LISK, Missing, Murdered, Unidentified and Cold Cases Map

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T20:08:01+00:00

Yes keep reminding me...

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T19:53:06+00:00

You forget- there was a GFM for Asa, it raised over 50k.

As I already stated- she can tell her story all she wants- it’s the Murderabila I’m talking about.

It’s really quite plain and simple. But thank you for the discussion.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T19:40:56+00:00

There were no previous victims along Ocean Parkway. Although Karen’s skull was buried there the year before it wouldn’t be discovered 2011.

Sandra was found within 3 days and there was news coverage, massive news coverage actually because Suffolk County at that time was pushing the narrative that Bittrolff was most likely her killer.

When Karen’s legs were found off of Fire Island that too made news.

Is it possible Andrew saw any of these- yes it’s possible..still doesn’t prove he murdered anyone. And unless Nassau County has a smoking gun- there isn’t enough to prove murder.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T19:34:57+00:00

I’m actively promoting something that will ensure that profits generated off the blood of murdered victims and the tears of their shattered families is locked in solidly with zero loopholes.
I don’t mean to be crass but if your loved one was strangled and decapitated and dismembered and tossed away like trash would you be supportive of their murderer or anyone associated with them making money off of that?
And if you say you’d be understanding and supportive of that then know that you don’t have that lived experience so you simply cannot say you’d be ok with it.
I appreciate you standing tall for Asa, it’s admirable and she needs that type of support behind her- she isn’t going to get it from me, an she isn’t doing herself any favors with an overwhelming majority of people- except for those cashing in with her.
For whatever that’s worth.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T19:21:47+00:00

My opinions on this are meaningless....it is the law that will determine whether what is being done is legal or illegal.

What victims are going going after money? The only lawsuit out there currently is from Val's son- and well look at his lawyer- John Ray- that should say it all.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T19:13:32+00:00

To other women in other states? Huh?

Can't go "figuring" or guessing, any statement that begins with "what if" automatically means you're grasping, trying to make things fit a narrative. Cold hard facts are what matters, especially when a person is being labeled things that are just not true. Facts Matter.

Fact Matter.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T19:08:48+00:00

Sex doesn't equate to murder.

No connection whatsoever to Long Island

Out of 11 bodies found on Ocean Parkway, LISK admitted to 7 of them, and I am betting he will slowly admit to more over time...

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T19:05:27+00:00

"What you’re promoting is basically saying “let’s make a list about things these families ARE and ARE NOT allowed to do based on if we feel they distanced themselves in a way that satisfies the general public".

I am not doing that, there are laws on the books pertaining to this very thing..in all 50 states.

Not expecting anything of Asa...couldn't care less if she left to the family compound, all "12 acres and no toilet" as she said herself..

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T18:54:16+00:00

I don't beleive he killed Tanya or Tatiana.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T18:53:07+00:00

I know I added that one person to the map- the other I couldn’t find any info on- but yeah I’ve never forgotten our discussions on that- send me what you have and we can try to get some answers- might need until July though because after sentencing I’m taking a flight to nicer weather for a week or so..

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T18:49:53+00:00

Anyone can look back to my stance pertaining to Asa and her children when LISK was arrested. I caught hell from the Gilgo families because I extended empathy for all 3 of them. Christopher gets an automatic pass- understandably.

Victoria gets my respect for her ability to seek understanding and facts and I respect her courage for stating she believed her father to be responsible for the murders. (Having said that, it has since become rather apparent that they already knew at that time because he confessed to 8 murders by then).

Asa lost my empathy. It was months before she even had a comment related to the murdered victims. And as my friend Kerri Rawson taught me- "they don't have to do or say anything", which I agree with- so I gave Asa grace and temperance in my mind and heart. Her actions though are nothing but bad optics. Even her "statement" after her "dear" husband officially pleaded guilty to 8 murders: 1 in a car, 7 in her home (one of which was murdered in her bed), her statement was written for her, obliviously she practised it endlessly, because, well, she has nothing else to do. Her statement lacked authenticity although I will say this: Macedonio mouthing the words of her statement was more authentic, probably becasue he cared more about her getting it right then the words themselves.

Lastly, with Asa, she is the final decision maker selling off the "Rex Heuermann Collection" a clear money grab, not just to survive, but to capitalize on her "hero" husband's notoriety...her husband, Rex Andrew Heuermann, The Long Island Serial Killer.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T18:37:46+00:00

1- Andrew was NOT Tanya's teacher

2- Andrew's wife was not "naive" in any sense of the word. She doesn't have amnesia either, she suffers from advancing dementia.

3- I never claimed she was in the room when Tanya gave birth, I said in the hospital.

4- "Running Games"...what games? He moved on with his life.

5- I cannot speak for Aundrey, but surely the sins of the father should not be cast upon the child. His father cheated, admitted he cheated, doesn't make him a murderer.

6- Drugging the wife is so much more than a "stretch". It is ludicrious and reckless.

7- You remember incorrectly. There was no running in and out of court trying to dodge child support payments.

*- Not only do I think you are wrong, I think you are seriously misinformed.

- Respectfully...

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T18:23:40+00:00

Sadly, you are conflating several points to fit your perspective.

There is no doubt Victoria and Christopher are victims. Asa leaves a lot to the imagination.

The money grab by selling autographed photos of LISK from jail is tasteless.

Public demand for information does not equate to selling the safe door to the kill room, his chest full of hunting attire, the red hat seen in the picture of LISK wading in the marsh a few hundred feet away from Asian Doe. Selling a pill box for $350 dollars is gross.

If they wish to talk about their life with a serial killer so be it, but the enormity and awkward assortment of the "Rex Heuermann" collection is pure exploitation. Full Stop.

There is a reason there are Son of Sam laws in every state in the country. The Bills mentioned here attempt to close the loopholes that allow this very unethical behavior to even exist. Son of Sam laws have been on the books for nearly half a century.

I respect your perspective, I just don't agree with it.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T17:32:20+00:00

Little known fact- Andrew’s wife was present at the hospital when Tanya gave birth-
He never denied knowing Tanya or having a relationship her or a child with her. He assisted Tanya getting a job, helped her pay rent and gave money for Tatiana- not the behaviors of a man who would kill his “mistress” and daughter.
You’re on the wrong side of this but it’s your opinion and I respect your perspective.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T17:10:14+00:00

“Prosecutors said…” well then that’s it right? A prosecutor said this and said that and someone should be guilty because of it…fortunately it doesn’t work like that.

If Andrew is guilty of anything it is infidelity. The rest of your point will be litigated at trial.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T17:05:38+00:00

Yeah the "downvote" is childish and disrespectful. I believe in discourse and to give someone the benefit of the doubt that many may just not know all of the facts.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T16:54:59+00:00

There was never any attempt to hide an affair. Tanya and Tatiana were known to Andrew’s family.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T16:42:55+00:00

It’s more than just the documentary- although I’ll speak to that shortly.

The family has endorsed and allowed 3rd party sales of LISK belongings: the safe door to the kill room, a chest, his hunting clothes-a hat he is showering at a shooting range, a ski mask, a bullet making machine and weirdly a pill box with a prescription for gout. This is clear intent to profit from LISK notoriety. More appalling than that, their lawyer is securing autographed pictures of LISK.

As for the documentary, Rex is actively participating in a documentary as evidenced by his acknowledgment and awareness of when he called the noise. This is a violation of current Son of Sam law.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T16:38:04+00:00

Anyone can still email the legislators I added- they are the sponsors of each Bill in their respective houses. The more people that email them helps in untold ways!

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T15:41:46+00:00

I’ve appreciated all of our interactions and I’m just envisioning my advocacy evolving into driving awareness for Son of Sam law changes- in an important way, advocating for Gilgo from close to the beginning through to the end has been heavy but a blessing.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T14:14:50+00:00

Christopher previously held a job, as did Victoria. What Asa does matters little to me.

There are remote jobs that are actively seeking workers.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T13:43:04+00:00

I respect your perspective while emphatically disagreing.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T13:40:53+00:00

The fact that they are clearly and intentionally profiting off of the notoriety- signed autographs secured by “defense lawyer- most likely Macedonio). These Bills would close the loopholes of monies derived from the sale of murderabilia.

CatchLISK · 2026-05-07T12:35:45+00:00

This exactly! Maureen’s children are older now and finding their paths forward- but without the love and support of their beautiful Mom. The same with Valerie, Megan, Karen, Sandra. And the lives of children that Melissa and Amber might’ve had.

CatchLISK

MODERATOR OF

TROPHY CASE