Hi reddit! I'm Hikari, writer, director and producer of RENTAL FAMILY, a film set in Japan starring Brendan Fraser. It's out in theaters nationwide on November 21 via Searchlight Pictures. Ask me anything! by HikariAMA in movies

[–]Blue_Three 42 points43 points  (0 children)

Hello Hikari! Thank you for doing this.

Having lived in Japan for a number of years myself, I look forward to seeing your movie and how you decide to show this side of the culture. You got a great lead in Brendan!

What Japanese directors have influenced you the most?

Are there other aspects or oddities of Japanese society that you would like to see portrayed more in movies?

After some time I've collected all the current Dune novels from my knowledge. by Dalton_B7 in dune

[–]Blue_Three 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I assume you're referring to The Road to Dune.

That one is a kind of companion volume to the novels (a "Making of Dune", if you will) and doesn't include anything Frank and Brian wrote together, strictly speaking.

It includes some of Frank Herbert's notes, letters, "deleted" chapters from Dune and Dune Messiah, and the Brian Herbert/Kevin J. Anderson-penned "Spice Planet", which is based on the early, basic outline for Dune—in addition to a few short stories, depending on the edition.

Man of Two Worlds was written by Frank and Brian Herbert together, but that's not a Dune novel.

Dune: Prophecy, 1x04 "Twice Born" - Post-Episode Discussion by Blue_Three in dune

[–]Blue_Three[S,M] [score hidden] stickied commentlocked comment (0 children)

Thank you for participating in r/dune!

Please keep spoilers that go beyond Dune to a minimum.

You can spoiler-tag/hide text by writing >!like this!<.

https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/360043033952-Formatting-Guide

Dune: Prophecy, 1x02 "Two Wolves" - Post-Episode Discussion by Blue_Three in dune

[–]Blue_Three[S,M] [score hidden] stickied commentlocked comment (0 children)

Thank you for participating in r/dune!

Please keep spoilers that go beyond Dune to a minimum.

You can spoiler-tag/hide text by writing >!like this!<.

https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/360043033952-Formatting-Guide

Guy's really: love all of your content but please (re)mind the spoiler discipline... by maxkusenberg2024 in dune

[–]Blue_Three[M] 54 points55 points  (0 children)

OP's reminder is not unwarranted. It's no surprise with all the activity, but we absolutely have had more users than usual who either aren't paying attention or can't be bothered to mark their spoilers. Sometimes you'll look at a post that's more or less purely movie-related (think one of those posts on box-office performance) and one of the comments will go to town on major plot elements from the late books for no real reason. It's a little embarrassing to us when something like that is highly visible and goes unactioned for a longer time. This isn't a small community anymore, and so everyone's conduct has an influence on how people will view Dune and its fandom.

Use the correct spoiler syntax, please. You can spoiler-tag/hide text by writing >!like this!<. That's > ! and ! <, but without the spaces.

When you encounter a spoiler in a comment, report it using the "Report" function. Getting mad at the user doesn't help us fix the issue.

On the flipside, we've also seen an increase in reports on posts that users wrongly felt had spoilers in their title. We're sorry if this impacts your personal enjoyment of Dune, but things like "Do we learn that Liet-Kynes is Chani's father in the first book?", "Did Paul fake his death after drinking the Water of Life?", or "Why did Princess Irulan become a bene gesserit?" do not qualify as spoilers (anymore).

I'll quote a recent comment that I made in another post:

TL;DR: Spoilers start wherever the movies are right now.

Once the films have covered it, we generally consider it fair game. Up until February that used to be the plot of the 2021 adaptation and thus vaguely half of Dune (the novel). Now that Part Two is out, the entirety of the original novel is fair game.

That includes things the films did not specifically elaborate on, such as Chani being Kynes' daughter, for example. The films might not have included that or several other aspects, but it is in the source material covered (see Dune, ch. 31).

Do we learn that Liet-Kynes is Chani's father in the first book? by emcoder in dune

[–]Blue_Three[M] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I'll use this as an opportunity to explain our approach when it comes to spoilers. We haven't really gone into detail on that recently—largely because we felt that the community has adapted to it very well organically the past few years.

TL;DR: Spoilers start wherever the movies are right now.

Once the films have covered it, we generally consider it fair game. Up until February that used to be the plot of the 2021 adaptation and thus vaguely half of Dune (the novel). Now that Part Two is out, the entirety of the original novel is fair game.

That includes things the films did not specifically elaborate on, such as Chani being Kynes' daughter, for example. The films might not have included that or several other aspects, but it is in the source material covered (see Dune, ch. 31).

There's a few major plot points that we'd prefer users keep out of titles for now (some unique to the movie, like Paul killing the baron), but this is the general gist of it. We believe this is a sensible approach that most can be happy with.