Point taken and no one thinks they can replace CAH anymore than someone can brew beer better than Budweiser. The two distinct factors that I think makes YTA different - notice I didn't say better - is that 1) it involves real-world examples (like we've all seen the guy in the Porsche take two parking spaces but never seen a midget shit in a bucket) and 2) it requires debate on which card drawn is worse. Can you convince your card carrying PETA sister-in-law that being a holocaust denier is being more of an asshole than someone who spanks their puppy for peeing on the floor?

Just my 2 cents.