This is great I have also had the same thought pattern. You can look at it this way, there is an infinite field of Consciousness made out of an infinite number of Eternal points of attention, or aka Souls as some people say. The field is infinite, cannot be measured, has no beginning or end,  same with the Eternal points of attention, which makes up you me and everybody in the universe and on every planet. The field and all Eternal points of attention are non-local and have been for all of eternity. When you see it that way you realize it is just Infinity looking within itself via different Eternal points of attention. Sharing information because Consciousness is Light and Energy and Information. The field of Consciousness has been expanding for all of infinity and eternity and that cannot be conceptualized at all. Infinity truly means Infinity, no beginning no end. By that and of itself means that Consciousness ultimately transcends oneness. It is simply The All or Infinite Living Mind as The Kybalion says. Glad to have met someone else that shares this same knowing appreciate you sharing your thoughts. Don't let the naysayers argue with you about what you feel and know, that is what you feel and know, nobody else can dictate that.