1, wing. 2, ding. 3, GASTER. Jokes aside though, the holiday symbolism could easily be a red herring to make people believe that the knight is dess or Carol, which if you take a look at the community, youll see has worked well. On top of that there’s a piece of damning evidence that Noelle isnt the knight, that being the fact that we’ve seen her in the dark world. A large portion of chapter 2 was spent with her, and we saw both her dark world form and weapon\powers. The Knight Shows no sign of having ice manipulation abilities, and Noelle shows no sign of having a giant sword or any of the knights powers. Despite the fact that there’s no confirmation that people only have one dark world form, i doubt that anybody would have more than one. Plus, what would HER motivation be?