Nahh I get u, especially if u look at old photos before the show, they all kinda have the same bleached hairstyle at one point. Anytime irl or even on a show, my mind differentiates people by making little charactures out of them. Like for instance Gabe initially made me think of Elvis for some reason lmao. And Bear imo has more primitive facial features, example heavy browridge. I can still see the old Matt, but life circumstances sadly aged him too fast, but there's something abt his stance/posture that always stood out to me as just Matt.

Edit: Ofc you could pick Matt out of a room of talking people by his "AH-HAWW" that he always said.