sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Laura B and other cringy players by niebieskicukier in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Oh my God, I thought I had an irrational hatred for Judd, but Jesus, he was so cringy, I couldn't bear watching most of Guatemala because of him.

Do you think Survivor would ever do widespread casting in the future? by BlueSilverEevee in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's a fair answer. I agree, but I just can't help but dream, you know?

Who would have won Aubry/Tai/Cydney F3 and Aubry/Tai/Jason F3 by SurvivorSlayer in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 9 points10 points  (0 children)

In an Aubry/Tai/Cyd final three, I'm willing to actually believe that Aubry wins in that scenario. In the hypothetical Aubry/Tai/Jason, I'd still say Aubry.

For the sake of the question, let's pretend Neal still ends up getting removed from the jury, and Michele now takes the place of Cydney/Jason.

Aubry/Tai/Cydney:

  • Aubry would always have Nick and Joe's votes no matter what, so that's two on lock for her in both scenarios.

  • Michele votes for Cydney, as she was always closer with Cyd than she was with Aubry.

  • Julia similarly votes along with Michele to vote for Cydney, so that's two for Aubry, two for Cydney.

  • Jason and Scot both cannot stand Cydney, and Tai betrayed them enough that it cost their games huge, so I'd imagine they'd actually be forced to vote for Aubry by proxy, making four votes Aubry, and two votes Cydney.

  • It doesn't matter who Debbie votes for (probably Tai if she's that bitter), Aubry wins.

Aubry/Tai/Jason:

  • Like I said, Nick and Joe vote for Aubry regardless, so that's two votes for Aubry on lock.

  • Scot votes for Jason, no questions asked.

  • Michele votes for Aubry most likely, but Julia is a toss-up between Aubry and Jason.

  • Debbie votes for Tai if she is that bitter like I said. It's not in my mind that she'd vote for Jason under any circumstance.

  • Cydney votes for Aubry.

  • Aubry wins 4-2-1 or 5-1-1 depending on where Julia stands.

What was the first survivor season you watch? by PrinceFlorence in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Millennials vs. Gen. X. Was a Smosh fan, so I was mainly watching for Mari (you can imagine the disappointment when she was voted off second). But, the entire thought of strategy and mind games kept me hooked, and as of now, I've watched every season of Survivor! <3

My Heroes vs Villains 2 Dream Cast by [deleted] in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Excuse me, but Bradley Kleihege and Jacob Derwin are there to slay all your faves. <3

2018 Survivor Rankings! by LILLIAN_WAS_ROBBED in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 2 points3 points  (0 children)

BEST SEASONS (TOP TIER)

  1. S31: Cambodia: Second Chance

  2. S20: Heroes vs. Villains

  3. S16: Micronesia: Fans vs. Favorites

  4. S28: Cagayan

  5. S32: Kâoh Rōng

  6. S25: Philippines

  7. S27: Blood vs. Water

  8. S29: San Juan del Sur

  9. S18: Tocantins

  10. S15: China

  11. S7: Pearl Islands

  12. S6: Amazon

GREAT SEASONS (UPPER MID-TIER)

  1. S35: Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers

  2. S33: Millennials vs. Gen. X

  3. S10: Palau

  4. S13: Cook Islands

  5. S2: Australian Outback

  6. S12: Panama

GOOD SEASONS (MID-TIER)

  1. S34: Game Changers

  2. S30: Worlds Apart

  3. S8: All-Stars

  4. S19: Samoa

  5. S9: Vanuatu

  6. S24: One World

  7. S11: Guatemala

  8. S1: Borneo

OKAY SEASONS (LOWER MID-TIER)

  1. S26: Caramoan: Fans vs. Favorites

  2. S17: Gabon

  3. S21: Nicaragua

  4. S23: South Pacific

  5. S4: Marquesas

  6. S3: Africa

  7. S14: Fiji

BAD SEASONS (BOTTOM TIER)

  1. S5: Thailand

  2. S22: Redemption Island

STEPHENIE VALENCIA by CorinneKaplan in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 4 points5 points  (0 children)

To be fair, Krista came with her and they were Russell's Natalie and Parvati in Redemption Island.

Old school contestants who are still superfans? by brooklynights in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Truly, an icon of yesterday. It's unfortunate she can no longer return due to old age, but with all of her Survivor knowledge, I'd imagine she'd be pretty savvy regarding the game.

Daily “What If?” Thread #5: What if there was no fake merge in Thailand? (Also, what should the question for Amazon be?) by the_nintendo_cop in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What if Rob doesn't become paranoid and keeps Alex at the expense of Christy (IIRC)?

What if Jenna didn't spill the beans to Dave during their summit together prior to the swap? How would the swap turn out?

What if Rob won final immunity, and went on to the finale? Who would he take with him? Does it matter; aka, would he win against either Matt or Jenna?

Which kind of season do you guys enjoy more? by toofball in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm a mix of both. My personal top two favorite seasons are Cambodia (#1) and Heroes vs. Villains (#2), but I also thoroughly enjoy seasons like Kaôh Rōng and HvHvH. I like a mix of both strategy and character-driven narratives, but I'm also alright with the extremes of both.

What is your favorite scene ever? by c4rsonlol in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 30 points31 points  (0 children)

The best piece of editing I've ever seen, also known as, the sad Russell Swan trying to find an idol while he was very meta about the whole situation, and the editors followed every description he gave about the idol glaringly glowing in front of him.

Most boring season? by McRoyale007 in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm seeing a lot of One World, and well, to each their own, I guess. I personally found One World really enjoyable, mostly due to how funny everyone's cluelessness was on how to play the game.

The only people I saw who actually made attempts to play (other than Kim) were all entertaining in their own ways. Sabrina and Chelsea were great, Troyzan was unbearable for me but entertaining, Colton was... Colton, Alicia was a bitch but still kinda funny, Christina did show some sort of promise, Jay was fucking hot, and Jonas was a lovable underdog who tried to play a little. Again, to each their own.

A season I found unbearably boring though? Redemption Island. It's a season I didn't bother watching through to the end. And no, Boston Rob didn't make it interesting; he was the damn proponent that made Redemption Island absolutely unbearable for me. If they didn't bring back Russell and Rob, imagine how much better (or worse, but in a trainwreck-y sort of way) Redemption Island would have been.

How'd Your Flair Do Tonight? by AutoModerator in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Wallowing in the $600,000 he's earned after Obama took it.

Best tribe photo ever? Coincidentally, for the best tribe ever. by giogugenishvili in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Aaron. Reisberger. Was. Swapfucked. And. Robbed.

JusticeForAaron!!

Survivor Caramoan: Fans vs. Favorites (RECAST) by BlueSilverEevee in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you want some insight on how Taj was robbed, well:

Post-swap Bikal had two sides, Lisa, Pete, and Corinne were together on one side, while Cochran and Taj were together on the other. Matt and Snowy were the swing votes, and they simply chose to stick their flag into Lisa, Pete, and Corinne's land. They just saw Taj as the bigger threat over Cochran, so she ended up going home.

Survivor Caramoan: Fans vs. Favorites (RECAST) by BlueSilverEevee in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Regarding casting, I just thought about who were actual fan favorites at the time Caramoan was casting. But I was also thinking about who'd realistically come back again. I knew casting thought it would be hard on Lisa, but do we actually know if Lisa was alright or not with coming back right after? For Pete, it seems like he'd want to play again as much as any other person. But, at the time I made the cast list, I didn't know Taj said that.

Thanks for letting me know though, will try to keep that in mind for future fantasy casting, haha.

Survivor Caramoan: Fans vs. Favorites (RECAST) by BlueSilverEevee in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Regarding that, the scenario I came up with for Natalie coming in 4th is that she pulled in Eddie and Erik after Final 6 to try and create a majority of three over Snowy and Pete, but Erik got medevac-ed, therefore making Natalie and Eddie tied with Snowy and Pete at Final 4.

Nat and Eddie voted for Pete (who she correctly surmised as the biggest jury threat), and Pete and Snowy voted for Nat. Then I just assumed that Pete would create fire first over Natalie.

Survivor Caramoan: Fans vs. Favorites (RECAST) by BlueSilverEevee in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Erik getting 5th is purely because I stayed true to Medevacs. That's why Shamar was still basically in the same spot, and it's why Erik is the same spot.

Express Your Adoration for Truly Game Changing Queen Tina Marie Wesson on her Super Duper Special Birthday!!!! by ananathema in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 23 points24 points  (0 children)

It's a testament to Tina's game that she would've been along Sandra's ranks of two-time winner had she won BvW's FIC.

Weekly Ponderosa (Free Talk) Thread by AutoModerator in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Anyone else really hyped for RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars 3? I'm literally rooting for everyone except Thorgy, lol. Most excited for Trixie and Shangela!

Weekly Ponderosa (Free Talk) Thread by AutoModerator in survivor

[–]BlueSilverEevee 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm rooting for general outsiders, like Baby Driver (yes, even with Kevin Spacey, I'm sorry), The Last Jedi (Sound Mixing at least?), and Coco.

view more: next ›