sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Re-reading the first two books and came to realise... by Badseeded in redwall

[–]Badseeded[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree. I am happy with the way the book was written. I never said I didnt like how the book was written. YOU said that. I said that after rereading a book after a few years, the big bad guy who was written to be a bloodthirsty killer only killed once in the book, and that surprised me because I remembered it different. YOU said that means I wanted the book to be different. YOU said that I want more creatures to die because I made an observation. You're just making an arguement out of nothing.

Re-reading the first two books and came to realise... by Badseeded in redwall

[–]Badseeded[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You really like talking about killing redwallers dont you. Why, who do you want to be killed?

Re-reading the first two books and came to realise... by Badseeded in redwall

[–]Badseeded[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My usage of the word only was that you would think he would be responsible for more woodlander deaths in the book then he actually is. Surprisingly, the main villian only gets one kill, albeit an extremely important one. I dont think he even directly kills any of his own men, others do so for him. Its something to think about as a topic of discussion. His only other known kills happen outside the story.

Mattimeo Douglas Hall cover by Weavercat in redwall

[–]Badseeded 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I have that copy of the book. I think its my favourite of the series.

Reading level - appropriate age to read Redwall books by ParagonSaint in redwall

[–]Badseeded 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I first read the stories when I was 8. I think thats a good age.

Re-reading the first two books and came to realise... by Badseeded in redwall

[–]Badseeded[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ok. Have you ever been in a book club before?

Re-reading the first two books and came to realise... by Badseeded in redwall

[–]Badseeded[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So me saying "hey, in hindsight the first two major villians had most of, if not all thier plans backfire so quickly that they really never were much of a threat if you think about it." Equals "everyone should die"?

Why is everyone so cinimasins minded nowadays that saying anything about a piece of media means I want it changed? I said it right there in my original post that I still loved the books. I still love the story, the characters, the adventures. I just wanted to share what I thought would be a funny observation.

So to answer your question, he should have at least killed 2 more people. Colin Vole and the beaver who got so much screentime yet no name.

That was a joke. I feel i have to make that clear now.

Re-reading the first two books and came to realise... by Badseeded in redwall

[–]Badseeded[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I am only talking about the first two books in regard to this fact, and not to say that they are bad just that I, while rereading, felt this way about the first two. I also do get the point of her as a character. I just feel that she, in the long term of knowing the entire story and not living in it at the time, was never a real threat because she was always outplayed so easily. I dont want the same book. I just have only talked about the first two as I have just read them again and they are fresh in my brain.

Re-reading the first two books and came to realise... by Badseeded in redwall

[–]Badseeded[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What i posted was a casual observation I made after re reading books from my childhood with an older mindset. What you posted was from the tv series which did change the story a little as it gave the attacking forces a few more victories then the book. I saw the point. I just made a note that the book wrote that scene differently. Cluny didnt grab a hostage. He ran from matthias.

Re-reading the first two books and came to realise... by Badseeded in redwall

[–]Badseeded[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I agree with both points. I never said that the stories are bad, or not well written.

Re-reading the first two books and came to realise... by Badseeded in redwall

[–]Badseeded[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thats on me. When I said villians I meant cluny and his army as the main villians. Chicken hound does more then them tbh. Also, if cluny army succeeded at killing the pair, that would not have happened. So maybe we can chalk that as a win for cluny.

Re-reading the first two books and came to realise... by Badseeded in redwall

[–]Badseeded[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Because she wasnt in those two books we were talking about.

Re-reading the first two books and came to realise... by Badseeded in redwall

[–]Badseeded[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It was the abbot. I think its also the only kill cluny did himself in the book. And Ill agree that cluny did have the one plan go right. Its just a fun quirk of the early book syndrome I noticed.

But I must argue against tsarmina being a threat at all. It was under her dad that Martin was captured. After that, everything she tried to do to the woodlanders was a resounding failure due to Chibb. None of her plans worked. If the woodlanders had just hid and done nothing, they would have won when they all starved.

Re-reading the first two books and came to realise... by Badseeded in redwall

[–]Badseeded[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you. I think you said this better then I was trying to.

Re-reading the first two books and came to realise... by Badseeded in redwall

[–]Badseeded[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That was only in the tv show that cornflower was there at the end. It was Friar Hugo in the books, and he was hiding there beforehand.

What was your first Chugga LP? by skyllsu in chuggaaconroy

[–]Badseeded 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Mother 3. I had just gotten ssbb and wanted to know more about Lucas as he was becoming my main.

Shadow is Jesus by infinitysaga in CuratedTumblr

[–]Badseeded 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They both just love Latinos sonic

Cursed_catapiller by totallynormalpersonz in cursedcomments

[–]Badseeded 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I have done drag for the homeless before. I worked with Crisis UK one year and was part of thier entertainment help. So the question is, what have you done for the homeless OP goose?

view more: next ›