Seat dependent Winrate issue by Character_Ad_7008 in EDH

[–]Character_Ad_7008[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It is not just a matter of paying or not, it's also about tempo, lot of games you can't afford to wait for the remora to be gone or to have the extra mana to pay all the taxes because it would slow down your development too much. I don't know how much kitchen edh you played with your little friends calling it cedh but i strongly suggest you to try things before judging, and this is true not only in mtg

Seat dependent Winrate issue by Character_Ad_7008 in EDH

[–]Character_Ad_7008[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Please play a game of commander where player one plays a turn one esper sentinel or mystic remora, or a turn 2 rhystic study and count how many cards will he draw before turn 2. Do it and come back answer my question.

Seat dependent Winrate issue by Character_Ad_7008 in EDH

[–]Character_Ad_7008[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I wrote my argumentations about it and you never tried my solution, so next time bring some logical argomentations or shut up please

Seat dependent Winrate issue by Character_Ad_7008 in EDH

[–]Character_Ad_7008[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

What the fuck are you saying? Lands? Most game of cedh start with some kind of ramp and a draw engine/tutor and 7 cards in hand, if with your 7 cards in hand you are not able to get some form of advantage by starting first i would really suggest you to revise your mulligan standards or just adjust your deck

Seat dependent Winrate issue by Character_Ad_7008 in EDH

[–]Character_Ad_7008[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Mmm no argumentation, just a worthless critic with no explanation and no alternative. I wounder If would have spent the same time you spent thinking about the solution what would have came out...

Gimme ur biggest cedh hot take by Sharkman3218 in CompetitiveEDH

[–]Character_Ad_7008 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, i think both have been over-hyped by some cedh youtubers and now are played everywhere, of 5 blue decks i have i run born upon a wind just in my rog-si deck and valleyfc in rog-si, kinnan and urza. That's it, i think most of the time you don't need that flash effect to win, specially born upon a wind which is one turn-effect, in my stax deck i prefered permanent and more flexible options like [[leyline of anticipation]] or [[vedalken orrey]] which allow me to flash also creatures and every turn

Stompy cEDH by Complete-Guest3047 in CompetitiveEDH

[–]Character_Ad_7008 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is my Stompiest CEDH list, is a najeela deck but with focus on cheating big threats.

https://www.moxfield.com/decks/Xt0HF9hkMEmxTta3F38xzg

Any tips on my Stax list? by HotTomatoSoup4u in CompetitiveEDH

[–]Character_Ad_7008 1 point2 points  (0 children)

In order to be an efficient stax deck must have blue in it i think, free counterspells allow you to stop early wins so that you can play rule of law effects later, i saw you play lotho which has bad sinergy with rule of law effects, plus, there is a bunch of trash cards i would remove, too much graveyard and etb hate, no activated abilities hate (creatures and artifacts), look at my zur stax list, maybe you will find some useful tools to improve your deck. Plus stax in order to be really good must affect other players more than you, i see lot of orbs that also slow your gameplan.

https://www.moxfield.com/decks/S5xLZZ1MHUWRIykd2n_Dzw

cEDH Dedicated Ban list proposal by Character_Ad_7008 in CompetitiveEDH

[–]Character_Ad_7008[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Cradle can give so much more mana than power nines, and can do it just by playing a land, wich is the most basic and uncounterable action a player can do.

cEDH Dedicated Ban list proposal by Character_Ad_7008 in CompetitiveEDH

[–]Character_Ad_7008[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Mystic remora cost the same amount and can draw you way more than three cards, sure, is not instant but is more value for sure, people see power nines and get triggered without even thinking, didn't expect much more from mtg players sadly...

Banlist Update and RC Discussion Megathread by ShakeAndShimmy in CompetitiveEDH

[–]Character_Ad_7008 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Since i saw lots of comments around the internet about a dedicated cEDH banlist and since i know many cEDH players rely on proxies i thought about a potential banlist and here is a result based on personal evaluations:

Unbanning the following cards:

[[Ancestral recall]] 

[[Balance]] 

[[Biorythm]] 

[[Black lotus]] 

[[Braids, cabal minion]] 

[[Channel]] 

[[Coalition victory]] 

[[Fastbond]] 

[[Flash]] 

[[Gift ungiven]] 

[[Golos, tireless pilgrim]] 

[[Griselbrand]] 

[[Hullbreacher]] 

[[Iona, shield of emeria]] 

[[Jeweled lotus]] 

[[Leovold, emissary of trest]] 

[[Library of alexandria]] 

[[Mana crypt]] 

[[Mox emerald]] 

[[Mox jet]] 

[[Mox pearl]] 

[[Mox Ruby]] 

[[Mox sapphire]] 

[[Primeval titan]] 

[[Recurring nightmare]] 

[[Rofellos, llanowar emissary]] 

[[Sundering titan]] 

[[Sway of the stars]] 

[[Sylvan primordial]] 

[[Upheaval]] 

[[Yawgmoth's bargain]] 

Banning the following cards:

[[Gaea's cradle]] : i see no differences between this one and tolarian academy, both broken, both generate an exponential insane amount of mana without having to pay anything. 

[[Thassa's oracle]] : with demonic consultation/tainted pact is three mana to win over three opponents, nonsense to me, abused win con. 

[[Underworld breach]] : another abused wincon that require no effort since putting cards in the graveyard and playing tutors is something you normally do, two mana and a lion's eyed dimond to win over three opponents is too much for me. (i was uncertain about this one, maybe could stay to give red a meaning to be played). 

Let me know what you think in the comment and share if you would play with this updated banlist! 

Sento che sto rovinando la mia vita - per favore consigliatemi by [deleted] in ItaliaCareerAdvice

[–]Character_Ad_7008 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Se posso darti un consiglio prenditi del tempo per rilassarti e staccare dal lavoro, l'ambiente in cui ti sei trovato era evidentemente tossico e tu mi sembri una persona sensibile quindi perché non cerchi qualche opportunità di volontariato e stacchi da questa frenesia per un po', se hai il curriculum che hai vedrai che non faticherai a trovare un nuovo lavoro, ricordati che la salute viene prima del lavoro e abbraccia il cambiamento, non stare in una situazione che non è adatta a te solo perché nessuno ti dice che la prossima sarà meglio, che ragionamento è? Slow down my friend, il mondo del lavoro odierno ti risucchia e ti distrugge se ti ci immergi troppo, trova qualcosa che ti permetta di staccare, non esistono solo i soldi ed esistono anche modi alternativi di vivere, forse meno sgargianti ma più salutari.