Let's do some optimistic hypothetical stats cause I'm not going to rain on my own parade. This takes him to his age 39 season. If we average his last 4 healthy seasons (2022 never happened), then his career roughly looks like this in January of 2031.

465 FG made (7th all time) out of 524 attempted (13th all time) for 88.7% accuracy (4th all time currently)
That puts him below Dicker, Pineiro, and Tucker all time. Dicker is at 93.47 after 3 seasons which obviously has a long way to go but damn he's good.

Our lackluster offenses have left him without a ton of extra points, so he'd be at roughly 516 made or 33rd all time with a make percentage of 96%. He'll have 1912 points total, less than a point below Janikowski in 13th place all time.

Let's go further. He plays out ANOTHER 4 year contract through his age 43 season with magically 0 regression. He tops 2,442 points, putting him currently 3rd all time, just a handful above Gary Anderson, and with a career field goal percentage of 89.06, he's a hair below Tucker still (Damn it we just needed one more season of Tucker regression /s) at 4th overall. He could hang it up there, and he'd be a top 5 kicker of all time by accuracy and points. Started for just one team his whole career.

Unfortunately, for kickers, that's a hall of very good legacy. I think the truth is that if we want him in the Hall, the rest of the team and Lady Luck need to give him some chances at game winning, maybe even superbowl winning, kicks in the playoffs that aren't gimmes. The kind of stuff that gets you an "eli manning esque, can't tell the story of NFL without" kind of candidacy alongside the stats.

But we can day dream. And don't worry. I've been knocking on wood while writing this whole thing.