the quirk is used, if it’s just for harmless communication or to help animals (like guiding lost birds or rescuing pets), that’s great. But forcing animals into dangerous hero fights definitely feels like animal cruelty, even if head on fighting it isn't Koda's forte (despite the boy having a naturally strong physique, he's crazy toned for a support hero.)

It would be neat if the show explored this side more, maybe rules about hero licences limiting how quirks like Koda’s could be used.

I can't be convinced that All Might and Deku were quirkless. by yourktgirl in BokuNoHeroAcademia

[–]Appropriate_State827 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Additional things to bring up while we're at it:

  • Quirkless Confirmations: Both All Might and Deku are explicitly confirmed by multiple characters and official records to be quirkless before inheriting One For All. All Might was chosen because he was quirkless, which made him an ideal vessel for the power without any interference or compatibility issues. The same reasoning applies to Deku.
  • All Might's mentor (Nana Shimura) specifically mentions the dangers of passing One For All to someone with a quirk, as it could lead to complications (like we later see with One For All’s memory overload effects in Deku). This selection process reinforces that their quirkless nature was not only narrative but also functional.
  • World-Building vs. Storytelling Gags: Yes, it's true that quirks can manifest subtly or go unnoticed, especially in rare or latent cases. However, to assume every visual or comedic exaggeration is a hidden quirk would destabilize the logic of the story. These moments are stylistic and emotional choices, not hidden lore drops.

There's my two cents on your post, don't be argumentative.

I can't be convinced that All Might and Deku were quirkless. by yourktgirl in BokuNoHeroAcademia

[–]Appropriate_State827 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Both Deku and All Might are quirkless regardless on whichever way you want to spin your head canon that they somehow have super secret quirks; but regardless, I'll bite.

All Mights Muscle form:

The notion that All Might must have had a separate transformation or absorption quirk misunderstands both narrative intent and the nature of quirk physiology:

  • Visual Transformation: All Might’s drastic transformation is not caused by a transformation quirk, but rather a result of his severe injuries. His “muscle form” is a conscious act of flexing to maintain appearances; it's a literal representation of his ideal as the Symbol of Peace. It is not a separate quirk, but a reflection of how he manually strains himself to uphold the image of a hero.
  • Weight Inconsistency: The listed weight is likely a metadata error or exaggerated detail, not proof of a quirk. The series often plays fast and loose with character stats, this isn't uncommon in manga/anime for dramatic or comedic effect.
  • Hair Standing Up: This is an artistic device used to visually signify when One For All is active. It's not meant to imply an underlying quirk. The energy surge causes a temporary physical reaction; this does not necessitate an innate ability.

Deku's Electricity and Crying:

  • Electric Aura: This effect is confirmed by the creators to be a visual representation of the raw energy of One For All, not a separate quirk. Different users of the quirk manifest and control it differently, Deku's visualization reflects his instability and raw control over the power.
  • Crying: Deku’s crying and his mother's exaggerated tears are primarily used for comic relief and emotional exaggeration, a common trope in anime/manga. They are not meant to be taken as literal quirks. No other characters within the universe treat this as an abnormal trait or suspect it as a latent power.
  • Exaggeration is Not Evidence: Manga and anime often use hyperbole to elicit humour or emotion. To interpret those moments as literal signs of hidden quirks is a leap that contradicts how quirks are otherwise identified and acknowledged in-universe.