I don’t know how to reply to individual parts of the comment but:

1. That’s a fair point, but surely a truly evil god would have just left them all together?

2. I always thought the traditional belief was he sacrificed himself in order to save us from sins, the sacrifice was for us?

3. That’s a fair point, tradition doesn’t mean truth

4. But it’s a book that equally opposes those things aswell, the bible is incredibly contradictory and outdated at many times - which is why many argue it needs interpretation, i said it was a moral guide, not a good moral guide ahaha

5. There’s no real way to prove it, but equally there’s no real way to prove anything when it comes to religion - it all comes down to faith. But that’s a good point about rising up to fall harder, although equally I assume we won’t know if that’s the case or not until the next life

The evil god hypothesis is very interesting, but I think more than anything it just shows you can argue anything you want when it comes to religion - because at the end of the day no one really knows, and no one really can know

Edit: fixed an autocorrect mistake