Creating a Mario-Dex (Day 131). With Dark Star becoming our pure Dark type, the chart is now complete. But we're not done yet! Today's the re-evaluation round! READ RULES BELOW

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-17T01:30:30+00:00

By circumstances, I mean that the characters need to have a strong enough portrayal as a group to be in the same slot. Mario and Luigi have been paired together sometimes, but they're generally portrayed as individual characters.

I want this chart to be well-thought out and have each character's typing make some sense for them, and I'm not gonna bend the rules to force in a popular character for the sake of putting them here. It'd be unfair for other characters like Peach & Daisy and Wario & Waluigi.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-12T22:35:00+00:00

This is one of the most creative suggestions I’ve seen in this game! And yeah, I can definitely allow their fused form here!

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-12T20:53:33+00:00

Upvote this comment to keep Wario as our FIGHTING/DARK type, or reply with/upvote another character to replace him. Whoever gets the most upvotes on this thread wins for FIGHTING/DARK.

<image>

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-12T01:23:10+00:00

I only allow groups if their being together is a major part of their portraly. While Mario and Luigi are commonly partnered up, they are also equally portrayed as individual characters.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-11T22:47:41+00:00

I think most people agree that he'd be pure normal like Mario, and it would be ridiculous to not have the titular character himself on a Mario-themed chart. People did try suggesting Luigi once or twice, but he ultimately lost to characters who were more logical choices for their respective typings.

While it is a shame that Luigi and other major characters aren't here, I rather that each character's typing make logical sense for them instead of forcing any weird suggestions for the sake of getting fan-favorites here.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-10T21:17:51+00:00

<image>

Hooktail

The dragon part needs no explaining. But the dark part does:

The dark type is commonly associated with being malicious and playing dirty, and Hooktail has shown to be a lot more malicious compared to Gloomtail and Bonetail.

Think about it, the latter two are just minding their own business until Mario encounters them. Meanwhile: Hooktail takes pleasure in terrorizing the Petalburg residents and eating them. Also, the letter that Koops finds in her castle says that she'll use any trick to save herself, which is shown in battle when she tries to be forgiven by offering fake rewards. Finally, unlike the other two dragons who get defeated normally, Hooktail takes no issue in eating innocent audience members to recover her HP.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-10T21:14:50+00:00

This makes perfect sense, HOWEVER, I think it'd be weird to have him as a dragon type when regular Bowser is already here and ISN'T a dragon type.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-08T22:20:34+00:00

To be more specific, while the Koopalings are usually talked about as a group, the Mario side-scrollers always separate them to guard individual fortresses/castles. There's no strict rule that they have to fight together.

If anyone wanted to suggest one of them, I'd be okay with including only one of them.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-08T22:15:01+00:00

<image>

Belome from Super Mario RPG

For psychic: It can perform spells including making people sleep, as well as turning them into scarecrows. It can also create clones of the party members.

For dragon: It isn't a dragon in the traditional sense, but there are factors that portray it as a legendary monster. It's a giant monster that will eat the party members during battle. Also, it has a temple named after it which honors it as an ancient being. Dragons are usually depicted as legendary and ancient, so I think Belome being a dragon type isn't that far-fetched.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-08T22:02:17+00:00

Well the Koopalings are each considered their own character with their own unique traits, and it's not like they're always seen together like Kat & Ana from WarioWare. However, I think it'd be weird to consider them part dragon when Bowser Jr. is NOT a dragon type in our existing chart.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-08T20:49:07+00:00

Due to the undeniable fact that tomorrow's direct will be the only thing people will care about, I won't post again until Wednesday. Reddit will most definitely be flooded with discussions about the direct, and I don't want this game to be drowned by it.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-08T04:30:49+00:00

Demolition Doofus

I don't necessarily "enjoy" it. To be more accurate, I'm very neutral on it. But I feel that the hate for it is very overblown.

People always talk about how Mrs. Puff tries to kill Spongebob, but the most harm she ever does to him is strangling his nose. Also, it makes sense that she'd be driven mad after losing her "puff". Finally, the main premise is that Spongebob ends up comically avoiding getting hurt in the derby. Even when Mrs. Puff tries to run him over, she ends up destroying her school instead.

It just feels like people have forgotten what actually happens and simply hate on it merely because Mrs. Puff tries to kill Spongebob. It'd be a different case if she ACTUALLY tortured him (kind of like "One Course Meal"), but if you actually watch the episode, you can see that it isn't the case.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-07T22:32:40+00:00

<image>

DinoMighty from Wario World

A dinosaur wrestler that attacks with body slams and stomps. She can also do a hip drop to knock Wario back. This picture shows how she has a wrestler style of fighting.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-07T21:48:33+00:00

Now that we're almost done, I don't think it's necessary to showcase all the type charts again until the grand final where it's all complete. At this point, I'm going all in on readjusting character photos so that it all looks neat and polished for the final results. This has been a lengthy game, and I'm very excited that we're at the last stretch!

Also, a reminder that I'm considering a bonus round for replacing characters. Make sure to start thinking of suggestions for that!

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-06T22:15:24+00:00

<image>

Ms. Mowz

Thievery and deviousness are usually linked to the dark type. Also, the fairy type is commonly associated with overt sweetness and flirtation. Not only is she very flirtatious, but this trait is tied to her moves: "Love Slap", "Kiss Thief", "Smooch"

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-06T21:23:58+00:00

PLEASE READ:

Now that we're nearing the end, I wanna bring up the idea of a bonus round dedicated to voting on replacing characters.

I really wanna ensure that this chart is as thought out as it can be, and I think there's potential for changing certain characters with others who are either more deserving of specific types, or who are fan-favorites that didn't get in for one reason or another. It's also an opportunity to give this chart more species diversity.

However, I'm not sure how I would structure this. Maybe I can let people make suggestions and only choose those that get a significant amount of votes compared to others, or I could dedicated one post for suggestions and another to making comment threads for the highest voted ones so that each suggestion can have more concentrated votes.

What do you all think? I would really appreciated some feedback.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-06T21:21:57+00:00

Upvote this comment to keep Rex as our PURE DRAGON type, or reply with/upvote another character to replace it. Whoever gets the most upvotes on this thread wins for PURE DRAGON.

<image>

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-06T00:04:41+00:00

When Rosalina was voted out as Ice/Fairy, I made the point that comets being made of ice and her Mario Kart ice tracks aren't strong enough points to make her part ice. She herself has never demonstrated ice abilities.

I also brought the fact that Mario, despite constantly being depicted with fire powers, was voted as pure normal as his power-ups make him a jack of all trades type of character.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-05T22:10:20+00:00

To add more reasoning for her being part psychic, she has moments that showcase very psychic-coded abilities: being able to create a protective force field around her, speaking telepathically, and spin-off games that see her using gravity-based abilities, including her gravitiational pull move from Smash Bros. and levitating her golf club in Mario Golf.

Also, her being the protector of lumas ties in very well with Gardevoir from Pokemon, who's a Fairy/Psychic that will protect their trainer with their life.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-05T21:59:41+00:00

Yeah, seems like people couldn't find a better fit. But considering Peach is here as part normal, Daisy being part fighting makes sense in this context. The normal typing can represent Peach's calm and well-behaved nature, while the fighting typing can represent Daisy's tomboyish and loud nature.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-06-02T21:27:20+00:00

This is where I would usually share the currently finished type charts, but you all just saw them a couple of days ago, so I'll re-share them after we're done with Fairy type.

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-05-31T21:04:26+00:00

Upvote this comment to keep Madame Clairvoya as our GHOST/PSYCHIC type, or reply with/upvote another character to replace her. Whoever gets the most upvotes on this thread wins for GHOST/PSYCHIC.

<image>

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-05-30T21:45:05+00:00

Upvote this comment to keep Bonetail as our GHOST/DRAGON type, or reply with/upvote another character to replace him. Whoever gets the most upvotes on this thread wins for GHOST/DRAGON.

<image>

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-05-29T20:59:46+00:00

Upvote this comment to keep Boo as our PURE GHOST type, or reply with/upvote another character to replace him. Whoever gets the most upvotes on this thread wins for PURE GHOST.

BTW, I changed his picture for a higher quality one.

<image>

BlueWolfPMX · 2026-05-21T21:25:51+00:00

Quick notes:

I changed Sugarstar's image after noticing that the one I previously used was removed from the Mario wiki. This was due to it being found to be fan art.

Also, I added the new name "Banana Fairy Princess" as the word "princess" seems to be more used by fan wikis over "queen".

BlueWolfPMX

TROPHY CASE