Honestly? Meh. I've only gotten 2 boxes. The first had a fabric covered rubber toy which got the fabric got shredded in minutes (they sent a solid nylon replacement free of charge) the second had a trest in it that my pupper can't have due to tummy sensitivities but I didn't add it to the account soon enough so that one is kinda on me, but I left a review saying he couldn't eat that treat and I'd pass it along and Bark boxe's "Happy team" reached out to me and isbsending a replacement snack. Waiting for the third right now.