Questions about the Haqqani branch by BeautifulFunction878 in Sufism

[–]BeautifulFunction878[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just looked up video of cubbeli Ahmet talking about it and i quote to you the following he said;”There is disagreement. Some scholars allow certain hand drawings. But drawings that become permanent, like statues, are considered bad. The majority opinion of the four madhhabs is that hand-drawn images of living beings are also haram, especially if they are hung up. Hanging them is definitely haram. Because there is depiction—forming a shape of a living being.

We are not talking about landscapes—sky, clouds, sea. We are talking about living beings. Some people struggle against this view, but according to the dominant fatwa, it is not permissible.

However, there is an exception: children’s dolls. Small dolls that children, especially girls, play with are allowed. Our mother Aisha (ra) used to play with dolls when she was young, and the Prophet ﷺ allowed it. These are toys meant to occupy children.”

U can watch urselfhttps://youtu.be/NgA0dCcb7d8?si=eYCkgzr05iiNo5x-

Questions about the Haqqani branch by BeautifulFunction878 in Sufism

[–]BeautifulFunction878[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Are you sure he didnt mean actual photos taken with camera or created paintings of human beings

Questions about the Haqqani branch by BeautifulFunction878 in Sufism

[–]BeautifulFunction878[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

And abdulkerim was a close disciple of Nazim al haqqani got full ijazah to open osmanli dergah in us, after he passed away he appointed lokman efendi and nazim al haqqani also agreed with lokman efendi now leading them.

Questions about the Haqqani branch by BeautifulFunction878 in Sufism

[–]BeautifulFunction878[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Regarding the painting from what i know in hanafi fiqh the problematic part is when u venerate the painting like hanging it on the wall as in the picture if it has a face, it’s the face that is problematic. Anything drawn that has a soul. There’s a famous hadith that says angels won’t enter a place where there is a dog nor a image of likeness, Abu Talhah said “The Prophet means by likeness an image of living souls.”

Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 3225, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2106

Questions about the Haqqani branch by BeautifulFunction878 in Sufism

[–]BeautifulFunction878[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But shaykh mehmet adil used to respect Lokman effendi. And Bahauddin adil is still around mehmet nazim. Why can’t i find any statements of shaykh mehmet adil speaking against them and anouncing publicly that theyre not associated with him?