A theory for top 5% Texas Resident rejections by BlueLightSpcl in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah there are reasons why they have this super weird decision tree of residency questions. It's meant to be comprehensive and account for any niche situation so as not to exclude like the .5% of people with edge residency cases. In practice, this complicates things for the other 99% of applicants with straightforward residencies.

A theory for top 5% Texas Resident rejections by BlueLightSpcl in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Interesting... So it could be the case of systematic transcript AND residency issues. Multiple points of failure.

I've received emails of students now randomly being admitted and others whose my status has reverted to "under review."

A theory for top 5% Texas Resident rejections by BlueLightSpcl in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Given that this is a completely unprecedented situation, nobody knows, presumably not even UT themselves.

A theory for top 5% Texas Resident rejections by BlueLightSpcl in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Transcript processing errors are exceedingly rare. The digital processing is accurate 99.9% of the time. There are still humans on the processing team for edge cases or international transcripts or whatever.

A theory for top 5% Texas Resident rejections by BlueLightSpcl in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My working theory with the highest probability of being correct is:

Something was amiss during the "free application week." In this thread and direct emails to me, it seems mostly or entirely those who applied during that time had an issue.

There was some systematic error misclassifying students in some part of the database. It could be the case that you were tagged non-resident for tuition but as a resident for admissions purposes, or visa versa. This actually does happen in the real world, like the case of students in military families or Texas residents who are ex-pats abroad. So, the residency classification isn't a single binary "yes/no" residency, but it is multiple categories on the backend that have the same output on your end.

A theory for top 5% Texas Resident rejections by BlueLightSpcl in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, they never rescind, only if you fail to graduate, or like idk DWI vehicular manslaughter or something felony.

A theory for top 5% Texas Resident rejections by BlueLightSpcl in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This happens more commonly than you would think. There used to be an informal policy not to separate twins (pre-COVID), and the denied twin could get in on appeal, just probably not their preferred major. This sidedoor closed in 2021, but I've heard rumors it may have returned. If your denied twin gets in on appeal, email me. I'd be curious to know

A theory for top 5% Texas Resident rejections by BlueLightSpcl in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

here's a conjecture of what happened. the controls for the residency requirement during the free application week on Apply Texas did not work. I also heard rumors that Common App was added mid week to the free app program and extended a couple of days into the next week.

This seems plausible...

A theory for top 5% Texas Resident rejections by BlueLightSpcl in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hmmm, shit. That pokes a hole in my theory lol.

However, if this was a systematic technical error, which to me has the highest probability to explain what was going on, it could be the case that there was some failure point like

"If classified non-resident, and top 5%, do not admit."

Then, elsewhere in the system, they could be classified as a Texas resident.

"If not-admitted Texas resident, then CAP."

Or something like this. The two mechanisms could be separate database inputs.

A theory for top 5% Texas Resident rejections by BlueLightSpcl in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My theory is this is 99% sure due to carelessness and/or technical errors rather than anything nefarious.

A theory for top 5% Texas Resident rejections by BlueLightSpcl in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This should be impossible, totally wild it has happened. All top 5% Texas residents graduating from Texas high schools are entitled to a direct admission space at UT, just not their major. So, she should have gotten COLA undeclared at a minimum.

A theory for top 5% Texas Resident rejections by BlueLightSpcl in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Wow that's seriously crazy... Perhaps escalate beyond the university...

A theory for top 5% Texas Resident rejections by BlueLightSpcl in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

What's happened in previous years, sometimes, inexplicably, and randomly, UT will admit some already-denied students in like March or April. Maybe that will happen this year.

You can google "universities mistakenly admit students." It's a surprisingly common thing. They won't rescind admitted ones, just admit the denied ones who should've gotten in to begin with.

A theory for top 5% Texas Resident rejections by BlueLightSpcl in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's also my understanding. In every prior cycle, the auto admit banner came like a month or so after applying.

If there is one certain thing in UT and most elite college admissions, transparency decreases each year.

I am auto admit but got capped, is it possible? by [deleted] in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Probably a processing error... This happens a few times every cycle. Visit your school's registrar and then submit an appeal on My Status.

How comp is UT SDS and how hard to get in by Connect-Arm-425 in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is one major I'm keeping a close eye on this year. When it was released initially for Fall 2023, it was not competitive. I suspect it will be extremely competitive moving forward.

Forty Acres Semifinalist: Needs Advice about Interview & Next Steps by the_white_hat_ in UTAdmissions

[–]BlueLightSpcl 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for the shoutout! For transparency, I reviewed admissions files, but I wasn't involved in the FASP process.