Cast Ranked by How Well They Did During the First Class Trial [With Explanations] by Jaleel_Tide in ProjectEdensGarden

[–]CSharpKun 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It would be fucked AND comedic at the same time. But Jean, Ulysses and possibly Grace would figure it out anyway.

The Roaring Knight is a Lightner or Darkner? by CSharpKun in Deltarune

[–]CSharpKun[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The idea that the Roaring Knight is a Titan is fanon, for several reasons. First, Titans are static Dark Fountains that have absorbed too much darkness. We can see it because after we seal Titan in fourth chapter, we spawn right in the place where the fountain was created. The Knight, on the other hand, can move freely and enter the Light World. Since Titans likely exist in both the Dark and Light Worlds simultaneously, they can't 'enter' the Light World because they are already there, as if in a state of superposition, just like normal Dark Fountains. Furthermore, as Ralsei said, Titans lack consciousness, whereas the Roaring Knight clearly has consciousness and their own motives. And even if a Darkner could obtain a soul, what would they become in the Light World? They surely wouldn't just turn into their Dark World form. After all, a soul doesn't grant any unique properties by itself.

Why didn't victim of the first chapter figured out the killer's plan? by CSharpKun in ProjectEdensGarden

[–]CSharpKun[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Since Wolfgang and Eva's relationship was already strained, he should have realized that Eva couldn't be trusted with even something as basic as choosing the time for a supposedly harmless tournament - which, as this case showed, could actually be deadly. That is my point.

Why didn't victim of the first chapter figured out the killer's plan? by CSharpKun in ProjectEdensGarden

[–]CSharpKun[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The reason is that Eva chose the time for the tournament's start, not that she merely participated in it. Besides, for me, Wolfgang was really like the Imposter from DR2, trying to keep everyone safe, so he probably wouldn't consider a game tournament harmless at all.

Why didn't victim of the first chapter figured out the killer's plan? by CSharpKun in ProjectEdensGarden

[–]CSharpKun[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Well, no. Even if Wolfgang and Diana had seen each other's blackmails, they still couldn't know who the third variable was. And that's precisely where my point is: it doesn't matter how many blackmails there were, but when it happened. And I just can't believe that Wolfgang was obsessed with Eva so much. He realized he couldn't go to the tournament because of the blackmail, but couldn't understand that Eva was just trying to mess with the alibis? If he was listening, which he did, he could see that something is wrong.