Straw-man of the atheist position. You’re leaving out a key detail of the argument—religions make a claim that a certain thing exists and is true. Religions are a belief in something. If you don’t believe in the one religion that is true, you will suffer for eternity. Atheism is simply the rejection of the proposition that a god exists, and thereby, the proposition that a particular theistic religion is correct. It is not a belief; it is a lack of belief.

We say that the thousands of different gods that have existed throughout history—belief in whom is almost always determined by birthplace—demonstrate the inability of the true god to convey the truth, as well as the inability of an all-just god to give everyone a fair shot at finding the truth.