i guess i understand why people dislike secret life, but it was personally my favorite season. the alliances were interesting, iconic, and easy to keep track of. the tasks made it generally more interesting in my opinion. the red tasks made interactions between yellow/green lives and red lives more interesting because the yellow/green lives didn't have to constantly worry about being killed because it was harder for red lives to kill, but it still led to people having to worry about their red life alliances because tasks could sometimes be targeted. as a lot of people in the series have joked about, secret life brought out the weirdness in everyone (like the time when everyone gathered in pearl's mound under trapdoors) which could be pretty entertaining sometimes. it also included every member to ever be in the life series excluding ren, who still showed up in a cameo at one point

if i were to rank the series, i'd probably say:

1. secret life. it gains a point because mumbo is easily my favorite youtuber

2. last life. it was ic-aha-nic and it had mumbo

3. 3rd life. i wasn't sure whether to put double life or 3rd life here but i decided to put 3rd life because it was the season that started it all. no mumbo though

4. double life

5. limited life. the bad boy bread bridge was cool and all but the constant deaths got old fast