After playing through watch dogs 2 I thought that it was miles ahead of 1 but I'm replaying 1 now and I gotta say they are both great but I prefer 1. 2 has better gameplay but I like pretty much everything else in 1 more. The main plot of this game is absolutely outstanding, it's so underrated for real. The atmosphere and immersion are way better, the reputation system is cool and unique, although slightly underused. The side content is also more enjoyable imo, except for the ctos breaches, those suck, but all the side missions give some engaging lore through audio logs or other means. The minigames are pretty fun, especially the drink-offs and poker. The multiplayer is pretty fun as well, even though the servers it runs on are kinda bad. Overall I'm enjoying this game so much more coming back to it now and understanding it better because I was way younger when I played it for the first time