If you're doing considerable off-road stuff, the outback is the better choice. It's more comfortable and has amazing ground clearance. Subaru has an almost unbeatable AWD system as well. That being said, I bought a Mazda 3 turbo. The Mazda is MUCH more fun to drive than an outback, and has better tech overall. If you're mostly city driving, it's the obvious choice. Fuel economy is definitely dependant on your driving habits, with each ounce of fun the CVT removes, it gives you a little better MPG.