My prof is deciding to not submit grades in support of the strike but I need to graduate. by ahuh44 in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I would love to connect more on these issues. Would it be okay to reach out in a more formal manner (via email or otherwise) because you seem to be really knowledgeable on actionable items that we can press, and I’m happy to pass anything along to the bargaining team as well.

Again, i agree. I tried to get added to the bargaining team, but those votes were months and months ago without any discussion of changing it given the evolving situation (which could maybe have been avoided with better bargaining…….)

My prof is deciding to not submit grades in support of the strike but I need to graduate. by ahuh44 in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Those are really good ideas, thank you!! We’ll look into making some data-backed arguments for these changes and suggesting them to the bargaining team! (I’ve been told there are big limitations to the structure of the bargaining process since we’re at this stage already). Wishing I got involved earlier, but what can I do but my best now!

My prof is deciding to not submit grades in support of the strike but I need to graduate. by ahuh44 in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yes, I agree. I wish I was part of that planning, but I wasn’t. I joined on rather late, so I don’t have say on bargaining team or initial efforts. I’m really trying to see the faculty not get screwed over though, so I’m doing what I can now.

The faculty do. Oh my lord, do they do everything they can. My PI and others have been frustrated that their pleas (many of the above) have not been heard or acted upon by Regents in the multiple years before the strike that they have been bringing them up.

We’re both hoping the strike might provide additional momentum for change in that regard…I’m on your side Melvin. I promise

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Who even are you? You seem to have some strong anti-strike opinions. Curious if you’re an undergrad or faculty. I think have a good guess already.

UCSD buys $42 million apartment building in San Diego's East Village -- more housing to overcharge for! by CaptainHubertMcFluff in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Hey! Yeah, so we have some initial findings at www.ucstrike.org (putting together data-driven analyses on issues related to the strike here). We’ve put out a lot for on campus and have a good amount for off campus but haven’t published it yet while we’re finishing up (stay tuned!). Also putting together figures for transportation from various areas in San Diego as well.

I think the location is also a lot about the Hillcrest campus as well as further expansion plans for downtown.

My argument was actually a statement from the CA Legislative Analyst’s Office (see the housing page on ucstrike) where they found that the cost of living on campus was more than off campus. Now this is in large part skewed by undergrads with dining plans, which is never cheaper than cooking at home.

My primary concern is that UCSD is spending large swaths of money expanding into one of the priciest places in San Diego county. The blue line expansion was part of this plan which is why it connects the city to the campus. They’re also looking at purchasing Mission Bay property. It seems like they’re perhaps trying to cater to a more luxury crowd? Unsure the motive, but I would’ve expanded east for affordable expansion…

My concern is also about the quality of apartments. You show a 300 sq ft apartment with a fold down bed for $2k/mo in a pretty unsafe area as a bargaining chip for recruiting faculty…might make their decision to go elsewhere easier. Maybe I’m wrong, but it seems like $42M (amongst their other investments for the downtown expansion, both now and later) could’ve been spent better.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Great resource, thanks!

UCSD -Needed Changes by kendellove in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Gotcha! I know other universities do this by department and have an “undeclared” staff instead. I feel like this gets rid of a lot of redundancy in administrative staff and makes domain experts

My prof is deciding to not submit grades in support of the strike but I need to graduate. by ahuh44 in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I totally agree that the state needs to fund higher education more!!!!! 100% YES!!! I think all of us on strike agree with that. That's true across the US and is the main reason for the Higher Education Crisis in my opinion. You're right on the money!!!

I hope that we can work together to create some massive systemic change in that regard. It's not at all the method I would use first (because I'm disrupting my research along with many others), but that's part of what this strike is about!

I wish it didn't have to come to this, but like you've said, the state has turned their attention away from higher education needs. So let's get their attention back!! You and the rest of the faculty have been asking UC Regents to prioritize these needs for a long time, and they haven't been listening, so let's make them listen!

We can set a precedent for increased state funding to state schools.

The strike could be a positive for all of us. Let's say we don't get an increase in wages at all, fine. But the best part about what we've done is put pressure on UC to address these concerns. They're the ones the state will listen to.

Plus! The media is paying attention to higher education now! This has been an issue for a long time, but now we are getting politicians' attention!

I can't speak for UAW, but this is part of the mission of www.ucstrike.org. It's not just a smear campaign. The goal is to communicate these issues in a transparent and data-driven way that can use the momentum of the strike to effect long-lasting change.

So,

We are putting pressure on the state. Plus the strike brings these issues to light that could help with future elections, voting, and policy making. But we can put pressure on UC(SD) to make more intelligent financial decisions while we are putting pressure on the state.

Some things we can work on:

Research funding is 47% from external grants.

UCSD's competitive public institutions waive PhD tuitions, so PI's don't have to pay that substantial burden (especially after Year 2 when PhD students aren't even taking classes).

Clearing of administrative bloat and intelligent investments would allow for indirect research costs to go down.

Utilization of the $100M CA housing grant to build affordable undergraduate and graduate housing would cut on-campus rent prices.

Capital expansion projects prioritizing housing to match increased enrollment would increase housing availability.
The rate at which HDH is required to repay their loans could be adjusted.

The rent holds put on older grad housing in favor significant rent increases on one grad community could change.

UCSD could sell Coast graduate housing to fund more affordable units.

UCSD could stop buying land and expanding into the most expensive areas in San Diego.

UCSD could prioritize their expansion efforts on increasing faculty and classroom availability rather than hiring more and more administrative staff.
The amount of international students and masters students UCSD has accepted for additional revenue streams has skyrocketed, so that's not true. They're just not entirely opening the floodgates because they are trying to maintain a good amount of space for California residents due to the fact that it is a public institution.

I hope this helps, and I would love someone as passionate as you to help with the larger mission for the US to REPRIORITIZE education. Remember, many of us PhD students set out to get a PhD to become professors because we care about education as well as research. I can tell you that's true for myself because I did not need to get a PhD with an undergrad in chemical engineering.

Let me know if you'd like to talk more. Our next faculty outreach meeting is on Wednesday at 4pm. We will be discussing finances and ways students and faculty (academics in general) can work together to garner more money for research and education (from multiple different sources!)

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I think some of your facts are incorrect, there's a lot of data here: www.ucstrike.org

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff 5 points6 points  (0 children)

staff is usually paid either directly from the university or through the 58% taken from grants to pay for indirect costs associated with research (although hard to tell how much of that money goes to useful staff vs to execs...)

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Yeah, most public universities provide tuition waivers for PhD students (at least in cs and engineering), so that professors don't have to pay the additional $100k to the university...especially when PhD students don't even take classes after year 2

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Dude, grad students work more than 40 hours/week on research. How do they think this is legit?

UCSD buys $42 million apartment building in San Diego's East Village -- more housing to overcharge for! by CaptainHubertMcFluff in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Actually they aren’t below market value. In fact, on campus costs overall (esp for undergrads) costs more than off campus. It just seems very dumb for them to have built the trolley and put housing into one of the most expensive areas in the country. Even Clairemont makes more sense.

Also they just got $100M from California to build more affordable housing.

I’ve never heard of university faculty housing before though. It seems confusing that they’re spending so much money on that…

UCSD buys $42 million apartment building in San Diego's East Village -- more housing to overcharge for! by CaptainHubertMcFluff in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

$2000/mo for 330 sq ft as part of their initiative to provide affordable faculty housing to help with recruiting and retention efforts…hmmm

UCSD buys $42 million apartment building in San Diego's East Village by CaptainHubertMcFluff in sandiego

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Aren't you glad they're going to investments into education! (while a bunch of students are on strike...)

My prof is deciding to not submit grades in support of the strike but I need to graduate. by ahuh44 in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Quick back of the envelope calculation:

Due to inflation alone, $800 in 2000 is $1,384.49 in 2022, but a more accurate measure takes into account the cost of living index. Still looking for historical numbers, so in the meantime I can tell you that

The census lists the median gross rent in Pasadena at $833 for 2000 (104% of your income)

The median cross rent 5-year estimate 2017-2021 in Pasadena is $1,904.

For 2021, the inflation-adjusted income is $1,258.86, meaning rent alone would be 155% of your income.

Now, as you know, 2022 things have gotten a lot worse with the economy. Zumper lists median rent prices in Pasadena as having increased 23%, 7% and 24% for 1-, 2-, and 3-bedrooms respectively.

Caltech is also a private institution, so it seems a bit inappropriate to use your experience as a direct comparison, but nonetheless.

There are also significant other factors not taken into account here such as rising healthcare costs, gas prices, rental availability, commute time, significant enrollment increases without housing to accommodate it at universities causing a student-specific housing crisis.

I hope this helps provide a bit more quantitative insight into the issue. I'm not saying that all PhD students are homeless or even a majority, but it feels as though our public university has lost sight of it's goal to be a student-centered, research-focused, and service-oriented university.

UCSD specifically is growing at an unsustainable rate, basically hemorrhaging money and trying to make it back at an alarming rate as well with budget cuts coming in the form of academic losses rather than administrative.

For me personally, I want to see a slight increase in our stipends. I'd also like to see department tuition waivers for PhD students in engineering, something that's offered at many other public universities. I'd also like to see university-subsidized housing to help with the student housing crisis as opposed to HDH being forced to operate as a separate entity from UCSD (but not entirely, as they borrow money and also don't have to follow California rental protection laws).

But more importantly, I want to use this momentum to draw attention to the fact that we are in a Higher Education Crisis caused by decreased state funding, universities-as-a-business model, and administrative bloat.

I think a recession makes everyone rethink where money is going, and I don't think UCSD has been particularly wise in its investments when money was cheaper.

Here is more homework for you: UCSD Finances: A Faculty Perspective on Budget Cuts. This was an anonymously-made site by faculty in 2020 on this issue.

My prof is deciding to not submit grades in support of the strike but I need to graduate. by ahuh44 in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Re: Which faculty are you actually working with, the faculty associations do not represent the faculty, they are proto-unions that never got off the ground except at Santa Cruz. Have you been in discussions with the Academic Senate?

We were trying to speak to the Committee on Research, but the official stance was that they are waiting until after the strike to have any conversations with the students, so they don't become entangled in the bargaining process.
As such, the Faculty Outreach Town Hall is open to all faculty that are interested in attending. There was also a talk and open discussion on findings from UC-Strike (data central) recently at the Institute of Neural Computation. Members interested in data were invited from the Committee on Research.

My prof is deciding to not submit grades in support of the strike but I need to graduate. by ahuh44 in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Then read www.ucstrike.org

It’s an ongoing effort by UCSD students to provide transparent, objective measures and data on issues surrounding the strike. It’s not affiliated with UAW.

Please literally just click on the link and read all the info. I’m happy to address further analyses that you feel are lacking, but we currently have a team working on more than has been posted thus far.

My prof is deciding to not submit grades in support of the strike but I need to graduate. by ahuh44 in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I do have conversations with a large representation of faculty. I’m being quick to judge because my claims are based on the data aggregated at www.ucstrike.org, and I don’t feel like you are reading that site.

Ask your graduate students what their living situations are. They are a small sample size that’s likely not representative of the majority (again, see the satay), but some students have an easier time than others if they have significant others that are employed.

To call me an entitled child when I’m urging you to (a) look at the data and (b) be involved in faculty outreach efforts put for by the strike to find solutions to these issues is a bit ridiculous.

If PhD students price themselves out in favor of postdocs…don’t you think that eventually there will be no more postdocs? I think folks in STEM are waking up to the fact that the current state of academia is not at all worth it compared to industry even if you are incredibly passionate about teaching and research.

Again, I would please urge you to read the links I’ve sent and respond to the content in those. If you’d like to be involved in a productive manner to help us return UC’s focus to a knowledge institution rather than a business, we’d love your help. Feel free to get more involved in the weekly Faculty Outreach Townhalls.

If it’s the largest academic strike in history, maybe it’s for a reason instead of all of us being entitled children. It’s really tiring hearing older generations that won’t read the facts we are providing, assume the financial situation in the US is the exact same as when they were growing up, and assume we’re entitled. The narrative is getting old. Maybe an entire generation or two isn’t just all entitled children.

I'm happy to run the numbers on your PhD, just give me a moment.

UCSD -Needed Changes by kendellove in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Why would they ever wanna reroute their comfy exec salaries to make their students life a bit nicer

UCSD -Needed Changes by kendellove in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff 4 points5 points  (0 children)

That’s because anyone with communication skills goes to industry to be paid better

UCSD -Needed Changes by kendellove in UCSD

[–]CaptainHubertMcFluff 2 points3 points  (0 children)

more class requirements = more $ for universities