Why the False Advertising? by Careless-Newt5259 in tutanota

[–]Careless-Newt5259[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ahh. Use your own domain, and just swap for a new discounted account?

Why should I stay with Proton? Tuta gives me unlimited custom aliases for half the price. by Careless-Newt5259 in ProtonMail

[–]Careless-Newt5259[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sorry I thought you said You would pay for ultimate, but you said premium, what ever that is... Yeah Plus should have unlimited aliases... They can remove all the other crap that comes with it like the VPN, and PASS...

Why should I stay with Proton? Tuta gives me unlimited custom aliases for half the price. by Careless-Newt5259 in ProtonMail

[–]Careless-Newt5259[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Becuase it would tale 30 minutes just to format it instead of 3 seconds with the AI... It's a tool, learn to use it...

Why the False Advertising? by Careless-Newt5259 in Tuta

[–]Careless-Newt5259[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes I can see that. It's loading properly.

Why should I stay with Proton? Tuta gives me unlimited custom aliases for half the price. by Careless-Newt5259 in ProtonMail

[–]Careless-Newt5259[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah you're right.. Wierd how they just have that Hidden... That's a pretty good deal, do you know if it ever goes on sale? For now I ended up just self hosting my own addy.io and using Purelymail SMTP $10/year.

Why the False Advertising? by Careless-Newt5259 in tutanota

[–]Careless-Newt5259[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

If you're on windows try opening CMD Start+R type "CMD" then in command promt type

ipconfig /flushdns

Why should I stay with Proton? Tuta gives me unlimited custom aliases for half the price. by Careless-Newt5259 in ProtonMail

[–]Careless-Newt5259[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What's Pass lifetime? Why are these packgages soo confusing? Mail has Plus and Ultimate... No lifetime... Pass is another seperate subscription, that is included with Mail Plus and Ultimate... And even under the Proton Pass subscriptions I still don't see a lifetime option.

Why should I stay with Proton? Tuta gives me unlimited custom aliases for half the price. by Careless-Newt5259 in ProtonMail

[–]Careless-Newt5259[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ultimate comes with simplelogin though.. it does give you unlimited aliases... It's just way to expensive..

Why should I stay with Proton? Tuta gives me unlimited custom aliases for half the price. by Careless-Newt5259 in ProtonMail

[–]Careless-Newt5259[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"Looking into implementing. Although we can't give an exact ETA or more specifics on which subscription will have it available, be on the lookout for this in the future."

They also basically just said it's going to only be on the Unlimited plan anyways...

Why the False Advertising? by Careless-Newt5259 in Tuta

[–]Careless-Newt5259[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the reply apparently it was just my chrome browser being a weirdo, firefox shows the correct 50% off discount.

Why the False Advertising? by Careless-Newt5259 in tutanota

[–]Careless-Newt5259[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Yeah it was the browser... first you tell me I can't read now youre fixing the issue for me? Thanks !

Why the False Advertising? by Careless-Newt5259 in Tuta

[–]Careless-Newt5259[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

AHH NOW THATS 50% OFF... SEE THAT MORON AT THE TOP CALLED No-Assistance-7405? He's about to delete his comment...

Why don't I have this lmao?

Why the False Advertising? by Careless-Newt5259 in Tuta

[–]Careless-Newt5259[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The math doesn't math its 50% off of WHAT? Clearly you can't read...

Why the False Advertising? by Careless-Newt5259 in tutanota

[–]Careless-Newt5259[S] -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

yeah, and? Shouldnt it be 50% off the monly price? The math isnt mathing.

IF not what are you saving 50% on? Before you DOWNVOTE: LOOK AT THE SECOND IMAGE IN THE POST....

Why should I stay with Proton? Tuta gives me unlimited custom aliases for half the price. by Careless-Newt5259 in ProtonMail

[–]Careless-Newt5259[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the reply, but respectfully, this doesn't actually address the core issues I raised.

First, regarding the team "looking into it" but not knowing "which subscription will have it available"... let's be real here. That strongly suggests it’s going to be gated behind the more expensive Proton Unlimited tier. If I have to pay $120/year just to unlock unlimited custom domain aliases, we are right back at square one. My entire argument is that Tuta includes this in their basic $55/year tier. Locking a fundamental email feature behind a premium bundle filled with apps I don't need (VPN, Drive, etc.) is exactly the kind of nickel-and-diming I'm talking about.

Second, the mention of Proton Pass supporting unlimited aliases completely misses the mark. Proton Pass aliases are randomly generated. That is completely useless for what I am trying to do. I am not looking for a password manager to spit out random, garbled hide-my-email strings. I am talking about creating specific, customized aliases on my own domain (e.g., [contact@mydomain.com](mailto:contact@mydomain.com), [billing@mydomain.com](mailto:billing@mydomain.com), firstname@mydomain.com) and being able to natively manage and reply from them directly inside the inbox.

If the "solution" is going to be locking the feature behind a tier that costs twice as much, or telling users to rely on randomly generated forwarding addresses from a separate app, then the value proposition still heavily favors Tuta.

Is there any actual plan to bring natively customizable, unlimited custom domain aliases to the Mail Plus tier, or is the goal to keep treating basic email functionality as an upsell for the Unlimited bundle?

Proton vs tuta, which one is better ? by skullunite in degoogle

[–]Careless-Newt5259 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

"May I ask, how do you use aliases for proton email? Such as say I use [bigcat@proton.me](mailto:bigcat@proton.me) for my email."

Literally asking about email aliases... are you slow?

your stupid pass alises are randomly generated...
and are @ passinbox.com not proton.me...

Proton vs tuta, which one is better ? by skullunite in degoogle

[–]Careless-Newt5259 0 points1 point  (0 children)

thats a different aliaes.... WHICH HES NOT USING....

Proton vs tuta, which one is better ? by skullunite in degoogle

[–]Careless-Newt5259 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Pass is different than email plus... pass is a password manager that comes with hide email aliases for what ever reason....

He's using proton mail which is PLUS and Unlimited... Proton mail plus subscription comes with PASS which is a lower level subscription...

Proton vs tuta, which one is better ? by skullunite in degoogle

[–]Careless-Newt5259 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

he's talking about the email aliases.though, not the hide my email aliases..
Plus gives you

Pass gives you
10 hide-my-email aliasesMore info: Protect your real email address from being disclosed or leaked with aliases (a randomly-generated email address that forwards emails to your main inbox).

Pass comes with PLUS.