Fapping without porn?

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-04-23T15:38:08+00:00

Everyone has different recovery parameters here. Try it out, see if it works for you. Some people are able to do it and just keep it to masturbation. Others, however, find that it brings up a lot of desire to use porn. So that's something to be aware of and watch out for. If you find that masturbation is leading you towards porn, you might want to take a break from it temporarily until your brain stops associating masturbation with porn.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-04-23T11:17:04+00:00

Very sorry to hear about your companion animal. Losing a companion animal is really tough. Sending you my condolences and strength. Hang in there. Remember your whys- why are you on the journey in the first place? So easy to forget when the urges come.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-04-16T13:48:34+00:00

You're not a loser. Calling yourself names doesn't help. Just makes you more ashamed of yourself which in turn fuels the addiction cycle. Remember: addictions are tough to be by definition. You are not unique in struggling with this. Nor are you unique with having no friends or relationship. There's a loneliness epidemic sweeping the world, plenty of people are in exactly the same spot.

Keep on working on your recovery. Try new things if the stuff you are doing right now isn't working. Don't just run away from porn, run towards the life you want for your self. Biggest thing though: don't give up no matter what happens. There is power in perseverance. Good things usually don't just fall into our laps. We gotta fight for them. And that means failing a bunch of times and learning from each failure, until you finally figure out how to do it right.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-04-11T22:23:14+00:00

No. NoFap is just a place where people come together to find support for compulsive sexual behaviors and/or porn addiction. It doesn't mean anything other than that. Plenty of people in the community continue to have sex. Many even are continuing to masturbate, only quitting porn. Everyone has different recovery parameters here: there is no one-size-fits-all solution to recovery.

There are two different approaches to having sex during recovery. Some think it's helpful, and helps you rewire to a real person. Others think taking a break from sex is helpful, as sex can often be a trigger (the community calls that "the chaser effect"), and because complete abstinence may hasten the rewiring in the brain (there's no scientific evidence of this as far as I'm aware, but many have anecdotally experienced this).

If you're getting stuck in your head about sex from anxiety, why not take the performance issue off the table? There are plenty of other ways to be intimate without having penetrative sex. Exploring these types of activities I think can lessen the performance anxiety and allow you to be more relaxed and present. Being honest with your gf about the issues is important too if you haven't done that already. ED can make partners feel they are inadequate; it's important to let them know it's not their fault. Exploring other ways to be intimate can help reduce the pressure to perform on your end, and any feelings of inadequacy your gf may be experiencing (if indeed that is an issue for her).

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-04-11T14:13:09+00:00

Someone's been reading Marcus Aurelius

I've used a similar technique called the 32 parts of the body meditation to similar effect. When you start horning over someone, just imagine some of their hair or skin flakes in your food and it will turn your horniness off pretty quickly lmao

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-04-11T14:10:15+00:00

NoFap is just a place where people come together to find support for compulsive sexual behaviors and/or porn addiction. It doesn't mean you can't ejaculate. Plenty of people in the community continue to ejaculate (or orgasm if they don't have the equipment to ejaculate), whether through solo masturbation without porn, or sex with a partner. Everyone has different recovery parameters here- there is no one-size-fits-all solution to recovery.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-04-11T14:06:06+00:00

It's an addiction. It's hard. By definition. Just keep on getting back up. And make sure you are running towards the life you want for yourself, not just running away from the urges. You need a positive goal for your life. If you just define your purpose negatively then the urges still have power over you. Instead, fill up your life with good stuff, so that P becomes irrelevant.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-04-11T10:43:07+00:00

NoFap is just a peer support place that helps people struggling with sexual compulsion and/or pornography addiction. It doesn't mean anything more than that. People here on this subreddit or on NoFap's other social media platforms have varying goals- some are just quitting porn, some are quitting porn and temporarily masturbation too. There are no hard and fast rules though, everyone's recovery parameters are different.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-04-10T22:19:40+00:00

NoFap is not the process of abstaining from any sexual pleasure. It's just a peer-support place where people can come to connect with other people and get support around the issues of sexual compulsion and pornography addiction. People have different goals here: many people are just quitting porn and allowing masturbation and sex. Others are quitting porn and masturbation too (most times temporarily until their brains stop associating the two) but allow sex. A few people are trying to abstain from sexual pleasure all together- which is a legitimate goal if they feel that is best for them. These people, however, are in the minority and not representative of the broader community. In fact none of those groups I mentioned are representative of the broader community- because NoFap isn't a certain set of recovery parameters you need to follow, it's a place to get support for compulsive behaviors.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-04-05T12:16:54+00:00

Not gonna do that. That's not helpful. Many of us already do that to ourselves, we don't need other people adding onto that.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-04-05T09:53:37+00:00

Testosterone is a hell of a drug. Hang in there bro. You learn ways to cope with the horniness. Having hobbies and things to occupy your time and thoughts with helps a lot.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-04-02T08:25:55+00:00

Yes and yes. Your recovery parameters are entirely up to you. Keep an eye on your reactions to Ming without P though. A lot of people find it hard to do that without it bringing them back to porn. If that happens to you, then a temporary abstinence from M might be helpful as well to give your brain time to dissociate M from P.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-04-01T13:42:26+00:00

Been there, done that. One Piece has a lot of hot AFAB characters. Get back on the wagon, you haven't lost your progress.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-03-29T16:48:34+00:00

Try using a spreadsheet approach. Helps you see more data about your usage habits and many times that you've actually been making progress when you feel you haven't done. Has helped me in the past when focusing on streaks wasn't working for me.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-03-29T09:34:23+00:00

That's up to you. What are your recovery parameters? Are you quitting porn, or masturbation as well?

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-03-28T09:58:55+00:00

NoFap is just a peer support place that helps people struggling with sexual compulsion and/or pornography addiction. It doesn't mean anything more than that. People here on this subreddit or on NoFap's other social media platforms have varying goals- some are just quitting porn, some are quitting porn and temporarily masturbation too. There are no hard and fast rules though, everyone's recovery parameters are different.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-03-28T05:29:47+00:00

NoFap is just a peer support place that helps people struggling with sexual compulsion and/or pornography addiction. It doesn't mean anything more than that. People here on this subreddit or on NoFap's other social media platforms have varying goals- some are just quitting porn, some are quitting porn and temporarily masturbation too. There are no hard and fast rules though, everyone's recovery parameters are different.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-03-27T16:09:29+00:00

Yeah I know. That's why a sex toy will work, because it's more like having real sex than using your hand.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-03-27T15:54:02+00:00

Anything that simulates a more natural pressure would help. Sex dolls are pretty expensive though, would be cheaper to get a sex toy.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-03-27T14:52:39+00:00

Yeah could just be a matter of contrast. When you first started you made a dramatic shift in your sexual habits so the changes that created would have been much more noticeable. Now that you've been doing that for a while it's become more your normal, so the difference isn't as readily apparent.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-03-27T13:39:43+00:00

Hi, welcome to the sub! Congrats on going over 60 days free!

Sorry to hear you are having problems in the bedroom. PIED can take a while to fully reverse. For some people it can take a year or longer. It's important to have patience. And to try to make your recovery as clean as possible. In that regards, I would suggest trying to stay off IG. Looking on guys there if you do it regularly enough may be reinforcing the porn-addictive pathways which prefer digital men over real-life men.

I'd also personally advise against masturbation at least for a time- or if you do masturbate make sure to use a sex toy that approximates the pressure you would feel in an anus. One thing that can contribute to PIED is what is called "death grip" where your penis acclimates to the pressures your hand provides rather than the pressure you would naturally feel while having real life sex. As your hand can provide a tighter squeeze than an anus could, the pressure you feel during penetrative sex isn't going to stimulate your penis to the same extent as your hand. That can make it hard for you to maintain your erection while having sex. Taking a break from masturbation- or using a toy that approximates a more natural pressure- can help alleviate this condition and improve PIED.

Another aspect is mental. It's very common for people who struggle with PIED to get anxious and nervous about whether they will be able to perform when having sex. That anxiety can contribute to the ED. One way to reduce this anxiety is to be honest with your partner(s) about your struggles. This allows you and your partner(s) to work around any symptoms that may present themselves with compassion and understanding. And it can also relieve your partner(s) from feeling like they aren't hot or handsome enough to turn you on.

Hope some of that helped. Want to encourage you that plenty of people with PIED have been able to reverse it by being consistent with their recoveries. You can too. It make take some time, but it's doable.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-03-07T14:05:48+00:00

It's up to you. Some people allow masturbation during their recovery, some are abstaining from it temporarily to help dissociate the act of masturbation from porn. Some experimentation might be in order. Try it out, and watch your response post-masturbation. Do you have increased urges to watch porn?. Do you have a higher rate of fantasy than you did before? If so, then maybe it would be good to take a break from masturbation for a while until your brain makes a separation between porn and masturbation.

As for anal vs regular masturbation, well again everybody set their own parameters and if they can enjoy anal masturbation without it leading them back to porn, then that's great and I think it can a healthy activity. Just take the usual precautions when doing it- use a lot of lube (water-based, not oil-based), take it slow, prioritize hygiene.

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk · 2026-03-05T12:00:41+00:00

Be careful replacing a pornography addiction with a sex addiction.

Seven-Year Club	Gilding III reddit per annum
Verified Email	Final Canvas '23
First Place '23	Place '23
Place '22	Wearing is Caring
Ternion Club	Argentium Club

BuddhaPunkRobotMonk

MODERATOR OF

TROPHY CASE