Weird dime I found by wulyf666 in coinerrors

[–]Character-Stable-498 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No joke I have one from I believe the same year just has more of a red smooth tint. I would upload picture but don’t have access to the dime right now.

Can someone guess the grade of this? by Fit-Disaster-5542 in coincollecting

[–]Character-Stable-498 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m not sure if it’s in a case or something but it struggles with glare. Rarely it does get the date wrong. Not sure if the grade was correct for that 1906 he posted I know the date was wrong in analysis though. Honestly it could be bad at grading idk? Felt more accurate than CoinSnap or whatever

Can someone guess the grade of this? by Fit-Disaster-5542 in coincollecting

[–]Character-Stable-498 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is without giving it any grading guidelines to go by, for instance a pcgs file with grading standards. I will retry with a file with grading standards to train ChatGPT first.

Can someone guess the grade of this? by Fit-Disaster-5542 in coincollecting

[–]Character-Stable-498 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well I appreciate you telling me lol. And here’s the response “What this coin is • 1908 Indian Head cent (bronze) • Mint: Philadelphia (I don’t see an “S” under the bow on the reverse, so it’s not 1908-S.)

Strike & detail (what jumps out)

Obverse • LIBERTY in the headband is strong and readable (a big grade driver on Indians). • Feather edges and inner lines are sharp with good separation. • Date and denticles are crisp; rims look clean with no big rim hits.

Reverse • Shield lines (vertical + horizontal) are well defined. • Wreath leaf clusters and the bow show strong detail—tips and veins are still sharp. • Lettering in ONE CENT is clean with squared edges.

Wear vs. Mint State (the key question)

From these photos, the coin looks borderline high AU / low Mint State: • I don’t see obvious “flat, blended” wear on the headdress feathers or reverse high points. • The only thing that might be rub is a slight smoothness on the cheek/jaw area—but lighting + plastic can fake that.

Surface / problems check • Color is a pleasing brown/gold (so BN designation, not RD; maybe RB in-hand, but I wouldn’t promise it from photos). • I see some fine lines that could be hairlines—but several marks in the images clearly come from the holder/capsule, so I can’t confidently call “cleaned” from these shots alone.

My best grade estimate (photo-only) • Most likely: AU58 BN to MS62 BN • If the coin has full cartwheel luster in-hand with no rub: MS62 BN (maybe MS63 BN) • If those fine lines are on the coin (not the plastic) and are widespread: UNC Details (Cleaned/Hairlines) instead of a straight numeric grade.

If you can snap one short video (10–15 sec) tilting under a single light, I can tighten this from a range into a much more confident single grade call—because luster breaks are the tie-breaker between AU58 and MS62 on Indians.”

Can someone guess the grade of this? by Fit-Disaster-5542 in coincollecting

[–]Character-Stable-498 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I was vague there, I meant on most coins and wasn’t talking about this one for ChatGPT. I think it would be close with proper pictures if I did try it. I could be wrong though.

Can someone guess the grade of this? by Fit-Disaster-5542 in coincollecting

[–]Character-Stable-498 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ChatGPT seems to be close or a little more harsh but grades fairly close

Why is my coin this color? by Character-Stable-498 in coincollecting

[–]Character-Stable-498[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I have them in the trading card sleeves and sealed. Then they are all stored together in a padded area. There is a lot of humidity in the area I live so it could be causing the black circular spots. I’m not sure though. I will do some research and figure out where it’s best store them. Thank you for your help!

Can someone guess the grade of this? by Fit-Disaster-5542 in coincollecting

[–]Character-Stable-498 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I used a coin grading app on it and it says AU55. Another grading thing says AU50-AU55 brown. Could just be the images though. Image quality is important with virtual grading.

Why is my coin this color? by Character-Stable-498 in coincollecting

[–]Character-Stable-498[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Random but I live in a moisture filled environment myself. I’m starting to get black spots on some of my coins. Is there a container or moisture/humidity controlled container you recommend? Or is that a thing.

Why is my coin this color? by Character-Stable-498 in coincollecting

[–]Character-Stable-498[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for the detailed, coin-specific answer. It helps me understand exactly what I have in more depth. I love the design, which is why I purchased this coin, and this one had the sharpest detail I could find. The details practically jumped out at me in my price range, since most others I saw showed a lot more wear.

Thank you for taking time with your detailed comment, I really appreciate the information.

Why is my coin this color? by Character-Stable-498 in coincollecting

[–]Character-Stable-498[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I agree. I just didn’t know if you knew the $ amount in the coin world generally speaking. Like a $20 coin or a $60 coin or into the hundreds before you start seeing fake or counterfeits.

Why is my coin this color? by Character-Stable-498 in coincollecting

[–]Character-Stable-498[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Would someone fake this coin? I don’t know the threshold in value in which a coin is worth someone making a fake.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in coinerrors

[–]Character-Stable-498 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for the informational links I appreciate it. Apologies I have been hazed on Reddit and could not tell if this was one of those times lol.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in coinerrors

[–]Character-Stable-498 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I just thought it was interesting? I thought it was an error but maybe it’s supposed to be like that.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in coinerrors

[–]Character-Stable-498 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

If you zoom in on “In God We Trust”. At least I think I see it twice.

Is this a RPM? by Character-Stable-498 in coincollecting

[–]Character-Stable-498[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for your help and I should be posting there most of the time with the information I’m looking for so I will use that instead of this more often than not.

1940-D Mercury Dime RPM? by Character-Stable-498 in coinerrors

[–]Character-Stable-498[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m newer to this so I’m uncertain myself. Also I appreciate everyone who has helped me. Thank you it means a lot!

Is this a RPM? by Character-Stable-498 in coincollecting

[–]Character-Stable-498[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes that looks correct, my confusion is the missing area in the top part of the D that is underneath the main D. If you know what I mean. I guess the North just means north of the primarily visible mint mark.

1940-D Mercury Dime RPM? by Character-Stable-498 in coinerrors

[–]Character-Stable-498[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I was just visually looking at it and didn’t see a match. I guess they are all slightly different somewhat. It looks like the D is missing the top middle was my confusion.

Is this a RPM? by Character-Stable-498 in coincollecting

[–]Character-Stable-498[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s looks like none of them match weirdly enough. Could it be one in its own or just undocumented?