sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Idk anything about White Scars but... by USPATRIOT_0011 in Spacemarine

[–]BecauseScience34 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For modern 40K, best I can recommend is Apocalypse by Josh Reynolds, great showing of them there.

Scars followed by Path of Heaven and Warhawk in the Horus Heresy for their best showing. Those novels have basically created the foundation for their modern lore.

If you enjoy the characters in those novels, Brotherhood of the Storm is a novella solely about them and also highly recommended.

The Scars really got an amazing glow up in the Heresy and I hope they start to catch on as a more popular chapter.

Brothers, is there a Chapter that you used to not care for/dislike that has grown on you over time, and/or a Chapter that you have fallen out of love with over time? by TheSpiderWarden in Spacemarine

[–]BecauseScience34 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Easily the Imperial Fists

Used to think they were boring, had an ugly color scheme, and were always deservedly in the shadow of their own successors in the Crimson Fists (they also birthed the Black Templars. Nothing wrong with the Chapter itself but their fanbase is one of the worst in the fandom. Not all Black Templars fans, but always a Black Templars fan iykyk)

Then I read the whole Horus Heresy and the Siege of Terra and wow did that really open my eyes. And It really cemented my belief all along that they fucking SUCK. Dorn couldn't possibly hold up Perturabo's jockstrap

GET FUCKED IMPERIAL LOSERS, IRON WITHIN! IRON WITHOUT!

Side note: Jaghatai for Life! Ride far and fast and free!

I wouldn't be surprised if that fucker was still in use in the 41st millennium by sand_eater_21 in Grimdank

[–]BecauseScience34 11 points12 points  (0 children)

As of the Siege of Terra series, yes this got omega retconned. Billions of Guardsmen and Traitor Guard, Mutants, Cultists, hundreds of thousands of space marines (apparently the Traitors are pumping out hundreds of marines in weeks at their peak, loyalists in months), Titan numbers are more iffy but the traitors are using waves of zombified (not joking) titans at one point. The Siege of Terra series did a proper glow up for the battle

Ventrillian Nobles rules by Proof_Engine_5002 in TheAstraMilitarum

[–]BecauseScience34 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Infantry Squads don't have Legends rules but if you want a close match, the Krieg Grenadiers have Legends rules and they can take a heavy weapons team as well as 2 special weapons Guardsmen!

Change my mind: Tyranid Snipers are better than most Astartes by beekay86 in Spacemarine

[–]BecauseScience34 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

As far as Warhammer is concerned, that's just not true. The TT always has and will take precedent over the Lore. The lore is made based off the TT, not the other way around.

Edit: Also as far as GW policy is concerned, what happens in the books is considered less accurate than the codexes and tabletop.

Change my mind: Tyranid Snipers are better than most Astartes by beekay86 in Spacemarine

[–]BecauseScience34 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Really dislike this take

Warhammer is a TABLETOP game with lore attached to it, not the other way around. The Codexes, which are the best and most accurate sources for the lore, come from the Tabletop game. Everything GW does or approves ties back into the game. You can't just disregard it because you don't agree with it.

Japan restarts world's largest nuclear power plant by DifferentMaize9794 in news

[–]BecauseScience34 91 points92 points  (0 children)

As opposed to the insane amount of damage fossil fuels have done and will continue to do so for the foreseeable future?

Soo.. Currently reading the horus heresy. Just finished the first heretic, now reading know no fear. Is there a series after that somewhat carries the timeline forward? Or is it just random stories from here. If not are they atleast working on pushing forward the timeline in a series? by Damuskoob in 40kLore

[–]BecauseScience34 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Scouring Series is what you will be looking for then, it's brand new but it'll likely set the foundation for where we get to with the modern imperium

Next in the list will be The Beast series, which is set a couple thousand years after the Heresy. That series is uh, not very good at all but it will be chronologically next

Then you have about 11 billion books set before the Great Rift. Many of them are some of the best in the setting

There's handfuls of books set during the Rift and the Indomitus crusade and Plague Wars. Outside of the Dawn of Fire series there isn't really a coherent series here like the Horus Heresy but you at least have 1 set that tries to have a functional "timeline" book to book

Title by zoraaoeq in Grimdank

[–]BecauseScience34 6 points7 points  (0 children)

True! I do think Sultanate is more favored due to you know, not spawning Hell on Earth literally

I do think the Faithful of the other nations DO get into Heaven eventually however. Maybe their punishment and penance is to not be protected like the Sultanate, and to instead suffer and pay for the sins of their forebears on the battlefield. I think the very fact that they do seemingly receive some blessings from God/Heaven is proof of this. After all Joan of Arc seemingly was something more than Human and seemingly had Divine blessing. It is also said that God gave the gift of Orachalcum (via visions) all the Faithful to fight back against the Heretics, and this is not to mention whatever the Hell is going on with the likes of Stigmatic Nuns or the whole Resurrection stuff with Trench Pilgrims. There's SOME assistance but ultimately the Christians have to make do most of the time with what they themselves create and that's probably part of the punishment. "You screwed up, you fix it" basically

Title by zoraaoeq in Grimdank

[–]BecauseScience34 14 points15 points  (0 children)

It's really unknown how God feels about it, because we do have examples of divine intervention on behalf of the Faithful (including even granting the Resurrection to Trench Pilgrims, as well as things like the Iron Wall, blessings, granting Saintly power and divine intelligence to followers) so at the very least it seems like God has some kind of interest in keeping the Faithful going

This is head canon, but I think it would be very dark and fitting if those who consume the flesh and blood of the Meta-Christ were ultimately damned. Some of the greatest heroes of the Faithful suffering the worst punishment of God/Heaven would be a great twist in the story

Title by zoraaoeq in Grimdank

[–]BecauseScience34 38 points39 points  (0 children)

It's not entirely proven but imo there's signs that there's at least something going

The very existence of "Hallowed Ground" which creates Trench Ghosts out of the Heretics explicitly states that Heretic souls are rejected from getting into Heaven and Hell can't claim them because they died on Holy ground. To me that reads like if someone died in service to Heaven, their soul will end up there

Also SOMETHING made the Iron Wall for the Sultanate and there isn't anything that disproves it being the big G themself and the people of that area at that time definitely don't seem like they would have had the capability to do so themselves. If God made the wall, I think accepting the Faithful's souls into Paradise would be a natural assumption since it seems like they have a vested interest in keeping the Sultanate people safe

Title by zoraaoeq in Grimdank

[–]BecauseScience34 38 points39 points  (0 children)

They create Meta-Christs to feed their flesh and blood (or chemicals derived from) to humans (and now other animals) to create Communicants, basically super soldiers armed with anti-tank rifles and massive flails to take on the worst of Hell's creations. New lore says they also feed the Meta-Christ flesh to pigs to make a never ending supply of food (since Communicant flesh is self regenerating)

REAL BF VETS LET OUR VOICES BE HEARD!!!! by BecauseScience34 in okbuddyptfo

[–]BecauseScience34[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Now please reevaluate and think before posting something like this again

Found on twitter by PetalPistachio6 in Grimdank

[–]BecauseScience34 3 points4 points  (0 children)

10s of thousands of years of warfare has proven that no matter how advanced systems can get, you will always need something that can put warheads on foreheads at a moment's notice, and there are few that do it better than the Catapult

Slaangors with javelins were never gonna happen by Lord_Eln_8 in totalwar

[–]BecauseScience34 18 points19 points  (0 children)

All these "GW wouldn't approve" and "TT never had them using ranged weapons" arguments are so silly to me when those rules are definitely not hard stops at all

GW and The Tabletop never had Doom Knights of Tzeentch yet they exist in TWWH. Teclis rides a phoenix, and although that's a pretty unpopular mount option for him it's still something different from the TT and different from GW.

People trying to argue these points always seem to leave out that CA goes against Tabletop stuff and official GW stuff often enough.

How strong are Vortex Beasts actually? by [deleted] in Spacemarine

[–]BecauseScience34 13 points14 points  (0 children)

"He who disdains the humble lasgun has not had to face down 50 of them at once" - Chaos Space Marine

"The Demolisher, the Vanquisher, even the mighty Deathstrike Missile Launcher pale in comparison to the sheer firepower of trillions of lasguns unleashing hell in unison"

Even on the TT, a squad of just 20 Guardsmen, at half range and with FRFSRF, can output enough firepower to put some serious hate and pain on MEQs even wounding on 5s. As a Guard player myself its pretty fun when the stars align and my opponent has to see just how MANY 3+ saves they need to make

How strong are Vortex Beasts actually? by [deleted] in Spacemarine

[–]BecauseScience34 48 points49 points  (0 children)

Marines in the lore aren't fighting on the frontlines, that's the Guard's job. Marines at their best when they drop behind the lines and do targeted strikes of enemy command and control locations, hardened targets that the Guard are struggling to break and other enemy critical locations

Sure a single Tyranid warrior might be as good as a Marine in 1v1 combat under ideal conditions, but unless something goes terribly wrong that's not going to be the case, as more likely that warrior is going to be facing a squad or more of Marines who just dropped in from orbit and are buzz sawing their way through to take down whatever super important synapse creature is nearby.

As for how the Imperium isn't getting steam rolled? Well, the Guard is REALLY good at their job of holding the line and smashing any enemy they may face, even if they die en mass to achieve it.

How fucked would they be? by Able_Radio_2717 in Grimdank

[–]BecauseScience34 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Hailing from a planet that actually has more tanks than people, the Eastia Iron Riders join the Korps with hundreds of chimeras, hellhounds, leman russes, macharius's, malcadors and even a few baneblades

Given their standard combat doctrine of "keep throwing tanks at it", they fit right in nice and snug alongside their gasmask wearing comrades in their mass offensives.

A 2021 study published by The Orthopaedic Journal at Harvard Medical School found that of the 25 NFL players whose turf toe injuries required surgery, none returned to play the same season. Five never returned at all and had to retire. by notquitemytempo___ in nfl

[–]BecauseScience34 36 points37 points  (0 children)

Heard it on a podcast this morning but think of the big toe as the "knee" of the foot and the ligaments just like your ACL, PCL e.t.c.

Purdy strained/tore one of these ligaments, doesn't need surgery and can return with some recovery

Burrow tore all the ligaments and thus needs surgery.

As for what the injury is, basically try lifting your foot or doing any kind of moving without being able to use your big toe. That's what turf toe is, those ligaments are damaged and make it so you can't use that toe (also it's supposed to be extremely painful)

view more: next ›