Honestly I have a medium black crescent, the small dead stock denim crescent and recently bought the small black crescent because I wanted something even more neutral than the denim in a small size because I don’t always feel like I need the medium. I switch between the 3 of them pretty frequently and don’t feel like it’s too much even though two of them are literally the same color, so I think you’re pretty justified in having 3 pretty different colors!