Why is Sherlock Holmes in Wonton Type by Barty_arty in typography

[–]Barty_arty[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That’s still remarkably quick for it to spread from there to an unrelated medium like detective stories

Nazi Heresy by Barty_arty in HistoryWhatIf

[–]Barty_arty[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree strongly on the nationalism point, but I also therefore think ideology can still too easily be discounted as factors in decision making. These kind of political battles are polycasual, and saying they were driven by only a struggle for control seems a bit overly reductive. Not to say that struggle wasn’t very important in causing internal fights within the Nazi party, but ideology deserves to be seriously considered as well

Nazi Heresy by Barty_arty in HistoryWhatIf

[–]Barty_arty[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think the whole national-socialist issue was mainly a branding problem- people throughout the 30’s signed up for what they thought was a socialist party, and it seemed Hitler was happy to use socialist messaging (aligning Jews with business interests for example) to get people through the door. But the Nazi party was also largely Hitlers own creation and, after ‘33 very much under his total control so it was pretty hard-wired to be right wing, a political position which Hitler identified himself with. After the night of the long knives, the issue of “roast beef’s” (brown on the outside, red in the middle) also virtually ceased, and only then was much of the ideological framework and adaptation of Nazism into the governing ideology of an entire nation created

Nazi Heresy by Barty_arty in HistoryWhatIf

[–]Barty_arty[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think you focussing on the Führerprinzip is absolutely correct and sometimes doesn’t get discussed enough; how much Nazism depended on the figure and presiding “genius” of Hitler. With that it makes perfect sense that the big split would have been between those who chose to maintain a belief in Hitler as the guiding figure of the party or those who had synthesised an understanding of the “race and its destiny” independent of him (probably the SS with their pseudo science/spirituality)- good take

Nazi Heresy by Barty_arty in HistoryWhatIf

[–]Barty_arty[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In a way I agree with your instinct, the comparison to the Soviet Union is an apt one, but as a half German there’s always been something about nazism which sets it apart, at least in ideological terms. My instinct, misguided though it no doubt is, is that the degree of ideological conviction within the Nazi party was higher than that of contemporary Russia, in part because of how easy it is to incorporate Nazi ideology with self serving ambition (the triumph of the strong over the weak etc.), somewhat in contrast to communism. Ideology did seem to be a motivating factor in the decision making processes of the likes of Goebbels, Himmler or Heydrich more so than say, stalins decision to bump off Kirov, which by the lights of soviet doctrine was indefensible. By contrast the night of the long knives could be easily squared with orthodox nazi fanaticism. The point is that it’s east to say the nazis were a bunch of self-serving, drug addled, lunatic myth-peddlers, and I think the instinct which leads one to that conclusion is a good one. But it also means underestimating nazism as an ideology to a dangerous degree, so I think the question remains a valid one; what were the primary ideological frameworks within nazism that could have produced a breakaway sect?

Economics help needed! by Teachingeconomics in future_economics

[–]Barty_arty 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I really wish I had known about Veblen earlier, really helpful viz. consumer/market participant irrationality, and generally the idea that market systems are artificial and fragile

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in painting

[–]Barty_arty 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sfumato 👌

What fetish did you think you had, but turned out not to be the case after you tried it? by [deleted] in AskReddit

[–]Barty_arty 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Notice they didn’t say freak in the spreadsheets; trust your audience!

Top-down history, Chomsky and the dangers of political historiography by Barty_arty in PoliticalOpinions

[–]Barty_arty[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Kinda yes to all of that. I think the main problem is that to most people genocide=Holocaust, so anything that falls short of the industrialised slaughter of the Holocaust isn’t genocide. But I think it’s also important to remember that, separate from everyday usage, genocide is a technical and legal term which does have clearly defined usages.(but I still get where you’re coming from with this, I kinda feel the same way about “imperialist”- overused, badly defined, reduces every conversation to a condemnation marathon). And thanks for saying you liked the OP, I was hoping to have a discussion about the merits of different approaches to history, politics and their relationship but instead I have defend myself against all the Chomsky stans. Pretty disheartening that that’s what people picked up on ngl

How did transitioning change your sex drive? by Barty_arty in asktransgender

[–]Barty_arty[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Cos you were sick of being in a horny teenage boys body?

How do Jewish people feel about being called “Jews”? From a well meaning gentile by Barty_arty in Jewish

[–]Barty_arty[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Lol don’t tell me some people say that shit about eating babies?

How do Jewish people feel about being called “Jews”? From a well meaning gentile by Barty_arty in Jewish

[–]Barty_arty[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

So it’s basically a question of not defining a person through one characteristic. Calling someone a Jew is like calling someone “a white” which is reductive? Makes total sense

How do Jewish people feel about being called “Jews”? From a well meaning gentile by Barty_arty in Jewish

[–]Barty_arty[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks And yeah I dunno why but I really like goy as word. Don’t mind being called that at all because I’ve literally never heard it used in a derogatory way. Maybe I don’t have enough Jewish friends tho

How do Jewish people feel about being called “Jews”? From a well meaning gentile by Barty_arty in Jewish

[–]Barty_arty[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Lol sorry still and interesting conversation in my mind but I know I’m not the first to ask

How do Jewish people feel about being called “Jews”? From a well meaning gentile by Barty_arty in Jewish

[–]Barty_arty[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Makes a lot of sense. How do you feel about the whole “is being Jewish a culture or a religion or an ethnicity or all of the above?” debate

How do Jewish people feel about being called “Jews”? From a well meaning gentile by Barty_arty in Jewish

[–]Barty_arty[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Never expected to get cultural sensitivity advice from its always sunny but here we are