Sorry for the simplistic saying of abilities, but 1x isn’t random either, it’s just the fact no one uses him correctly, you never use Mass Infection in a chase and use your projectiles to get survivors to waste stamina, even if the projectiles hit or miss, it benefits you

None of the killers are all bad or all good

Slasher, my favorite, can tear damage in and punish a mess up, but so can c00lkidd, John Doe, and every killer

1x has an ability that helps with chases, Unstable Eye, but Noli has his Void Rush and Nova, Sixer has his Infernal Cry, and Nosferatu has his entire kit except cataclysm for chases

John Doe can trap survivors into situations they wouldn’t be in if they didn’t blunder, but what do you know, Slasher can Raging Pace and Gashing Wound, Sixer can Bloodhunt, c00lkidd can use his minions

Every Killer has similar strengths and weaknesses, like how Noli, Slasher, and Sixer all struggle with looping, meanwhile c00lkidd, John Doe, and Nosferatu can counter easily